Comparison of BEAMing and Droplet Digital PCR for Circulating Tumor DNA Analysis

Published on Nov 1, 2019in Clinical Chemistry6.916
· DOI :10.1373/clinchem.2019.305805
Ben O'Leary8
Estimated H-index: 8
(ICR: Institute of Cancer Research),
Sarah Hrebien7
Estimated H-index: 7
(ICR: Institute of Cancer Research)
+ 10 AuthorsNicholas C. Turner45
Estimated H-index: 45
(ICR: Institute of Cancer Research)
Background: Circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) assays are increasingly used for clinical decision-making, but it is unknown how well different assays agree. We aimed to assess the agreement in ctDNA mutation calling between BEAMing (beads, emulsion, amplification, and magnetics) and droplet digital PCR (ddPCR), 2 of the most commonly used digital PCR techniques for detecting mutations in ctDNA. Methods: Baseline plasma samples from patients with advanced breast cancer enrolled in the phase 3 PALOMA-3 trial were assessed for ESR1 and PIK3CA mutations in ctDNA with both BEAMing and ddPCR. Concordance between the 2 approaches was assessed, with exploratory analyses to estimate the importance of sampling effects. Results: Of the 521 patients enrolled, 363 had paired baseline ctDNA analysis. ESR1 mutation detection was 24.2% (88/363) for BEAMing and 25.3% (92/363) for ddPCR, with good agreement between the 2 techniques (κ = 0.9l; 95% CI, 0.85–0.95). PIK3CA mutation detection rates were 26.2% (95/363) for BEAMing and 22.9% (83/363) for ddPCR, with good agreement (κ = 0.87; 95% CI, 0.81–0.93). Discordancy was observed for 3.9% patients with ESR1 mutations and 5.0% with PIK3CA mutations. Assessment of individual mutations suggested higher rates of discordancy for less common mutations (P = 0.019). The majority of discordant calls occurred at allele frequency Conclusions: This large, clinically relevant comparison showed good agreement between BEAMing and ddPCR, suggesting sufficient reproducibility for clinical use. Much of the observed discordancy may be related to sampling effects, potentially explaining many of the differences in the currently available ctDNA literature.
  • References (33)
  • Citations (2)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
15 Authors (Huilan Yao, ..., P. Vijay Kumar)
20182.93BMC Cancer
20 Authors (Nong Yang, ..., Fugen Li)
15 Citations
13 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Wenwen Chen (SZU: Shenzhen University)H-Index: 19
#2Jiaying Zheng (SZU: Shenzhen University)H-Index: 1
Last. Jidong Wang (SZU: Shenzhen University)H-Index: 6
view all 8 authors...
BACKGROUND: Infiltrating ductal carcinoma (IDCA) is the most common form of invasive breast cancer. Immunohistochemistry (IHC) is widely used to analyze estrogen receptor 1 (ER), progesterone receptor (PR), and human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2) that can help classify the tumor to guide the medical treatment. IHC examinations require experienced pathologists to provide interpretations that are subjective, thereby lowering the reproducibility of IHC-based diagnosis. In this study, we...
1 CitationsSource
#1Hiroaki Akamatsu (Wakayama Medical University)H-Index: 15
#2Yasuhiro Koh (Wakayama Medical University)H-Index: 19
Last. Ken Nakagawa (Kindai University)H-Index: 70
view all 9 authors...
Abstract Background Liquid biopsy has been approved as an optional method to detect epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) mutations in non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). However, the clinical significance of its utility for monitoring the disease remains elusive. WJOG8114LTR is a prospective, multi-institutional study of liquid biopsy in EGFR mutated patients with NSCLC. Patients and methods Chemotherapy naive, advanced NSCLC patients with EGFR -sensitizing mutation received afatinib 40 mg/bo...
1 CitationsSource
#1Neeraj Agarwal (HCI: Huntsman Cancer Institute)H-Index: 37
#2Richard B. LanmanH-Index: 27
Last. Sumanta K. Pal (City of Hope National Medical Center)H-Index: 43
view all 3 authors...
2 CitationsSource
#1Samuel V. AngiuoliH-Index: 35
#2James R. WhiteH-Index: 29
Last. Siân JonesH-Index: 37
view all 3 authors...
1 CitationsSource
#1Álvaro Taus (Autonomous University of Barcelona)H-Index: 8
#2Laura CamachoH-Index: 5
Last. Edurne ArriolaH-Index: 15
view all 14 authors...
Abstract Background The assessment of epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) mutations is crucial for the management of patients with lung adenocarcinoma. Circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA)-based assessment offers advantages over tumor as a minimally invasive method able to capture tumor heterogeneity. Patients and Methods Consecutive patients diagnosed with EGFR-mutant lung adenocarcinoma in tumor biopsy were included in this study. Plasma samples were obtained at different time points during the c...
6 CitationsSource
#1Jason D. Merker (Stanford University)H-Index: 19
#2Geoffrey R. Oxnard (Harvard University)H-Index: 38
Last. Nicholas C. TurnerH-Index: 45
view all 17 authors...
PurposeClinical use of analytical tests to assess genomic variants in circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) is increasing. This joint review from ASCO and the College of American Pathologists summarizes current information about clinical ctDNA assays and provides a framework for future research.MethodsAn Expert Panel conducted a literature review on the use of ctDNA assays for solid tumors, including pre-analytical variables, analytical validity, interpretation and reporting, and clinical validity and u...
131 CitationsSource
#1Jessica GarciaH-Index: 2
#2Julien ForestierH-Index: 1
Last. Léa PayenH-Index: 20
view all 26 authors...
// Jessica Garcia 1, 2, 3, 4 , Julien Forestier 5 , Eric Dusserre 1, 3, 4 , Anne-Sophie Wozny 1, 3 , Florence Geiguer 1, 3, 4 , Patrick Merle 6, 7 , Claire Tissot 8 , Carole Ferraro-Peyret 2, 9 , Frederick S. Jones 10 , Daniel L. Edelstein 10 , Valerie Cheynet 4, 11 , Claire Bardel 12, 18 , Gaelle Vilchez 4 , Zhenyu Xu 13 , Pierre Paul Bringuier 2, 9 , Marc Barritault 1, 9 , Karen Brengle-Pesce 4, 11 , Marielle Guillet 14 , Marion Chauvenet 15 , Brigitte Manship 2 , Marie Brevet 3, 9, 16 , Clair...
5 CitationsSource
#1Ben O'Leary (ICR: Institute of Cancer Research)H-Index: 8
#2Sarah Hrebien (ICR: Institute of Cancer Research)H-Index: 7
Last. Nicholas C. Turner (ICR: Institute of Cancer Research)H-Index: 45
view all 13 authors...
CDK4/6 inhibition substantially improves progression-free survival (PFS) for women with advanced estrogen receptor-positive breast cancer, although there are no predictive biomarkers. Early changes in circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) level may provide early response prediction, but the impact of tumor heterogeneity is unknown. Here we use plasma samples from patients in the randomized phase III PALOMA-3 study of CDK4/6 inhibitor palbociclib and fulvestrant for women with advanced breast cancer and ...
60 CitationsSource
#1Daniel F. Hayes (UM: University of Michigan)H-Index: 106
3 CitationsSource
#1Gonzalo Torga (JHUSOM: Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine)H-Index: 5
#2Kenneth J. Pienta (JHUSOM: Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine)H-Index: 106
59 CitationsSource
Cited By2
#1Kelly Cristina da Silva Oliveira (UFPA: Federal University of Pará)H-Index: 2
#2Iago Barroso Ramos (UFPA: Federal University of Pará)
Last. Paulo Pimentel Assumpção (UFPA: Federal University of Pará)H-Index: 22
view all 12 authors...
Circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) has recently emerged as a minimally invasive 9liquid biopsy9 tool in precision medicine. ctDNA-genomic DNA fragments that are released into the bloodstream after the active secretion of microvesicles or tumor cell lysis-reflects tumor evolution and the genomic alterations present in primary and/or metastatic tumors. Notably, ctDNA analysis might allow the stratification of patients, the monitoring of the therapeutic response, and the establishment of an opportunity ...
#1Lorenzo Gerratana (NU: Northwestern University)H-Index: 10
#2QiangZhang (NU: Northwestern University)H-Index: 57
Last. Massimo Cristofanilli (NU: Northwestern University)H-Index: 70
view all 13 authors...
Abstract Circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) is gaining momentum as sensitive diagnostic tool for advanced disease characterization because of its ability both to capture the tumor’s heterogeneity and its dynamic adaptations. However, the consistency between all the available platforms is still debated. The aim of the study was to explore the performance of the novel diagnostic NGS platform PredicinePLUS™ and to compare its results with the clinically available Guardant360™ platform for possible analy...
1 CitationsSource
#1Daniel Weiser (Albert Einstein College of Medicine)H-Index: 5
#2Diana C. West-Szymanski (U of C: University of Chicago)H-Index: 1
Last. Mark A. Applebaum (U of C: University of Chicago)H-Index: 9
view all 8 authors...
Pediatric solid tumors have long been known to shed tumor cells, DNA, RNA, and proteins into the blood. Recent technological advances have allowed for improved capture and analysis of these typically scant circulating materials. Efforts are ongoing to develop “liquid biopsy” assays as minimally invasive tools to address diagnostic, prognostic, and disease monitoring needs in childhood cancer care. Applying these highly sensitive technologies to serial liquid biopsies is expected to advance under...