Is It Really Racism?: The Origins of White Americans' Opposition to Race-Targeted Policies

Published on Jan 21, 1997in Public Opinion Quarterly
· DOI :10.1086/297785
O SearsDavid49
Estimated H-index: 49
Colette van Laar28
Estimated H-index: 28
+ 1 AuthorsRick Kosterman3
Estimated H-index: 3
We address the role of racial antagonism in whites’ opposition to racially-targeted policies. The data come from four surveys selected for their unusually rich measurement of both policy preferences and other racial attitudes: the 1986 and 1992 National Election Studies, the 1994 General Social Survey, and the 1995 Los Angeles County Social Survey. They indicate that such opposition is more strongly rooted in racial antagonism than in non-racial conservatism, that whites tend to respond to quite different racial policies in similar fashion, that racial attitudes affect evaluations of black and ethnocentric white presidential candidates, and that their effects are just as strong among college graduates as among those with no college education. Second, we present evidence that symbolic racism is consistently more powerful than older forms of racial antagonism, and its greater strength does not diminish with controls on non-racial ideology, partisanship, and values. The origins of symbolic racism lie partly in both anti-black antagonism and non-racial conservative attitudes and values, and so mediates their effects on policy preferences, but it explains substantial additional variance by itself, suggesting that it does represent a new form of racism independent of older racial and political attitudes. The findings are each replicated several times with different measures, in different surveys conducted at different times. We also provide new evidence in response to earlier critiques of research on symbolic racism.
  • References (51)
  • Citations (308)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
167 Citations
559 Citations
393 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Arthur H. MillerH-Index: 28
#2Bruce E. GronbeckH-Index: 1
Presidential campaigning in America candidate-generated images in presidential campaigns mass-media images in presidential campaigns images of the voter-citizen in presidential campaigns presidential campaigning and American self-images - agenda for tomorrow's research.
14 Citations
#1Bernd Wittenbrink (U of C: University of Chicago)H-Index: 19
#2Charles M. Judd (CU: University of Colorado Boulder)H-Index: 43
Last. Bernadette Park (CU: University of Colorado Boulder)H-Index: 40
view all 3 authors...
The content of spontaneously activated racial stereotypes among White Americans and the relation of this to more explicit measures of stereotyping and prejudice were investigated. Using a semantic priming paradigm, a prime was presented outside of conscious awareness (BLACK or WHITE), followed by a target stimulus requiring a word-nonword decision. The target stimuli included attributes that varied in valence and stereotypicality for Whites and African Americans. Results showed reliable stereoty...
666 CitationsSource
Perceptions of threat occupy a central place in race relations in Blumer's theory of prejudice but few direct efforts to study such perceptions exist. Extending Blumer's reasoning, we hypothesize that such perceptions are driven by a group's feelings of racial alienation within the larger social order The more that members of a particular racial group feel collectively oppressed and unfairly treated by society, the more likely they are to perceive members of other groups as potential threats. We...
890 CitationsSource
Racial ambivalence theory, modern racism theory, and research on prejudice-related discrepancies all suggest that many Whites have conflicting reactions to Blacks. The present research investigated whether these forms of prejudice-related conflict are distinct by determining (a) the extent of association among measures of each form of conflict and (b) the affective reactions associated with each form of conflict. Results revealed virtually no evidence of overlap among the measures of conflict, a...
59 CitationsSource
#1Jim SidaniusH-Index: 60
#2Felicia Pratto (Stanford University)H-Index: 53
Last. Lawrence D. Bobo (UCLA: University of California, Los Angeles)H-Index: 32
view all 3 authors...
Using data from 3 different samples, the authors found that: (a) the relationships between political conservatism and racism generally increased as a function ofeducational sophistication; however, the relationship between political conservatism and anti-Black affect did not increase with educational sophistication. (b) The correlation between political conservatism and racism could be entirely accounted for by their mutual relationship with social dominance orientation. (c) Generally, the net e...
364 CitationsSource
#1R KinderDonald (UM: University of Michigan)H-Index: 33
#2Lynn M. SandersH-Index: 2
When news of the O.J. Simpson verdict swept across the United States, a nation stood divided as blacks and whites reacted differently to the decision. Seldom has the racial division that permeates American society come so clearly and prominently into view. This book aims to supply the reasons for this division, asserting that racial resentment continues to exist. Despite a parade of recent books optimistically touting the demise of racial hostility in the United States, the authors marshal a wea...
982 Citations
Les AA. s'efforcent de comprendre les attitudes des blancs vis-a-vis des politiques en faveur des minorites ethniques. Ils examinent les theses defendues, en ce domaine, par S. A. Tuch et M. Hughes. Ils s'efforcent de comprendre l'influence du racisme en ce domaine. Ils presentent un certain nombre de donnees collectees aux Etats-Unis en 1985 et en 1986 et examinent l'influence de plusieurs facteurs comme la socialisation, le racisme symbolique, l'attitude vis-a-vis des afro-americains, l'intere...
43 Citations
Objective. Recent race attitude research has focused on the disparity between whites' support for principles of racial equality on the one hand and their intransigence on social policies designed to redress racial inequities on the other, the so-called principle-implementation gap. Whites' views on racial policy issues and the factors that shape these views are examined in this paper. Methods. Attitudes toward racial policies that span a broad political spectrum are modeled using data from two n...
96 Citations
#1Russell H. Fazio (IU: Indiana University)H-Index: 66
#2Joni R. Jackson (IU: Indiana University Bloomington)H-Index: 1
Last. Carol J. Williams (IU: Indiana University Bloomington)H-Index: 4
view all 4 authors...
The research examines an unobtrusive measure of racial attitudes based on the evaluations that are automatically activated from memory on the presentation of Black versus White faces. Study I, which concerned the technique's validity, obtained different attitude estimates for Black and White participants and also revealed that the variability among White participants was predictive of other race-related judgments and behavior. Study 2 concerned the lack of correspondence between the unobtrusive ...
1,676 CitationsSource
In this article, the authors identify three methodological short-comings of the classic Princeton trilogy studies: (a) ambiguity of the instructions given to respondents, (b) no assessment of respondents' level of prejudice, and (c) use of an outdated list of adjectives. These shortcomings are addressed in the authors' assessment of the stereotype and personal beliefs of a sample of University of Wisconsin students. In contrast to the commonly espoused fading stereotype proposition, data suggest...
584 CitationsSource
Cited By308
#1Eran Halperin (HUJI: Hebrew University of Jerusalem)H-Index: 30
#2Noa Schori-Eyal (Interdisciplinary Center Herzliya)H-Index: 7
1 CitationsSource
#1Mikaela H. Smith (OSU: Ohio State University)
#2Catherine Bolzendahl (UCI: University of California, Irvine)H-Index: 13
The lack of US paid parental leave policies has increasingly gained public and political attention. Yet it is unclear whether public support for such a policy will translate to enactment. To better...
#1William J. Scarborough (UNT: University of North Texas)H-Index: 1
#2Allyson L. Holbrook (UIC: University of Illinois at Chicago)H-Index: 20
Research on attitudes toward racial policies has often been limited to a single racial group (e.g., either Whites or Blacks). These studies often focus on the role of self-interest, group-interest, and race consciousness, but this work has operationalized these concepts in different ways when studying White or Black respondents. Using data from a study in which Whites and Blacks living in Chicago were asked their attitudes toward affirmative action, we build on this body of research by using com...
1 CitationsSource
#1Elizabeth Monk-Turner (ODU: Old Dominion University)H-Index: 18
Social scientists have proposed various explanations of why Donald Trump won the 2016 presidential election including racism, dissatisfaction among white collar workers—especially in rust belt states, Russian interference, Facebook ads, and Christian Nationalism. In the current work, we look to Donald Trump’s core base, white evangelicals, to better understand the 2016 election outcome. White evangelicals believe that men and women are different--and that men are natural leaders. Traditional whi...
#1Tessa Ditonto (Iowa State University)H-Index: 5
1 CitationsSource
#1Adam M. Enders (University of Louisville)H-Index: 4
Though most scholars of race and politics agree that old-fashioned racism largely gave way to a new symbolic form of racism over the course of the last half century, there is still disagreement about how to best empirically capture this new form of racism. Racial resentment, perhaps the most popular operationalization of symbolic racism, has been criticized for its overlap with liberal-conservative ideology. Critics argue that racially prejudiced responses to the items that compose the racial re...