Writing in History: Narrating the Subject of Time

Published on Jan 1, 1995in Written Communication
· DOI :10.1177/0741088395012001003
Sharon Stockton1
Estimated H-index: 1
(Dickinson College)
Student writing in history courses, graded evaluation of that writing, and faculty interviews all reveal a contradiction between the stated and implicit aims of historical discourse. The explicit definition of writing in history is “argumentation”; the implicit expectation, however, is for narrative. This apparent contradiction highlights what the author argues is the central function of academic historical discourse: the establishment of an autonomous subject of meaning who is always speaking from outside history about a distant and objectified past. Students are rarely aware of the importance of this voice, even at an unconscious level, because faculty themselves fail to articulate for students the distinctive nature of their genre or the function of historical discourse generally. This project thus builds on previous studies in rhetoric by using the work of theorists of history to identify more precisely what it is in historical discourse that is hidden from student view—the autonomous, transhistorical...
  • References (2)
  • Citations (22)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
61 Citations
464 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
History teachers are frequently urged to use primary sources in their classrooms. Yet little research exists to guide them, for history has been virtually ignored by researchers interested in cognition and instruction. The present study explored how people evaluate primary and secondary sources when considering questions of historical evidence. A group of working historians and high school seniors "thought aloud" as they reviewed a series of written and pictorial documents about the Battle of Le...
669 CitationsSource
#1Sam Wineburg (UW: University of Washington)H-Index: 30
464 CitationsSource
Cited By22
#1Jodi P. Lampi (NIU: Northern Illinois University)
#2Eric J. Paulson (Texas State University)H-Index: 9
In this manuscript, the authors use metaphor analysis to uncover community college faculty conceptualizations about disciplinary writing. The findings suggest that faculty have multiple beliefs, attitudes, and perceptions of disciplinary writing and tend not to articulate differences between disciplinary writing practices and general writing practices. Implications of this study include the importance of faculty considering how their conceptualizations of writing can support students' understand...
#1Richard E. MayerH-Index: 104
Preface Part I. Research on Learning 1. Introduction to Research on Learning, Patricia A. Alexander and Richard E. Mayer 2. Learning to Read, Emily Fox and Patricia A. Alexander 3. Learning to Write, Susan De La Paz and Deborah McCutchen 4. Learning Mathematics, Ann R. Edwards, Indigo Esmonde, and Joseph F. Wagner 5. Learning Science, Richard Duschl and Richard Hamilton 6. Learning History, Linda Levstik 7. Learning a Second Language, Min Wang 8. Learning Motor Skill in Physical Education, Cathe...
164 CitationsSource
This thesis has developed out of a classroom practitioner’s desire to find out what works when trying to improve both the quality of the writing and the attainment of GCSE Business Studies students. It investigates the body of literature on writing approaches and in the context of the current educational framework in UK secondary schools considers how suggested writing interventions can be used. It describes the use of an exploratory randomised controlled trial conducted with 14-15 year-old stud...
#1Susan De La Paz (UMD: University of Maryland, College Park)H-Index: 23
#2Daniel R. Wissinger (IUP: Indiana University of Pennsylvania)H-Index: 3
Historians use a range of genres in presenting their subjects, yet educators have increasingly privileged argumentation to help novices to reason with historical content. However, the influence genre and content knowledge are relatively unmeasured in this discipline. To learn more, the authors asked 101 eleventh-grade students to compose an argument or a summary on the Gulf of Tonkin and analyzed basic and disciplinary reading and writing measures. Results indicate that students with adequate co...
5 CitationsSource
#1Stephanie M. Bennett (USF: University of South Florida)H-Index: 1
#1Deborah McCutchen (UW: University of Washington)H-Index: 27
This article outlines a theory of the development of writing expertise illustrated by a review of relevant research. An argument is made for two necessary (although not sufficient) components in the development of writing expertise: fluent language generation processes and extensive knowledge relevant to writing. Fluent language processes enable the developing writer (especially the young developing writer) to begin to manage the constraints imposed by working memory, whereas extensive knowledge...
78 Citations
This study explores how different kinds of arguments are situated in academic contexts and provides an analysis of undergraduate writing assignments. Assignments were collected from the schools of business, education, engineering, fine arts, and interdisciplinary studies as well as the humanities, natural sciences, and social sciences in the College of Arts and Science. A total of 265 undergraduate writing assignments from 71 courses were analyzed. Assignments were reliably categorized into thes...
44 CitationsSource
#1Sarah North (OU: Open University)H-Index: 10
This article reports the findings of a 3 year research project which investigated disciplinary variation in student writing. Within an Open University course in the history of science, students from an arts background were found to achieve significantly higher grades than those from a science background. Textual and interview data suggest that differences in their essay writing may be related to differences in disciplinary culture and epistemology. The results thus support the hypothesis that st...
74 CitationsSource
Abstract Work in corpus linguistics has led to the development of a theory of language as phraseology [Hunston, S., & Francis, G. (1999). Pattern grammar: A corpus-driven approach to the lexical grammar of English. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Sinclair, J. M. (1991). Corpus, concordance, collocation . Oxford: Oxford University Press. Sinclair, J. M. (2004). Trust the text: Language, corpus and discourse . London: Routledge.]. This paper investigates whether and to what extent phraseology, as exemp...
68 CitationsSource