Comparing the recovery of richness, structure, and biomass in naturally regrowing and planted reforestation

Published on Mar 1, 2020in Restoration Ecology2.826
· DOI :10.1111/REC.13077
Timothy L. Staples4
Estimated H-index: 4
(UQ: University of Queensland),
Margaret M. Mayfield28
Estimated H-index: 28
(UQ: University of Queensland)
+ 1 AuthorsJohn M. Dwyer19
Estimated H-index: 19
(UQ: University of Queensland)
The clearing of natural vegetation for agriculture has reduced the capacity of natural systems to provide ecosystem functions. Ecological restoration can restore desirable ecosystem functions, such as creating habitat for animal conservation and carbon sequestration as woody biomass. In order to maintain these beneficial ecosystem functions, restoration projects need to mature into self-perpetuating communities. Here we compared the ecological attributes of two types of restoration, “active” tree plantings with “passive” natural forest regeneration (“natural regrowth”) to existing remnant vegetation in a cleared agricultural landscape. Specifically, we measured differences between forest categories in factors that may predict future restoration failure or ecosystem collapse: aboveground plant biomass and biomass accrual over time (for regrowing stands), plant density and size class distributions, and diversity of functional groups based on seed dispersal and growth strategy traits. We found that natural regrowth and planted forests were similar in many ecological characteristics, including biomass accrual. Despite this, planted stands contained fewer tree recruit and shrub individuals, which may be due to limited recruitment in plantings. If this continues, these forests may be at risk of collapsing into nonforest states after mature trees senesce. Lower shrub density and richness of mid-story trees may lead to lower structural complexity in planting plots, and alongside lower richness of fleshy-fruited plant species may reduce animal resources and animal use of the restored stand. In our study region, natural regrowth may result in restored woodland communities with greater conservation and carbon mitigation value.
  • References (66)
  • Citations (0)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
23 Citations
1 Author (John M. Dwyer)
2 Citations
10 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1T. Trevor Caughlin (BSU: Boise State University)H-Index: 9
#2Marinés de la Peña‐Domene (Universidad Autónoma del Estado de Morelos)H-Index: 2
Last. Cristina Martínez-Garza (Universidad Autónoma del Estado de Morelos)H-Index: 16
view all 3 authors...
: For tropical forest restoration to result in long-term biodiversity gains, native trees must establish self-sustaining populations in degraded sites. While many have asked how seedling recruitment varies between restoration treatments, the long-term fate of these recruits remains unknown. We address this research gap by tracking natural recruits of 27 species during the first 7 years of a tropical forest restoration experiment that included both planted and naturally regenerating plots. We use...
1 CitationsSource
#1Daniel C. Laughlin (UW: University of Wyoming)H-Index: 32
#2Loïc Chalmandrier (UW: University of Wyoming)H-Index: 5
Last. Jennifer L. Funk (College of Science and Technology)H-Index: 25
view all 6 authors...
Restoring resilient ecosystems in an era of rapid environmental change requires a flexible framework for selecting assemblages of species based on functional traits. However, current trait-based models have been limited to algorithms that select species assemblages that only converge on specified average trait values, and could not accommodate the common desire among restoration ecologists to generate functionally diverse assemblages. We have solved this problem by applying a nonlinear optimizat...
1 CitationsSource
#1J. Leighton Reid (Missouri Botanical Garden)H-Index: 16
#2Matthew E. Fagan (UMBC: University of Maryland, Baltimore County)H-Index: 13
Last. Rakan A. Zahawi (UH: University of Hawaii)H-Index: 24
view all 3 authors...
Several recent meta-analyses have aimed to determine whether natural regeneration is more effective at recovering tropical forests than active restoration (for example, tree planting). We reviewed this literature and found that comparisons between strategies are biased by positive site selection. Studies of natural forest regeneration are generally conducted at sites where a secondary forest was already present, whereas tree planting studies are done in a broad range of site conditions, includin...
18 CitationsSource
#1Holly P. Jones (NIU: Northern Illinois University)H-Index: 19
#2Peter C. Jones (NIU: Northern Illinois University)H-Index: 7
Last. David Moreno Mateos (Ikerbasque)H-Index: 4
view all 10 authors...
Given that few ecosystems on the Earth have been unaffected by humans, restoring them holds great promise for stemming the biodiversity crisis and ensuring ecosystem services are provided to humanity. Nonetheless, few studies have documented the recovery of ecosystems globally or the rates at which ecosystems recover. Even fewer have addressed the added benefit of actively restoring ecosystems versus allowing them to recover without human intervention following the cessation of a disturbance. Ou...
31 CitationsSource
#1Renato Crouzeilles (UFRJ: Federal University of Rio de Janeiro)H-Index: 15
#2Mariana Silva Ferreira (UFRJ: Federal University of Rio de Janeiro)H-Index: 7
Last. Bernardo B. N. Strassburg (UFRJ: Federal University of Rio de Janeiro)H-Index: 22
view all 9 authors...
Is active restoration the best approach to achieve ecological restoration success (the return to a reference condition, that is, old-growth forest) when compared to natural regeneration in tropical forests? Our meta-analysis of 133 studies demonstrated that natural regeneration surpasses active restoration in achieving tropical forest restoration success for all three biodiversity groups (plants, birds, and invertebrates) and five measures of vegetation structure (cover, density, litter, biomass...
52 CitationsSource
#1Daniel C. Laughlin (UW: University of Wyoming)H-Index: 32
#2Robert T. Strahan (New Mexico Highlands University)H-Index: 4
Last. W. Wallace Covington (NAU: Northern Arizona University)H-Index: 46
view all 6 authors...
1. Predicting restoration outcomes requires an understanding of the natural variability of ecosystem properties. A hierarchy of predictability has been proposed that ranks measures of restoration success from most-to-least predictable in the following order: vegetation structure > taxonomic diversity > functional diversity > taxonomic composition. This hierarchy has not been tested empirically, and the location within the hierarchy of trait-based measures, such as community-level trait means and...
15 CitationsSource
#1Lars A. Brudvig (MSU: Michigan State University)H-Index: 27
14 CitationsSource
#1Achim Häger (The School for Field Studies)H-Index: 3
#2Gerardo Avalos (UCR: University of Costa Rica)H-Index: 8
Altered landscapes play a major role in biodiversity conservation and carbon (C) storage in the tropics. There is increasing evidence that C storage potential is controlled by tree functional diversity, but underlying mechanisms are debated. We analyzed the effects of trait dominance (mass-ratio hypothesis), species diversity, and trait variation (species complementarity) on C storage in the soils and vegetation of 20 agroforestry systems (AFS) and seven forested sites in Costa Rica. AFS consist...
3 CitationsSource
#1Sarah Ford (UVM: University of Vermont)H-Index: 2
#2William S. Keeton (UVM: University of Vermont)H-Index: 28
Forest management practices emphasizing stand structural complexity are of interest across the northern forest region of the United States because of their potential to enhance carbon storage. Our research is part of a long-term study evaluating silvicultural treatments that promote late-successional forest characteristics in northern hardwood-conifer forests. We are testing the hypothesis that aboveground biomass development (carbon storage) is greater in structural complexity enhancement (SCE)...
21 CitationsSource
#1Paula MeliH-Index: 12
#2Karen D. Holl (UCSC: University of California, Santa Cruz)H-Index: 29
Last. David Moreno Mateos (Ikerbasque)H-Index: 4
view all 7 authors...
Global forest restoration targets have been set, yet policy makers and land managers lack guiding principles on how to invest limited resources to achieve them. We conducted a meta-analysis of 166 studies in naturally regenerating and actively restored forests worldwide to answer: (1) To what extent do floral and faunal abundance and diversity and biogeochemical functions recover? (2) Does recovery vary as a function of past land use, time since restoration, forest region, or precipitation? (3) ...
56 CitationsSource
Cited By0