A teleofunctional account of evolutionary mismatch

Published on Jul 1, 2016in Biology and Philosophy1.593
· DOI :10.1007/s10539-016-9527-1
Nathan Cofnas5
Estimated H-index: 5
(University of Cambridge)
When the environment in which an organism lives deviates in some essential way from that to which it is adapted, this is described as “evolutionary mismatch,” or “evolutionary novelty.” The notion of mismatch plays an important role, explicitly or implicitly, in evolution-informed cognitive psychology, clinical psychology, and medicine. The evolutionary novelty of our contemporary environment is thought to have significant implications for our health and well-being. However, scientists have generally been working without a clear definition of mismatch. This paper defines mismatch as deviations in the environment that render biological traits unable, or impaired in their ability, to produce their selected effects (i.e., to perform their proper functions in Neander’s sense). The machinery developed by Millikan in connection with her account of proper function, and with her related teleosemantic account of representation, is used to identify four major types, and several subtypes, of evolutionary mismatch. While the taxonomy offered here does not in itself resolve any scientific debates, the hope is that it can be used to better formulate empirical hypotheses concerning the effects of mismatch. To illustrate, it is used to show that the controversial hypothesis that general intelligence evolved as an adaptation to handle evolutionary novelty can, contra some critics, be formulated in a conceptually coherent way.
  • References (32)
  • Citations (8)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
1 Author (Rick Morris)
6 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Justin GarsonH-Index: 14
Introduction 1. Altruism and Egoism 2. Designed for Altruism 3. Evolution and Psychology 4. Nature and Nurture 5. Consciousness, Reduction, and the Brain 6. The Neuroscience of Free Will 7. How the Mind Makes Meaning 8. Psychiatry and the Mismatched Mind. Index
16 Citations
#1Edward Dutton (University of Oulu)H-Index: 8
Abstract Kanazawa (2012b) has recently presented the most comprehensive case yet for his Savanna-IQ Interaction Hypothesis. According to the hypothesis, intelligence is a domain-specific adaptation which has been selected for as humans have moved away from the (evolutionarily familiar) Savanna. As such, ability in ‘evolutionarily novel’ tasks and ‘evolutionarily novel’ preferences are positively correlated with high IQ. This article will present a critical examination of the hypothesis, arguing ...
7 CitationsSource
#1Laurence M. Cook (University of Manchester)H-Index: 30
#2Bruce Grant (W&M: College of William & Mary)H-Index: 14
Last. James Mallet (Harvard University)H-Index: 68
view all 4 authors...
Colour variation in the peppered moth Biston betularia was long accepted to be under strong natural selection. Melanics were believed to be fitter than pale morphs because of lower predation at daytime resting sites on dark, sooty bark. Melanics became common during the industrial revolution, but since 1970 there has been a rapid reversal, assumed to have been caused by predators selecting against melanics resting on today's less sooty bark. Recently, these classical explanations of melanism wer...
91 CitationsSource
#1Kim SterelnyH-Index: 37
A new theory of the evolution of human cognition and human social life that emphasizes the role of information sharing across generations.Over the last three million years or so, our lineage has diverged sharply from those of our great ape relatives. Change has been rapid (in evolutionary terms) and pervasive. Morphology, life history, social life, sexual behavior, and foraging patterns have all shifted sharply away from those of the other great apes. In The Evolved Apprentice, Kim Sterelny argu...
220 Citations
#1Lars PenkeH-Index: 34
#2Denny Borsboom (UvA: University of Amsterdam)H-Index: 51
Last. Jelte M. Wicherts (UvA: University of Amsterdam)H-Index: 39
view all 6 authors...
Evolutionary psychologists search for human universals, differential psychologists for variation around common human themes. So far, evolutionary psychology and differential psychology seem somewhat disparate and unconnected, although Kanazawa (May–June 2010) is certainly not the first to attempt integrating them (see Penke, 2010, and references therein). Kanazawa uses intelligence to elaborate his view of integration. His evolutionary theory of intelligence is based on two assumptions: (1) Gene...
17 CitationsSource
#1Satoshi Kanazawa (LSE: London School of Economics and Political Science)H-Index: 33
The origin of values and preferences is an unresolved theoretical question in behavioral and social sciences. The Savanna-IQ Interaction Hypothesis, derived from the Savanna Principle and a theory of the evolution of general intelligence, suggests that more intelligent individuals may be more likely to acquire and espouse evolutionarily novel values and preferences (such as liberalism and atheism and, for men, sexual exclusivity) than less intelligent individuals, but that general intelligence m...
111 CitationsSource
#1Jaime C. Confer (University of Texas at Austin)H-Index: 5
#2Judith A. Easton (University of Texas at Austin)H-Index: 8
Last. David M. Buss (University of Texas at Austin)H-Index: 82
view all 7 authors...
Evolutionary psychology has emerged over the past 15 years as a major theoretical perspective, generating an increasing volume of empirical studies and assuming a larger presence within psychological science. At the same time, it has generated critiques and remains controversial among some psychologists. Some of the controversy stems from hypotheses that go against traditional psychological theories; some from empirical findings that may have disturbing implications; some from misunderstandings ...
251 CitationsSource
#1Deirdre BarrettH-Index: 15
Our instincts-for food, sex, or territorial protection- evolved for life on the savannahs 10,000 years ago, not in today's world of densely populated cities, technological innovations, and pollution. We now have access to a glut of larger-than-life objects, from candy to pornography to atomic weapons-that gratify these gut instincts with often-dangerous results. Animal biologists coined the term "supernormal stimuli" to describe imitations that appeal to primitive instincts and exert a stronger ...
44 Citations
#1Debra Lieberman (UCSB: University of California, Santa Barbara)H-Index: 17
#2John Tooby (UCSB: University of California, Santa Barbara)H-Index: 59
Last. Leda Cosmides (UCSB: University of California, Santa Barbara)H-Index: 63
view all 3 authors...
How did humans learn who they are related to, to avoid inbreeding and mate with someone outside their family? This paper proposes that humans use evidence from their environment to compute a 'kinship index' and use it to estimate genetic relatedness to another human.
357 CitationsSource
#1Deirdre BarrettH-Index: 15
2 Citations
Cited By8
#1Nathan Cofnas (Balliol College)H-Index: 5
Thaler and Sunstein advocate ‘libertarian paternalism’. A libertarian paternalist changes the conditions under which people act so that their cognitive biases lead them to choose what is best for themselves. Although libertarian paternalism manipulates people, Thaler and Sunstein say that it respects their autonomy by preserving the possibility of choice. Conly argues that libertarian paternalism does not go far enough, since there is no compelling reason why we should allow people the opportuni...
In a trilogy of books, Kevin MacDonald argues that Judaism is a “group evolutionary strategy.” According to his theory, Jews are genetically and culturally adapted to advance their own group interests at the expense of gentiles. Several influential twentieth-century liberal intellectual and political movements were designed by Jews to promote separatism and group continuity among themselves while undermining gentile society. According to Cofnas [Human Nature, 29, 134–156, 2018], MacDonald’s argu...
#1Marco Del Giudice (UNM: University of New Mexico)H-Index: 26
#2C. Loren Buck (NAU: Northern Arizona University)H-Index: 8
Last. Haruka Wada (AU: Auburn University)H-Index: 18
view all 8 authors...
: The term "stress" is used to describe important phenomena at multiple levels of biological organization, but finding a general and rigorous definition of the concept has proven challenging. Current models in the behavioral literature emphasize the cognitive aspects of stress, which is said to occur when threats to the organism are perceived as uncontrollable and/or unpredictable. Here we adopt the perspective of systems biology and take a step toward a general definition of stress by unpacking...
4 CitationsSource
#1Rick Morris (UC: University of California)
#1Riley Bove (UCSF: University of California, San Francisco)H-Index: 18
Author(s): Bove, Riley M | Abstract: The goal of this review is to apply an evolutionary lens to understanding the origins of multiple sclerosis (MS), integrating three broad observations. First, only humans are known to develop MS spontaneously. Second, humans have evolved large brains, with characteristically large amounts of metabolically costly myelin. This myelin is generated over long periods of neurologic development-and peak MS onset coincides with the end of myelination. Third, over the...
#1Edward DuttonH-Index: 8
#2Dimitri van der Linden (EUR: Erasmus University Rotterdam)H-Index: 24
We present three models which attempt to explain the robust negative association between religion and intelligence: the Irrationality of Religion Model, the Cultural Mediation Hypothesis, and the Savanna-IQ Interaction Hypothesis. We highlight problems with each of them and propose that the negative religion-IQ nexus can be understood through substantially revising the Savanna-IQ Interaction Hypothesis. We argue that religion should be regarded as an evolved domain or instinct. Intelligence, by ...
10 CitationsSource
#1Annie SwanepoelH-Index: 2
#2Graham MusicH-Index: 6
Last. Michael J. ReissH-Index: 2
view all 4 authors...
SUMMARY We argue that current debates about attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) can be considered afresh using an evolutionary lens. We show how the symptoms of ADHD can often be considered adaptive to their specific environment. We suggest that, from an evolutionary point of view, ADHD symptoms might be understood to result from an ‘evolutionary mismatch’, in which current environmental demands do not fit with what evolution has prepared us to cope with. For example, in our ancestra...
2 CitationsSource
#1Nathan Cofnas (University of Cambridge)H-Index: 5
In 1965, Konrad Lorenz grounded the innate–acquired distinction in what he believed were the only two possible sources of information that can underlie adaptedness: phylogenetic and individual experience. Phylogenetic experience accumulates in the genome by the process of natural selection. Individual experience is acquired ontogenetically through interacting with the environment during the organism's lifetime. According to Lorenz, the adaptive information underlying innate traits is stored in t...
1 CitationsSource