A comparison of land-sharing and land-sparing strategies for plant richness conservation in agricultural landscapes

Published on Mar 1, 2012in Ecological Applications4.378
· DOI :10.1890/11-0206.1
J. Franklin Egan8
Estimated H-index: 8
(PSU: Pennsylvania State University),
David A. Mortensen36
Estimated H-index: 36
(PSU: Pennsylvania State University)
Strategies for conserving plant diversity in agroecosystems generally focus on either expanding land area in non-crop habitat or enhancing diversity within crop fields through changes in within-field management practices. In this study, we compare effects on landscape-scale species richness from such land-sharing or land-sparing strategies. We collected data in arable field, grassland, pasture, and forest habitat types (1.6 ha sampled per habitat type) across a 100-km2 region of farmland in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, USA. We fitted species–area relationships (SARs) for each habitat type and then combined extrapolations from the curves with estimates of community overlap to estimate richness in a 314.5-ha landscape. We then modified these baseline estimates by adjusting parameters in the SAR models to compare potential effects of land-sharing and land-sparing conservation practices on landscape richness. We found that species richness of the habitat types showed a strong inverse relationship to the re...
Figures & Tables
  • References (57)
  • Citations (62)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
4 Authors (Ben Phalan, ..., Rhys E. Green)
806 Citations
4 Authors (Rhys E. Green, ..., Andrew Balmford)
1,253 Citations
428 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Ben Phalan (University of Cambridge)H-Index: 26
#2Andrew Balmford (University of Cambridge)H-Index: 75
Last. Jörn P. W. Scharlemann (United Nations Environment Programme)H-Index: 34
view all 4 authors...
Should farming and conservation policies aim broadly to separate land for nature and land for production (land sparing) or integrate production and conservation on the same land (wildlife-friendly farming)? Most studies that try to address this question suffer from flaws in sampling design, inappropriate metrics, and/or failure to measure biodiversity baselines. We discuss how these failings can be addressed, and what existing information tells us about the key debates on this topic. The evidenc...
184 CitationsSource
#1Sandra Quijas (UNAM: National Autonomous University of Mexico)H-Index: 8
#2Bernhard Schmid (UZH: University of Zurich)H-Index: 86
Last. Patricia Balvanera (UNAM: National Autonomous University of Mexico)H-Index: 35
view all 3 authors...
Biodiversity is known to play a fundamental role in ecosystem functioning and thus may positively influence the provision of ecosystem services with benefits to society. There is a need for further understanding of how specific components of biodiversity are affecting service provision. In this context, terrestrial plants are a particularly important component of biodiversity and one for which a wealth of information on biodiversity–ecosystem functioning relationships is available. In this paper...
86 CitationsSource
#1Jenny A. Hodgson (University of Leeds)H-Index: 20
#2William E. Kunin (University of Leeds)H-Index: 51
Last. Doreen Gabriel (University of Leeds)H-Index: 14
view all 5 authors...
Organic farming aims to be wildlife-friendly, but it may not benefit wildlife overall if much greater areas are needed to produce a given quantity of food. We measured the density and species richness of butterflies on organic farms, conventional farms and grassland nature reserves in 16 landscapes. Organic farms supported a higher density of butterflies than conventional farms, but a lower density than reserves. Using our data, we predict the optimal land-use strategy to maintain yield whilst m...
116 CitationsSource
Among the myriad complications involved in the current food crisis, the relationship between agriculture and the rest of nature is one of the most important yet remains only incompletely analyzed. Particularly in tropical areas, agriculture is frequently seen as the antithesis of the natural world, where the problem is framed as one of minimizing land devoted to agriculture so as to devote more to conservation of biodiversity and other ecosystem services. In particular, the “forest transition mo...
357 CitationsSource
#1Adam B. Smith (University of California, Berkeley)H-Index: 17
Abstract Conservation biologists use the species–area relationship for a variety of purposes, including upscaling diversity from small plots to regions, predicting species loss, and for identifying biodiversity hotspots and prioritizing actions to protect them. Despite its widespread use, several complications that affect the accuracy of its application are often overlooked. First, interpretation of the species–area relationship is a function of the census design used to construct it. Nested cen...
45 CitationsSource
#1Richard G. Smith (PSU: Pennsylvania State University)H-Index: 21
#2David A. Mortensen (PSU: Pennsylvania State University)H-Index: 36
Last. Matthew R. Ryan (PSU: Pennsylvania State University)H-Index: 17
view all 3 authors...
Smith RG, Mortensen DA & Ryan MR (2009). A new hypothesis for the functional role of diversity in mediating resource pools and weed–crop competition in agroecosystems. Weed Research.50, 37–48. Summary We develop a new conceptual model we call the Resource Pool Diversity Hypothesis (RPDH) aimed at explaining how soil resource pool diversity may mediate competition for soil resources between weeds and crops. The primary tenets of the RPDH are that (i) in plant communities, the intensity of inter-s...
69 CitationsSource
#1Thomas Rudel (RU: Rutgers University)H-Index: 60
#2Laura Schneider (RU: Rutgers University)H-Index: 18
Last. Ricardo GrauH-Index: 1
view all 13 authors...
Does the intensification of agriculture reduce cultivated areas and, in so doing, spare some lands by concentrating production on other lands? Such sparing is important for many reasons, among them the enhanced abilities of released lands to sequester carbon and provide other environmental services. Difficulties measuring the extent of spared land make it impossible to investigate fully the hypothesized causal chain from agricultural intensification to declines in cultivated areas and then to in...
329 CitationsSource
#1Rufus Isaacs (MSU: Michigan State University)H-Index: 37
#2Julianna K. Tuell (MSU: Michigan State University)H-Index: 8
Last. D. A. Landis (MSU: Michigan State University)H-Index: 16
view all 5 authors...
Beneficial arthropods, including native bees, predators, and parasitoids, provide valuable ecosystem services worth $8 billion to US agriculture each year. These arthropod-mediated ecosystem services (AMES) include crop pollination and pest control, which help to maintain agricultural productivity and reduce the need for pesticide inputs. Maximizing survival and reproduction of beneficial arthropods requires provision of pollen and nectar resources that are often scarce in modern agricultural la...
256 CitationsSource
#1Thomas Merckx (University of Oxford)H-Index: 23
#2Ruth E. Feber (University of Oxford)H-Index: 22
Last. David W. Macdonald (University of Oxford)H-Index: 89
view all 7 authors...
How best to optimize the biodiversity gain from agri-environment schemes (AES) has recently been identified as a key policy-relevant question. Here, the effects of two features of lowland agricultural landscapes on the abundance and diversity of larger moths are contrasted. Although both features bring about positive effects, hedgerow trees have a larger impact than 6 m wide grassy field margins. Whilst AES payments are given to create and maintain grass margins, no financial reward is currently...
108 CitationsSource
#1Lena UlberH-Index: 3
Last. Bärbel GerowittH-Index: 14
view all 3 authors...
1 Citations
Cited By62
#1Wenbo Li (JLU: Jilin University)H-Index: 1
#1Wenbo LiH-Index: 1
view all 5 authors...
The competition for land resources created by the need for food security and ecological security is intensifying globally. To resolve the issue of land scarcity in agriculture following rapid urbanization, China implemented its requisition–compensation balance policy of cultivated lands in 1997, the introduction of which consumed numerous areas of land, such as river shoal and bare land, through reclamation. Moreover, these reclaimed and newly cultivated lands were mainly distributed in the nort...
#1Amanda E. Martin (Carleton University)H-Index: 7
#2Sara J. Collins (Carleton University)H-Index: 1
Last. Lenore Fahrig (Carleton University)H-Index: 72
view all 9 authors...
Abstract Pressure to increase food production to meet the demands of a growing human population can make conservation-motivated recommendations to limit agricultural expansion impractical. Therefore, we need to identify conservation actions that can support biodiversity without taking land out of production. Previous studies suggest this can be accomplished by increasing “farmland heterogeneity”—i.e. heterogeneity of the cropped portions of agricultural landscapes—by, for example, decreasing fie...
1 CitationsSource
#1Ashutosh Jha (IIM-C: Indian Institute of Management Calcutta)H-Index: 1
#2Debashis Saha (IIM-C: Indian Institute of Management Calcutta)H-Index: 17
The promulgation of the first National Telecom Policy of India in the year 1994 resulted in the geographical segregation of the country into 22 administrative units referred to as Telecom Circles (TCs). The creation of TCs was to enable targeted policy formulation and smooth implementation of the policy objectives of the government. The TCs were further clustered into four different categories, namely Metro, category A, category B, and category C, each category signaling to the telecom service p...
#1Max McClure (EcoHealth Alliance)H-Index: 1
#1Max McClure (EcoHealth Alliance)H-Index: 1
Last. William B. Karesh (EcoHealth Alliance)H-Index: 40
view all 7 authors...
The global trend toward increased agricultural production puts pressure on undeveloped areas, raising the question of how to optimally allocate land. Land-use change has recently been linked to a number of human health outcomes, but these are not routinely considered in land-use decision making. We review examples of planners’ currently used strategies to evaluate land use and present a conceptual model of optimal land use that incorporates health outcomes. We then present a framework for evalua...
1 CitationsSource
#1Jennifer Koch (OU: University of Oklahoma)H-Index: 11
#2Rüdiger Schaldach (University of Kassel)H-Index: 16
Last. Jan Göpel (University of Kassel)H-Index: 3
view all 3 authors...
Abstract Globally, the production of food, feed, bioenergy, and biomaterials has increased considerably during the past decades. This was achieved by the expansion of agricultural land and the intensification of agricultural management. Due to the conversion of natural ecosystems and the increasing use of pesticides and fertilizers, these processes are recognized as important causes of biodiversity loss. This study focuses on the African continent and analyses the potentials to achieve a stable ...
1 CitationsSource
#1Katrin KarnerH-Index: 2
#2Anna F. Cord (Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research - UFZ)H-Index: 18
Last. Martin SchönhartH-Index: 12
view all 17 authors...
Abstract Empirical research on land sharing and land sparing has been criticized because preferences of local stakeholders, socio-economic aspects, a bundle of ecosystem services and the local context were only rarely integrated. Using storylines and scenarios is a common approach to include land use drivers and local contexts or to cope with the uncertainties of future developments. The objective of the presented research is to develop comparable participatory regional land use scenarios for th...
2 CitationsSource
#1Pierre Chopin (SLU: Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences)H-Index: 1
#2Göran Bergkvist (SLU: Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences)H-Index: 16
Last. Laure Hossard (INRA: Institut national de la recherche agronomique)H-Index: 5
view all 3 authors...
Abstract Increased intensity of agriculture and landscape homogenization are threatening biodiversity in landscapes. We reviewed 67 case studies addressing the impact of agriculture on biodiversity in model based scenario approaches and compared the information they provide on biodiversity, spatial characteristics, scenarios, and landscapes. We found an overall large diversity of approaches that we summarized statistically into six groups. “Biodiversity based agent based models”, “Expert based e...
1 CitationsSource
#1Christoph P. Kiefer (CSIC: Spanish National Research Council)H-Index: 2
#2Javier Carrillo-Hermosilla (University of Alcalá)H-Index: 10
Last. Pablo del Río (CSIC: Spanish National Research Council)H-Index: 25
view all 3 authors...
Abstract Eco-innovations, or innovations that reduce the environmental impacts of production and consumption activities, are considered crucial for sustainability transitions and a key element of a Circular Economy. Although previous contributions have acknowledged the existence of different types of eco-innovations (e.g., product vs. service or incremental vs. radical), a precise conceptualization of eco-innovation types, which takes into account its multifaceted character, is missing. Yet such...
1 CitationsSource
#1Anna M. Rallings (UCM: University of California, Merced)H-Index: 1
#2Sean M. Smukler (UBC: University of British Columbia)H-Index: 13
Last. Kent Mullinix (Kwantlen Polytechnic University)H-Index: 6
view all 4 authors...
Abstract Hedgerows and riparian buffers in agricultural landscapes can help increase landscape multifunctionality and thereby mitigate conflicts among agricultural production and environmental stewardship objectives. However, the relative merits of conserving versus increasing non-production perennial vegetation (NPPV) are not well understood despite the universal conflicts among such objectives in rapidly urbanizing and intensifying agricultural regions worldwide. Hence, using the most intensiv...
1 CitationsSource
#1Rod A. HermanH-Index: 23
#2Meibao ZhuangH-Index: 1
Last. Bryan DelaneyH-Index: 9
view all 5 authors...
The risks of not considering benefits in risk assessment are often overlooked. Risks are also often evaluated without consideration of the broader context. We discuss these two concepts in relation to genetically engineered (GE) crops. The health, environmental, and economic risks and benefits of GE crops are exemplified and presented in the context of modern agriculture. Misattribution of unique risks to GE crops are discussed. It is concluded that the scale of modern agriculture is its disting...
1 CitationsSource