Neonicotinoid seed treatments of soybean provide negligible benefits to US farmers

Published on Dec 1, 2019in Scientific Reports4.011
· DOI :10.1038/s41598-019-47442-8
Spyridon Mourtzinis9
Estimated H-index: 9
(UW: University of Wisconsin-Madison),
Christian H. Krupke21
Estimated H-index: 21
(Purdue University)
+ 20 AuthorsShawn P. Conley16
Estimated H-index: 16
(UW: University of Wisconsin-Madison)
Neonicotinoids are the most widely used insecticides worldwide and are typically deployed as seed treatments (hereafter NST) in many grain and oilseed crops, including soybeans. However, there is a surprising dearth of information regarding NST effectiveness in increasing soybean seed yield, and most published data suggest weak, or inconsistent yield benefit. The US is the key soybean-producing nation worldwide and this work includes soybean yield data from 194 randomized and replicated field studies conducted specifically to evaluate the effect of NSTs on soybean seed yield at sites within 14 states from 2006 through 2017. Here we show that across the principal soybean-growing region of the country, there are negligible and management-specific yield benefits attributed to NSTs. Across the entire region, the maximum observed yield benefits due to fungicide (FST = fungicide seed treatment) + neonicotinoid use (FST + NST) reached 0.13 Mg/ha. Across the entire region, combinations of management practices affected the effectiveness of FST + NST to increase yield but benefits were minimal ranging between 0.01 to 0.22 Mg/ha. Despite widespread use, this practice appears to have little benefit for most of soybean producers; across the entire region, a partial economic analysis further showed inconsistent evidence of a break-even cost of FST or FST + NST. These results demonstrate that the current widespread prophylactic use of NST in the key soybean-producing areas of the US should be re-evaluated by producers and regulators alike.
  • References (26)
  • Citations (2)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
27 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Spyridon Mourtzinis (UW: University of Wisconsin-Madison)H-Index: 9
#2Juan I. Rattalino Edreira (NU: University of Nebraska–Lincoln)H-Index: 7
Last. Shawn P. Conley (UW: University of Wisconsin-Madison)H-Index: 16
view all 16 authors...
Abstract Field trials are commonly used to estimate the effects of different factors on crop yields. In the present study, we followed an alternative approach to identify factors that explain field-to-field yield variation, which consisted of farmer survey data, a spatial framework, and multiple statistical procedures. This approach was used to identify management factors with strongest association with on-farm soybean yield variation in the US North Central (NC) region. Field survey data, inclu...
13 CitationsSource
#1Thomas W. Sappington (ARS: Agricultural Research Service)H-Index: 6
#2Louis S. Hesler (ARS: Agricultural Research Service)H-Index: 9
Last. Sharon K. Papiernik (ARS: Agricultural Research Service)H-Index: 25
view all 5 authors...
5 CitationsSource
#1Louis S. Hesler (ARS: Agricultural Research Service)H-Index: 9
#2K. Clint Allen (ARS: Agricultural Research Service)H-Index: 4
Last. Sharon K. Papiernik (ARS: Agricultural Research Service)H-Index: 25
view all 5 authors...
5 CitationsSource
#1Jonas KathageH-Index: 4
#2Pedro Castañera (CSIC: Spanish National Research Council)H-Index: 37
Last. Emilio Rodríguez-CerezoH-Index: 31
view all 5 authors...
8 CitationsSource
#1Sharon K. Papiernik (ARS: Agricultural Research Service)H-Index: 25
#2Thomas W. Sappington (ARS: Agricultural Research Service)H-Index: 30
Last. K. Clint Allen (ARS: Agricultural Research Service)H-Index: 4
view all 5 authors...
4 CitationsSource
#1Juan I. Rattalino Edreira (NU: University of Nebraska–Lincoln)H-Index: 7
#2Spyridon Mourtzinis (UW: University of Wisconsin-Madison)H-Index: 9
Last. Patricio Grassini (NU: University of Nebraska–Lincoln)H-Index: 24
view all 16 authors...
Abstract Identification of causes of gaps between yield potential and producer yields has been restricted to small geographic areas. In the present study, we developed a novel approach for identifying causes of yield gaps over large agricultural areas with diversity in climate and soils. This approach was applied to quantify and explain yield gaps in rainfed and irrigated soybean in the North-Central USA (NC USA) region, which accounts for about one third of soybean global production. Survey dat...
29 CitationsSource
#1Christian H. Krupke (Purdue University)H-Index: 21
#2Adam M. Alford (Purdue University)H-Index: 2
Last. Kelton Welch (Purdue University)H-Index: 1
view all 10 authors...
BACKGROUND A two year, multi-state study was conducted to assess the benefits of using soybean seed treated with the neonicotinoid thiamethoxam to manage soybean aphid in the upper Midwestern US and compare this approach with an integrated pest management (IPM) approach that included monitoring soybean aphids and treating with foliar-applied insecticide only when the economic threshold was reached. Concentrations of thiamethoxam in soybean foliage were also quantified throughout the growing seas...
15 CitationsSource
#1Christian H. Krupke (Purdue University)H-Index: 21
#2Jeffrey D. Holland (Purdue University)H-Index: 10
Last. Brian D. Eitzer (Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station)H-Index: 26
view all 4 authors...
Summary Neonicotinoid insecticides are routinely used as seed treatments on most grain and oilseed crops in the USA, yet the extent and likelihood of spread of insecticide residues during planting has not previously been quantified. Honey bees, Apis mellifera, are highly mobile and highly sensitive to neonicotinoid residues, presenting an opportunity to estimate non-target exposures to neonicotinoids in mobile insects. We measured neonicotinoid dust drift during maize sowing and used sites of ma...
26 CitationsSource
#1Ben A. WoodcockH-Index: 33
#2Nick J. B. IsaacH-Index: 35
Last. Richard F. PywellH-Index: 42
view all 7 authors...
Neonicotinoid as insecticide on oilseed rape can reduce bee colony density, but its effect at a large geographical scale is unclear. This study describes 18-year long wild bee tracking data in England and show neonicotinoid use is correlated with wild bee population declines at real landscape scales.
115 CitationsSource
#1Elizabeth Y. Long (OSU: Ohio State University)H-Index: 10
#2Christian H. Krupke (Purdue University)H-Index: 21
Recent efforts to evaluate the contribution of neonicotinoid insecticides to worldwide pollinator declines have focused on honey bees and the chronic levels of exposure experienced when foraging on crops grown from neonicotinoid-treated seeds. However, few studies address non-crop plants as a potential route of pollinator exposure to neonicotinoid and other insecticides. Here we show that pollen collected by honey bee foragers in maize- and soybean-dominated landscapes is contaminated throughout...
72 CitationsSource
Cited By2
#1Claudia HitajH-Index: 5
#2David J. Smith (USDA: United States Department of Agriculture)H-Index: 18
Last. Margaret R. Douglas (Dickinson College)H-Index: 7
view all 6 authors...
#1Geneviève LabrieH-Index: 3
Last. Gilles TremblayH-Index: 15
view all 5 authors...
#1Robert Brenner (NDSU: North Dakota State University)
#2Deirdre A. Prischmann-Voldseth (NDSU: North Dakota State University)H-Index: 7
#2Ryan S. Prosser (U of G: University of Guelph)H-Index: 9
Last. Nigel E. Raine (U of G: University of Guelph)H-Index: 34
view all 3 authors...
The Common Eastern Bumblebee (Bombus impatiens) is native to North America with an expanding range across Eastern Canada and the USA. This species is commercially produced primarily for greenhouse crop pollination and is a common and abundant component of the wild bumblebee fauna in agricultural, suburban and urban landscapes. However, there is a dearth of pesticide toxicity information about North American bumblebees. The present study determines the acute oral toxicity (48-hour LD50) of cyantr...
#1Margaret R. Douglas (Dickinson College)H-Index: 7
#2Douglas B. Sponsler (PSU: Pennsylvania State University)H-Index: 4
Last. Christina M. Grozinger (PSU: Pennsylvania State University)H-Index: 36
view all 4 authors...
Each year, millions of kilograms of insecticides are applied to crops in the US. While insecticide use supports food, fuel, and fiber production, it can also threaten non-target organisms, a concern underscored by mounting evidence of widespread decline of pollinator populations. Here, we integrate several public datasets to generate county-level annual estimates of total ‘bee toxic load’ (honey bee lethal doses) for insecticides applied in the US between 1997–2012, calculated separately for ora...
2 CitationsSource