Evidence from randomised controlled trials did not support the introduction of dietary fat guidelines in 1977 and 1983: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Published on Jan 1, 2015
· DOI :10.1136/openhrt-2014-000196
Zoë Harcombe7
Estimated H-index: 7
(University of the West of Scotland),
Julien S. Baker31
Estimated H-index: 31
(University of the West of Scotland)
+ 4 AuthorsFergal M. Grace18
Estimated H-index: 18
(University of the West of Scotland)
Objectives: National dietary guidelines were introduced in 1977 and 1983, by the US and UK governments, respectively, with the ambition of reducing coronary heart disease (CHD) by reducing fat intake. To date, no analysis of the evidence base for these recommendations has been undertaken. The present study examines the evidence from randomised controlled trials (RCTs) available to the US and UK regulatory committees at their respective points of implementation. Methods: A systematic review and meta-analysis were undertaken of RCTs, published prior to 1983, which examined the relationship between dietary fat, serum cholesterol and the development of CHD. Results: 2467 males participated in six dietary trials: five secondary prevention studies and one including healthy participants. There were 370 deaths from allcause mortality in the intervention and control groups. The risk ratio (RR) from meta-analysis was 0.996 (95% CI 0.865 to 1.147). There were 207 and 216 deaths from CHD in the intervention and control groups, respectively. The RR was 0.989 (95% CI 0.784 to 1.247). There were no differences in all-cause mortality and non-significant differences in CHD mortality, resulting from the dietary interventions. The reductions in mean serum cholesterol levels were significantly higher in the intervention groups; this did not result in significant differences in CHD or all-cause mortality. Government dietary fat recommendations were untested in any trial prior to being introduced. Conclusions: Dietary recommendations were introduced for 220 million US and 56 million UK citizens by 1983, in the absence of supporting evidence from RCTs.
Figures & Tables
  • References (28)
  • Citations (84)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
650 Citations
766 Citations
384 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Julian P. T. Higgins (UoB: University of Bristol)H-Index: 99
#2Sally Green (UCL: University College London)H-Index: 50
The Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions is the official document that describes in detail the process of preparing and maintaining Cochrane systematic reviews on the effects of healthcare interventions.
7,644 Citations
#1Guillermo CarrilloH-Index: 15
Last. Rosario Pérez-ChaviraH-Index: 5
view all 3 authors...
88 Citations
Primary Funding Source: British Heart Foundation, Medical Research Council, Cambridge National Institute for Health Research Biomedical Research Centre, and Gates Cambridge.
650 CitationsSource
#1James J. DiNicolantonio (Ithaca College)H-Index: 27
A recent publication by Malhotra1 was refreshing, inspiring and hit on an important topic that has been heavily debated for over 50 years, that is, are saturated fats as bad as we have been led to believe? The vilification of saturated fat by Keys2 began two decades before the seven countries study, where Keys showed a curvilinear association between fat calories as a percentage of total calories and death from degenerative heart disease from six countries. However, he excluded data from 16 coun...
32 CitationsSource
#1Jpt HigginsH-Index: 1
#2S. R. GreenH-Index: 1
Last. Julian P. T. HigginsH-Index: 99
view all 3 authors...
4,281 Citations
#1Jonathan A C Sterne (UoB: University of Bristol)H-Index: 91
#2Alex J. Sutton (University of Leicester)H-Index: 85
Last. Julian P. T. Higgins (UoB: University of Bristol)H-Index: 99
view all 19 authors...
Funnel plots, and tests for funnel plot asymmetry, have been widely used to examine bias in the results of meta-analyses. Funnel plot asymmetry should not be equated with publication bias, because it has a number of other possible causes. This article describes how to interpret funnel plot asymmetry, recommends appropriate tests, and explains the implications for choice of meta-analysis model
1,828 CitationsSource
#1Dariush Mozaffarian (Harvard University)H-Index: 120
#2Renata Micha (Harvard University)H-Index: 40
Last. Sarah K. Wallace (Harvard University)H-Index: 3
view all 3 authors...
Background: Reduced saturated fat (SFA) consumption is recommended to reduce coronary heart disease (CHD), but there is an absence of strong supporting evidence from randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of clinical CHD events and few guidelines focus on any specific replacement nutrient. Additionally, some public health groups recommend lowering or limiting polyunsaturated fat (PUFA) consumption, a major potential replacement for SFA. Methods and Findings: We systematically investigated and quant...
675 CitationsSource
#1David Moher (Ottawa Hospital Research Institute)H-Index: 100
#2Alessandro Liberati (University of Birmingham)H-Index: 45
Last. Douglas G. Altman (University of Oxford)H-Index: 209
view all 4 authors...
30.8k CitationsSource
Questions: Does the PEDro scale measure only one construct ie, the methodological quality of clinical trials? What is the hierarchy of items of the PEDro scale from least to most adhered to? Is there any effect of year of publication of trials on item adherence? Are PEDro scale ordinal scores equivalent to interval data? Design: Rasch analysis of two independent samples of 100 clinical trials from the PEDro database scored using the PEDro scale. Results: Both samples of PEDro data showed fit to ...
573 CitationsSource
#1Lee HooperH-Index: 54
Last. Shah B. J. Ebrahim Dm FrcpH-Index: 127
view all 8 authors...
Objective To assess the effect of reduction or modification of dietary fat intake on total and cardiovascular mortality and cardiovascular morbidity. Design Systematic review. Data sources Cochrane Library, Medline, Embase, CAB abstracts, SIGLE, CVRCT registry, and biographies were searched; trials known to experts were included. Included studies Randomised controlled trials stating intention to reduce or modify fat or cholesterol intake in healthy adult participants over at least six months. In...
309 CitationsSource
Cited By84
The American Heart Association (AHA) recently published a meta-analysis that confirmed their 60-year-old recommendation to limit saturated fat (SFA, saturated fatty acid) and replace it with polyunsaturated fat to reduce the risk of heart disease based on the strength of 4 Core Trials. To assess the evidence for this recommendation, meta-analyses on the effect of SFA consumption on heart disease outcomes were reviewed. Nineteen meta-analyses addressing this topic were identified: 9 observational...
#1Tara Kelly (NUI: National University of Ireland)
#2David J. UnwinH-Index: 1
Last. Francis M. Finucane (NUI: National University of Ireland)H-Index: 21
view all 3 authors...
Low-carbohydrate diets are increasingly used to help patients with obesity and type 2 diabetes. We sought to provide an overview of the evidence for this treatment approach, considering the epidemiology and pathophysiology of obesity and diabetes in terms of carbohydrate excess. We describe the mechanistic basis for the clinical benefits associated with nutritional ketosis and identify areas of practice where the evidence base could be improved. We summarize the key principles which inform our a...
#1Pavel Grasgruber (Masaryk University)H-Index: 3
view all 2 authors...
Abstract Height is one of the most sensitive indicators of well-being because it combines the external influences of nutrition, economic wealth, health care, social equality, and other important socio-economic factors. The aim of this ecological study was to compare actual values of male and female height from 152 populations (except sub-Saharan Africa) with the mean supply of 47 food items from the FAOSTAT database (1995-2013) and mean values of seven socio-economic indicators (1995-2013). This...
#1Jean-Marie Bard (University of Nantes)H-Index: 28
#2Ludovic Drouet (French Institute of Health and Medical Research)H-Index: 41
Last. Christine Bobin-Dubigeon (University of Nantes)H-Index: 11
view all 10 authors...
Milk has a specific saturated fatty acid profile and its calcium content may change the kinetics of fat absorption. The goal of this study was to compare the effect on LDL Cholesterol and other risk markers of four isolipidic diets differing by their fat food source, vegetable fat, spring milk fat, winter milk fat or winter milk fat supplemented with calcium, in healthy moderately hypercholesterolemic humans. This double-blind, randomized trial with four parallel arms included 172 healthy adults...
#1Julie A. LovegroveH-Index: 43
CVD remains the greatest cause of death globally, and with the escalating prevalence of metabolic diseases, including type-2 diabetes, CVD mortality is predicted to rise. While the replacement of SFA has been the cornerstone of effective dietary recommendations to decrease CVD risk since the 1980s, the validity of these recommendations have been recently challenged. A review of evidence for the impact of SFA reduction revealed no effect on CVD mortality, but a significant reduction in risk of CV...
#1Blair J. O'Neill (U of A: University of Alberta)H-Index: 18
#2Paolo Raggi (U of A: University of Alberta)H-Index: 54
Last. Paolo Raggi (U of A: University of Alberta)H-Index: 19
view all 2 authors...
Abstract Diets have been at the center of animated debates for decades and many claims have been made in one direction or the other by supporters of opposite camps, often with limited evidence. At times emphasis has been put on a single new aspect that the previous diets had overlooked and the new one was to embrace in order to improve weight loss and well-being. Unfortunately, very few randomized clinical trials involving diets have addressed the combined question of weight loss and cardiovascu...
3 CitationsSource
#1Rade Vukovic (University of Belgrade)H-Index: 5
#2Aleksandra Zeljkovic (University of Belgrade)H-Index: 12
Last. Jelena Vekic (University of Belgrade)H-Index: 12
view all 6 authors...
Hashimoto autoimmune thyroiditis (AIT) is the most common cause of acquired hypothyroidism in the pediatric population. Development of AIT is mediated mainly by cellular immune response directed toward thyroid autoantigens, leading to inflammation and impaired function of thyroid gland. Both thyroid dysfunction and inflammation affect the metabolism of plasma lipoproteins. The alterations in lipid profile worsen with the advancement of hypothyroidism, ranging from discrete changes in euthyroid A...
Objectives The Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition (SACN) and the World Health Organisation (WHO) have recently updated nutritional guidelines for a reduced sugar intake. With the increased popularity of online health-food bloggers and 'refined-sugar free' recipes, this review looked to analyse recipes from popular online bloggers to validate the veracity of their 'sugar-free' and 'healthy' claims and assess their adherence to recently implemented nutritional guidelines. Method Four blogg...
2 CitationsSource
1 CitationsSource