Did Einstein really say that? Testing content versus context in the cultural selection of quotations.

Published on Aug 13, 2018in Journal of Cognition and Culture
· DOI :10.1163/15685373-12340032
Alberto Acerbi15
Estimated H-index: 15
(TU/e: Eindhoven University of Technology),
Jamshid J. Tehrani11
Estimated H-index: 11
(Durham University)
We experimentally investigated the influence of context-based biases, such as prestige and popularity, on the preferences for quotations. Participants were presented with random quotes associated to famous or unknown authors (experiment one), or with random quotes presented as popular, i.e. chosen by many previous participants, or unpopular (experiment two). To exclude effects related to the content of the quotations, all participants were subsequently presented with the same quotations, again associated to famous and unknown authors (experiment three), or presented as popular or unpopular (experiment four). Overall, our results showed that context-based biases had no (in case of prestige and conformity), or limited (in case of popularity), effect in determining participants’ choices. Quotations preferred for their content were preferred in general, despite the contextual cues to which they were associated. We conclude discussing how our results fit with the well-known phenomenon of the spread and success (especially digital) of misattributed quotations, and we draw some more general implications for cultural evolution research.
  • References (26)
  • Citations (1)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
5 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Sébastien Lerique (EHESS: School for Advanced Studies in the Social Sciences)H-Index: 2
#2Camille Roth (Sciences Po)H-Index: 2
We present an empirical case study which connects psycholinguistics with the field of cultural evolution, in order to test for the existence of cultural attractors in the evolution of quotations. Such attractors have been proposed as a useful concept for understanding cultural evolution in relation with individual cognition, but their existence has been hard to test. We focus on the transformation of quotations when they are copied from blog to blog or media website: by coding words with a numbe...
2 CitationsSource
#1Joseph M. Stubbersfield (Durham University)H-Index: 4
#2Jamshid J. Tehrani (Durham University)H-Index: 11
Last. Emma Flynn (Durham University)H-Index: 23
view all 3 authors...
This study used urban legends to examine the effects of a cognitive bias for content which evokes higher levels of emotion on cumulative recall. As with previous research into content biases, a linear transmission chain design was used. One-hundred and twenty participants, aged 16–52, were asked to read and then recall urban legends that provoked both high levels and low levels of emotion and were both positively and negatively valenced. The product of this recall was presented to the next parti...
9 CitationsSource
#1Keely Bebbington (UWA: University of Western Australia)H-Index: 3
#2Colin MacLeod (UWA: University of Western Australia)H-Index: 46
Last. Nicolas Fay (UWA: University of Western Australia)H-Index: 17
view all 4 authors...
Abstract The method of serial reproduction has revealed that the social transmission of information is characterized by the gradual transformation of the original message. This transformation results from the preferential survival of certain types of information and the resolution of ambiguity. Here we present evidence of a bias favoring the social transmission of negatively-valenced information across multiple transmission episodes. Ninety-two, four-person chains transmitted a story containing ...
30 CitationsSource
#1Lara A. Wood (St And: University of St Andrews)H-Index: 9
#2Rachel A. Harrison (St And: University of St Andrews)H-Index: 4
Last. Andrew Whiten (St And: University of St Andrews)H-Index: 67
view all 6 authors...
Abstract Theoretical models of social learning predict that individuals can benefit from using strategies that specify when and whom to copy. Here the interaction of two social learning strategies, model age-based biased copying and copy when uncertain , was investigated. Uncertainty was created via a systematic manipulation of demonstration efficacy (completeness) and efficiency (causal relevance of some actions). The participants, 4- to 6-year-old children ( N = 140), viewed both an adult mode...
12 CitationsSource
#1Alberto Acerbi (TU/e: Eindhoven University of Technology)H-Index: 15
#2Claudio Tennie (University of Birmingham)H-Index: 18
Last. Alex Mesoudi (University of Exeter)H-Index: 32
view all 3 authors...
The extensive use of social learning is considered a major reason for the ecological success of humans. Theoretical considerations, models and experiments have explored the evolutionary basis of social learning, showing the conditions under which learning from others is more adaptive than individual learning. Here we present an extension of a previous experimental set-up, in which individuals go on simulated ‘hunts’ and their success depends on the features of a ‘virtual arrowhead’ they design. ...
7 CitationsSource
#1Amy Z. YuH-Index: 4
#2Shahar RonenH-Index: 5
Last. César A. HidalgoH-Index: 22
view all 5 authors...
We present the Pantheon 1.0 dataset: a manually verified dataset of individuals that have transcended linguistic, temporal, and geographic boundaries. The Pantheon 1.0 dataset includes the 11,341 biographies present in more than 25 languages in Wikipedia and is enriched with: (i) manually verified demographic information (place and date of birth, gender) (ii) a taxonomy of occupations classifying each biography at three levels of aggregation and (iii) two measures of global popularity including ...
19 CitationsSource
#1Thomas J. H. Morgan (St And: University of St Andrews)H-Index: 8
#2Kevin N. Laland (St And: University of St Andrews)H-Index: 77
Last. Paul L. Harris (Harvard University)H-Index: 65
view all 3 authors...
Human culture relies on extensive use of social transmission, which must be integrated with independently acquired (i.e. asocial) information for effective decision-making. Formal evolutionary theory predicts that natural selection should favor adaptive learning strategies, including a bias to copy when uncertain, and a bias to disproportionately copy the majority (known as ‘conformist transmission’). Although the function and causation of these evolved strategies has been comparatively well stu...
40 CitationsSource
#1Maria Priestley (Durham University)H-Index: 1
#2Alex Mesoudi (Durham University)H-Index: 32
Online votes or ratings can assist internet users in evaluating the credibility and appeal of the information which they encounter. For example, aggregator websites such as Reddit allow users to up-vote submitted content to make it more prominent, and down-vote content to make it less prominent. Here we argue that decisions over what to up- or down-vote may be guided by evolved features of human cognition. We predict that internet users should be more likely to up-vote content that others have a...
7 CitationsSource
#1Joseph M. Stubbersfield (Durham University)H-Index: 4
#2Jamshid J. Tehrani (Durham University)H-Index: 11
Last. Emma Flynn (Durham University)H-Index: 23
view all 3 authors...
This study uses urban legends to examine the effects of the social information bias and survival information bias on cultural transmission across three phases of transmission: the choose-to-receive phase, the encode-and-retrieve phase, and the choose-to-transmit phase. In line with previous research into content biases, a linear transmission chain design with 60 participants aged 18–52 was used to examine the encode-and-retrieve phase, while participants were asked to rank their interest in read...
29 CitationsSource
#1Nicolas Claidière (St And: University of St Andrews)H-Index: 17
#2Mark Bowler (St And: University of St Andrews)H-Index: 16
Last. Andrew Whiten (St And: University of St Andrews)H-Index: 67
view all 5 authors...
Conformity is thought to be an important force in human evolution because it has the potential to stabilize cultural homogeneity within groups and cultural diversity between groups. However, the effects of such conformity on cultural and biological evolution will depend much on the particular way in which individuals are influenced by the frequency of alternative behavioral options they witness. In a previous study we found that in a natural situation people displayed a tendency to be ‘linear-co...
11 CitationsSource
Cited By1
#1Azita Chellappoo (University of Cambridge)
Some cultural evolution researchers have argued for the importance of prestige bias as a systematic and widespread social learning bias, that structures human social learning and cultural transmission patterns. Broadly speaking, prestige bias accounts understand it as a bias towards copying ‘prestigious’ individuals (which are typically described as high-status, due to a high level of skill or success in a socially valued domain, and so are treated by others with respect and deference). Prestige...
#1Theiss Bendixen (AU: Aarhus University)H-Index: 1
#1Ángel V. Jiménez (University of Exeter)H-Index: 1
#2Alex Mesoudi (University of Exeter)H-Index: 32
Cultural evolution theory posits that a major factor in human ecological success is our high-fidelity and selective social learning, which permits the accumulation of adaptive knowledge and skills over successive generations. One way to acquire adaptive social information is by preferentially copying competent individuals within a valuable domain (success bias). However, competence within a domain is often difficult or impossible to directly assess. Almost 20 years ago, Henrich and Gil-White (H&...
4 CitationsSource