Investigating the reading-to-write construct

Published on Jul 1, 2008in Journal of English for Academic Purposes1.732
· DOI :10.1016/j.jeap.2008.04.001
Yuly Asención Delaney3
Estimated H-index: 3
(NAU: Northern Arizona University)
Abstract This study explored the extent to which the reading-to-write construct is the sum of one's reading and writing abilities or an independent construct. The investigation included an analysis of (a) test tasks, (b) the relationship of test task scores and scores on reading and writing measures, and (c) the effects of proficiency level and educational level on reading-to-write performance. A sample of 139 participants performed two reading-to-write tasks—a summary and a response essay—based on the same source text. Results indicate that the test tasks were different dimensions of the reading-to-write ability, and that the reading-to-write ability seems to be a unique construct weakly associated with reading for comprehension and disassociated from writing an essay without background reading support. In addition, it was found that language proficiency and educational level had a modest effect on the performance of the tasks.
  • References (41)
  • Citations (67)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
1 Author (Lia Plakans)
95 Citations
1 Author (S. Cushing)
85 Citations
81 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Alan R. HirvelaH-Index: 1
Academic writing often requires students to incorporate material from outside sources (like statistics, ideas, quotations, paraphrases) into their own written texts-a particular obstacle for students who lack strong reading skills. In "Connecting Reading and Writing in Second" "Language Instruction," Alan Hirvela contends that second language writing students should be considered as readers first and advocates the integration of reading and writing instruction with a survey of theory, research, ...
88 Citations
#1Mark JacksonH-Index: 2
82 Citations
#1Latricia Trites (MSU: Murray State University)H-Index: 1
#2Mary E McGroarty (NAU: Northern Arizona University)H-Index: 8
To address the concern that most traditional reading comprehension tests only measure basic comprehension, this study designed measures to assess more complex reading tasks: Reading to Learn and Reading to Integrate. The new measures were taken by 251 participants: 105 undergraduate native speakers of English, 106 undergraduate nonnative speakers, and 40 graduate nonnative speakers. The research subproblems included determination of the influence of overall basic reading comprehension level, nat...
26 CitationsSource
#1Barbara KrollH-Index: 1
Part I. Exploring the Field of Second Language Writing: Section introduction 1. Second language writing in the twentieth century: a situated historical perspective 2. Research on second language writing: an overview of what we investigate and how Part II. Exploring the Voices of Key Stakeholders: Teachers and Students Section Introduction: 3. Experienced ESL/EFL Writing Instructors' conceptualizations of their teaching: Curriculum options and implications 4. Second language writing up close and ...
192 Citations
#1William GrabeH-Index: 1
63 CitationsSource
#1William GrabeH-Index: 21
Contents General Editors' Preface Authors' Acknowledgements and Dedication Publisher's Acknowledgements Introduction Section I: Understanding L2 reading 1 The nature of reading abilities 1.1 Purposes for reading 1.2 Defining fluent reading comprehension 1.3 Describing how reading works: Components of reading abilities 1.4 Synthesising research perspectives: Models of reading 1.5 Conclusion 2 Comparing L1 and L2 reading 2.1 Linguistic and processing differences between L1 and L2 readers 2.2 Indiv...
636 Citations
#1Diane Pecorari (University of Birmingham)H-Index: 12
"Linking Literacies" provides the most up to date theoretical overview of the connection between reading and writing in second language acquisition. Belcher and Hirvela have brought together the definitive collection of developments in reading-writing relations research and pedagogy. Papers are organized into these parts: Ground Practice: Theory, Research, and History In the Classroom: Teaching Reading as Writing and Writing as Reading (E)Merging Literacies and the Challenge of Textual Ownership...
100 CitationsSource
#1Salim A. Khaldieh (WSU: Wayne State University)H-Index: 2
: Previous research in second language (L2) learning indicates that successful learners seem to use a wider variety of learning strategies than unsuccessful learners. This article reports the author's findings on the learning strategies used by 43 American learners of Arabic as a foreign language (AFL) in their writing tasks. The learning strategies were assessed through a process of introspection. While composing, students wrote down all techniques and procedures used to perform the writing tas...
66 CitationsSource
A brief retrospective is first provided on the study of reading and writing relations. Next, it is suggested that research has supported the theoretical contention that reading and writing rely on analogous mental processes and isomorphic knowledge. Four basic types of shared knowledge are delineated. Then, reasons are articulated about why it is also important to consider the separability of reading and writing. Further, over time, as reading and writing are learned, the nature of their relatio...
324 CitationsSource
University students studying a second language are often required to summarize information they read or hear in that language. These learners bring with them a number of first-language summarization skills which may have an effect on how they acquire second-language summarization skills. What macrorules of summarization are actually affected by either first-language or second-language proficiency? According to the results of this study, both first-language summarizing skills and second-language ...
11 Citations
Cited By67
#1Wei Su (University of Languages and International Studies)
Previous studies explored how rubrics of writing and speaking could change students’ self assessment and awareness of language skills, yet few disclosed the benefits of rubrics of interpreting. To ...
#1Stephen M. Doolan (A&M-CC: Texas A&M University–Corpus Christi)H-Index: 2
#1John E. Henning (Monmouth University)H-Index: 10
The purpose of the study was to investigate differences in writers’ abilities to perceive global text organisation in self-, peer- and teacher/researcher-authored essays. Eight student participants were identified as proficient, middle or developing, based on the levels of paragraph subordination, the average number of T-Units and the number of words in an initially written essay. Participants read aloud 10 essays written by themselves, by their peers and by the teacher/researcher. A comparison ...
#1Anchana Rukthong (PSU: Prince of Songkla University)
#2Tineke Brunfaut (Lancaster University)H-Index: 7
Integrated test tasks, such as listening-to-speak or reading-to-write, are increasingly used in second language assessment despite relatively limited empirical insights into what they assess. Most ...
1 CitationsSource
#1Hiroyuki Yamanishi (Chu-Dai: Chuo University)
#2Masumi Ono (Keio: Keio University)H-Index: 2
Last. Yuko Hijikata (University of Tsukuba)H-Index: 1
view all 3 authors...
Background In our research project, we have developed a scoring rubric for a second language (L2) summary writing for English as a foreign language (EFL) students in Japanese universities. This study aimed to examine the applicability of our five-dimensional rubric, which features both analytic and holistic assessments, to classrooms in the EFL context. The examination especially focused on a newly added, optional overall quality dimension and two paraphrasing dimensions: paraphrase (quantity) a...
Abstract This study reports on provision to assist students in the health sciences develop knowledge and skill in locating, evaluating, and synthesising sources to use as supporting evidence for the argument essays they are required to produce for first year courses at a university in New Zealand. Students were provided with support in the form of documents, tutorials, online discussion and structured assignment tasks, as well as through embedded instruction offered collaboratively by subject le...
#1Min Kang (Kobe University)H-Index: 4
#2Koichi Kawamura (Kobe University)
Last. Kazuhiro Ohtsuki (Kobe University)H-Index: 6
view all 5 authors...
Writing in a foreign language is a struggle for learners and revising their writings is time consuming for teachers as well. For this reason, writing support systems have been widely proposed and one of its main functions is to automatically detect and revise errors in learners’ writings. However, the detection technologies are a work in progress and the effectiveness of error revision feedback is arguable. Meanwhile, numerous efforts have been made to enhance learners’ writing proficiency and r...
#1Caroline Payant (UQAM: Université du Québec à Montréal)H-Index: 5
#2Kim McDonough (Concordia University)H-Index: 20
Last. Rachael Lindberg (Concordia University)H-Index: 1
view all 4 authors...
Abstract Integrated writing tasks are widely used in L2 academic proficiency tests (Cohen, 2009) even though L2 writers experience challenges with the comprehension and integration of source ideas (Plakans & Gebril, 2013). Relatively few studies have examined whether prewriting planning helps mitigate these challenges (Hayes, 1996) or whether L2 writers' individual differences affect any potential benefits for prewriting planning. Therefore, this study explores the contribution of source compreh...
1 CitationsSource
#1Maryam Homayounzadeh (Shiraz University)
#2Mahboobeh Saadat (Shiraz University)H-Index: 2
Last. Alireza Ahmadi (Shiraz University)H-Index: 5
view all 3 authors...
Abstract The study presents an attempt to explore the impact of source characteristics on task comparability in integrated writing tasks. To this end, two read-listen-write tasks of TOEFL iBT were selected to differ in topic, structural organization, and lexical and conceptual overlap, suggested to be significant in affecting summary quality ( Cho, Rijmen, & Novak, 2013 ; Li, 2014 ; Yu, 2009 ). The performance of a group of TOEFL candidates on the two tasks was qualitatively analyzed and quantit...
#1Scott A. Crossley (GSU: Georgia State University)H-Index: 29
#2Minkyung Kim (GSU: Georgia State University)H-Index: 2
Last. Danielle S. McNamara (ASU: Arizona State University)H-Index: 50
view all 4 authors...
Summarization is an effective strategy to promote and enhance learning and deep comprehension of texts. However, summarization is seldom implemented by teachers in classrooms because the manual evaluation of students’ summaries requires time and effort. This problem has led to the development of automated models of summarization quality. However, these models often rely on features derived from expert ratings of student summarizations of specific source texts and are therefore not generalizable ...