Comparative analysis of performance and stability among composite cross populations, variety mixtures and pure lines of winter wheat in organic and conventional cropping systems

Published on Nov 1, 2015in Field Crops Research3.868
· DOI :10.1016/j.fcr.2015.08.009
Thomas F. Döring1
Estimated H-index: 1
(Newbury College),
Paolo Annicchiarico27
Estimated H-index: 27
(Consiglio per la ricerca e la sperimentazione in agricoltura)
+ 6 AuthorsMartin Wolfe7
Estimated H-index: 7
(Suffolk University)
This study investigated the effects of increased genetic diversity in winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.), either from hybridization across genotypes or from physical mixing of lines, on grain yield, grain quality, and yield stability in different cropping environments. Sets of pure lines (no diversity), chosen for high yielding ability or high quality, were compared with line mixtures (intermediate level of diversity), and lines crossed with each other in composite cross populations (CCPn, high diversity). Additional populations containing male sterility genes (CCPms) to increase outcrossing rates were also tested. Grain yield, grain protein content, and protein yield were measured at four sites (two organically-managed and two conventionally-managed) over three years, using seed harvested locally in each preceding year. CCPn and mixtures out-yielded the mean of the parents by 2.4% and 3.6%, respectively. These yield differences were consistent across genetic backgrounds but partly inconsistent across cropping environments and years. Yield stability measured by environmental variance was higher in CCPn and CCPms than the mean of the parents. An index of yield reliability tended to be higher in CCPn, CCPms and mixtures than the mean of the parents. Lin and Binns’ superiority values of yield and protein yield were consistently and significantly lower (i.e. better) in the CCPs than in the mean of the parents, but not different between CCPs and mixtures. However, CCPs showed greater early ground cover and plant height than mixtures. When compared with the (locally non-predictable) best-yielding pure line, CCPs and mixtures exhibited lower mean yield and somewhat lower yield reliability but comparable superiority values. Thus, establishing CCPs from smaller sets of high-performing parent lines might optimize their yielding ability. On the whole, the results demonstrate that using increased within-crop genetic diversity can produce wheat crops with improved yield stability and good yield reliability across variable and unpredictable cropping environments.
  • References (60)
  • Citations (21)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
79 Citations
205 Citations
175 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Ambrogio Costanzo (Sant'Anna School of Advanced Studies)H-Index: 3
#2Paolo Bàrberi (Sant'Anna School of Advanced Studies)H-Index: 23
Agrobiodiversity can improve the sustainability of cropping systems in a context of low external inputs and unpredictable climate change. Agrobiodiversity strategies to grow wheat are breeding ad hoc cultivars for organic and low-input systems, wheat–legume intercrops and living mulches, cultivar mixtures, and the use of genetically heterogeneous populations. However, applying those strategies can fail due the lack of a well-focused framework. Therefore, we need a better integration between bree...
53 CitationsSource
#1Henry E. Creissen (UEA: University of East Anglia)H-Index: 4
#2Tove H. Jorgensen (UEA: University of East Anglia)H-Index: 15
Last. James K. M. Brown (Norwich Research Park)H-Index: 39
view all 3 authors...
Background and Aims Plant genotypic mixtures have the potential to increase yield stability in variable, often unpredictable environments, yet knowledge of the specific mechanisms underlying enhanced yield stability remains limited. Field studies are constrained by environmental conditions which cannot be fully controlled and thus reproduced. A suitable model system would allow reproducible experiments on processes operating within crop genetic mixtures.
16 CitationsSource
#1Martin WolfeH-Index: 7
#2Sally HowlettH-Index: 2
Last. Thomas F. DöringH-Index: 1
view all 6 authors...
Background To help deal with the lack of appropriate plant varieties that are adapted to conditions of organic agriculture (e.g. Wolfe et al., 2008), the new COBRA project (Doring et al., 2013, this Symposium) aims to link breeding efforts in pure line breeding with research in the development of Composite Cross Populations (CCPs; Doring et al., 2011). In the meantime, a number of initiatives are already in progress to start this process. To allow the adoption of these approaches in practice, th...
1 Citations
#1Dim Coumou (PIK: Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research)H-Index: 24
#2Alexander Robinson (PIK: Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research)H-Index: 18
Last. Stefan Rahmstorf (PIK: Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research)H-Index: 63
view all 3 authors...
The last decade has produced record-breaking heat waves in many parts of the world. At the same time, it was globally the warmest since sufficient measurements started in the 19th century. Here we show that, worldwide, the number of local record-breaking monthly temperature extremes is now on average five times larger than expected in a climate with no long-term warming. This implies that on average there is an 80 % chance that a new monthly heat record is due to climatic change. Large regional ...
115 CitationsSource
#1Mathieu Thomas (INRA: Institut national de la recherche agronomique)H-Index: 7
#2Elise Demeulenaere (CNRS: Centre national de la recherche scientifique)H-Index: 7
Last. Isabelle Goldringer (INRA: Institut national de la recherche agronomique)H-Index: 22
view all 9 authors...
Since the domestication of crop species, humans have derived specific varieties for particular uses and shaped the genetic diversity of these varieties. Here, using an interdisciplinary approach combining ethnobotany and population genetics, we document the within-variety genetic structure of a population-variety of bread wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) in relation to farmers’ practices to decipher their contribution to crop species evolution. Using 19 microsatellites markers, we conducted two comp...
37 CitationsSource
#1R. Ford DenisonH-Index: 32
List of Illustrations vii Chapter 1 Repaying Darwin's Debt to Agriculture 1 Chapter 2 What Do We Need from Agriculture? 9 Chapter 3 Evolution 101 28 The Power of Natural Selection Chapter 4 Darwinian Agriculture's Three Core Principles 43 Chapter 5 What Won't Work 54 Tradeoff-blind Biotechnology Chapter 6 Selfish Genes, Sophisticated Plants, and Haphazard Ecosystems 76 Chapter 7 What Won't Work 95 Misguided Mimicry of Natural Ecosystems Chapter 8 What Has Worked 120 Improving Cooperation within ...
65 Citations
#1Daniel Urban (Stanford University)H-Index: 4
#2Michael J. Roberts (NCSU: North Carolina State University)H-Index: 25
Last. David B. Lobell (Stanford University)H-Index: 66
view all 4 authors...
Climate change has the potential to be a source of increased variability if crops are more frequently exposed to damaging weather conditions. Yield variability could respond to a shift in the frequency of extreme events to which crops are susceptible, or if weather becomes more variable. Here we focus on the United States, which produces about 40% of the world’s maize, much of it in areas that are expected to see increased interannual variability in temperature. We combine a statistical crop mod...
69 CitationsSource
#1Martin Lukac (University of Reading)H-Index: 23
#2Michael Gooding (University of Reading)H-Index: 32
Last. Hannah Jones (University of Reading)H-Index: 10
view all 4 authors...
† Background and Aims Self-pollination dominates in wheat, with a small level of out-crossing due to flowering asynchrony and male sterility. However, the timing and synchrony of male and female flowering in wheat is a crucial determinant of seed set and may be an important factor affecting gene flow and resilience to climate change. Here, a methodology is presented for assessing the timing and synchrony of flowering in wheat, Triticum aestivum. † Methods From the onset of flowering until the en...
19 CitationsSource
#1Marco Pautasso (CNRS: Centre national de la recherche scientifique)H-Index: 33
#2Thomas F. DöringH-Index: 21
Last. Michael Jeger (Imperial College London)H-Index: 35
view all 5 authors...
There has been a remarkable scientific output on the topic of how climate change is likely to affect plant diseases. This overview addresses the need for review of this burgeoning literature by summarizing opinions of previous reviews and trends in recent studies ontheimpactsofclimatechangeonplant health.Sudden Oak Death is used as an introductory case study: Cali- fornian forests could become even more susceptible to this emerging plant disease, if spring precipitations will be accompanied by w...
129 CitationsSource
#1Silvan Rieben (UZH: University of Zurich)H-Index: 1
#2Olena Kalinina (UZH: University of Zurich)H-Index: 11
Last. Simon L. Zeller (UZH: University of Zurich)H-Index: 7
view all 4 authors...
Understanding gene flow in genetically modified (GM) crops is critical to answering questions regarding risk-assessment and the coexistence of GM and non-GM crops. In two field experiments, we tested whether rates of cross-pollination differed between GM and non-GM lines of the predominantly self-pollinating wheat Triticum aestivum. In the first experiment, outcrossing was studied within the field by planting “phytometers” of one line into stands of another line. In the second experiment, outcro...
28 CitationsSource
Cited By21
#1Simona Ciancaleoni (University of Perugia)H-Index: 6
#2Valeria Negri (University of Perugia)H-Index: 17
BACKGROUND: The use of high inputs in agriculture resulted in few varieties (hybrids and pure lines) used in all agricultural systems. Also varieties of vegetables, including broccoli, for organic and low-input agriculture, are almost exclusively hybrids, since there are very few specific breeding programs and varieties for sustainable agriculture systems. A strategy to overcome this issue is the adoption of specific breeding programs for developing heterogeneous varieties (i.e. synthetics, open...
#1Samuel Knapp (TUM: Technische Universität München)H-Index: 2
#2Thomas F. Döring (University of Bonn)H-Index: 21
Last. Simon Griffiths (Norwich Research Park)H-Index: 27
view all 8 authors...
Most of our crops are grown in monoculture with single genotypes grown over wide acreage. An alternative approach, where segregating populations are used as crops, is an exciting possibility, but outcomes of natural selection upon this type of crop are not well understood. We tracked allelic frequency changes in evolving composite cross populations of wheat grown over ten generations under organic and conventional farming. At three generations, each population was genotyped with 19 SSR and 8 SNP...
#1Jeremy J. Burdon (Fujian Agriculture and Forestry University)H-Index: 50
#2Luke G. Barrett (CSIRO: Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation)H-Index: 19
Last. Jiasui Zhan (Fujian Agriculture and Forestry University)
view all 5 authors...
#1Gaëlle van FrankH-Index: 1
#2Pierre RivièreH-Index: 4
Last. Isabelle GoldringerH-Index: 22
view all 13 authors...
Modern agricultural systems rely on reduced crop genetic diversity, due in particular to the use of homogeneous elite varieties grown in large areas. However, genetic diversity within fields is a lever for a more sustainable production, allowing greater stability and resistance to biotic and abiotic stresses. In France, a Participatory Plant Breeding (PPB) project on bread wheat, involving farmers, facilitators and researchers, has led to the development of heterogeneous populations whose within...
#1Carolyn J. Lowry (USDA: United States Department of Agriculture)H-Index: 3
#1Carolyn J. Lowry (USDA: United States Department of Agriculture)
Last. Richard G. Smith (UNH: University of New Hampshire)H-Index: 21
view all 8 authors...
Abstract Cultivar mixtures can provide a host of beneficial agroecosystem services in annual grain crops; however, it remains unclear whether these same benefits apply to perennial forage cropping systems, or the degree to which beneficial effects depend on the functional trait diversity of the mixtures. We conducted a field experiment across four locations in the Northeast US in which we grew perennial ryegrass cultivar mixtures varying in cultivar number and range of expression of three functi...
#1Alberto MasoniH-Index: 2
#2Alessandro CalamaiH-Index: 7
Last. Enrico PalchettiH-Index: 3
view all 5 authors...
In many African countries, such as Madagascar, a large part of the population is currently estimated to be undernourished, and self-subsistence agriculture represents the primary source of food available for the family. Smallholder farmers cultivate crops with limited agricultural input and use old landraces or obsolete hybrid varieties, with a total country-wide production that is far from being able to sustain the national food demand. In this study, we have developed two maize composite cross...
#1Isabelle GoldringerH-Index: 22
#2Gaëlle van FrankH-Index: 1
Last. Pierre RivièreH-Index: 4
view all 21 authors...
Participatory plant breeding (PPB) is based on the decentralization of selection in farmers’ fields and their involvement in decision-making at all steps of the breeding scheme. Despite the evidence of its benefits to develop population varieties adapted to diversified and local practices and conditions, such as organic farming, PPB is still not widely used. There is a need to share more broadly how the different programs have overcome scientific, practical, and organizational issues and produce...
1 CitationsSource
#1A. K. Carneiro (UFRJ: Federal University of Rio de Janeiro)
#2Adriano Teodoro Bruzi (UFLA: Universidade Federal de Lavras)H-Index: 6
Last. Everton Vinicius Zambiazzi (UFLA: Universidade Federal de Lavras)H-Index: 4
view all 4 authors...
Twelve winter wheat composite cross populations (CCPs), based on three genetic backgrounds and maintained at the University of Kassel, Germany, under both organic and conventional management, were assessed for yield performance and stability in comparison to two commercial varieties over eight and 10 experimental years. A number of stability parameters were chosen in order to identify populations with either adaptation to specific environments or broad adaptation across environments. The genetic...
#1Sarah Brumlop (University of Kassel)H-Index: 3
#2Odette Weedon (University of Kassel)H-Index: 3
Last. Maria R. Finckh (University of Kassel)H-Index: 20
view all 4 authors...
Abstract Effective Population Sizes ( N e ) of three winter wheat composite cross populations (CCPs) that had been maintained under organic and conventional conditions from the F 7 to the F 12 were analysed. The number of plants ( N ) needed to maintain an N e of 5000 for each population was calculated based on the mean variation in the number of gametes per parent S k 2 . Variability in kernel number per plant was high, leading to large variations in the contribution of single plants to the nex...