TMI (Too much information)! Effects of given information on organic chemistry students’ approaches to solving mechanism tasks

Published on Jan 1, 2019in Chemistry Education Research and Practice2.285
· DOI :10.1039/C8RP00214B
Victoria DeCocq1
Estimated H-index: 1
(MSU: Missouri State University),
Gautam Bhattacharyya2
Estimated H-index: 2
(MSU: Missouri State University)
We report our qualitative study of twenty-four students enrolled in the second-semester of a second-year undergraduate (sophomore-level) organic chemistry course, Organic Two. We asked the research participants to propose the product and electron-pushing mechanism of elementary mechanistic steps in the absence and presence of the corresponding overall transformation. We also asked the students about their preferences of representational systems when working on tasks common to Organic Two to ascertain the extent to which an external representation, rather than a task, might evoke a problem-solving strategy. In addition to familiarity to instructional materials, the main reason for which the students preferred line-angle formulas for nearly all of the task types is that the representational system allowed them most readily extract relevant, or otherwise useful, information without distracting them. However, line-angle formulas did not seem to cue students to the three-dimensional attributes of molecules; only dash-and-wedge structures and Newman and chair conformers did so. For the electron-pushing tasks, the research participants’ reasoning processes included at least some chemical characteristics of the species involved in the transformation when they were not given the product of reaction. When provided with the overall transformation, however, the students changed their focus to getting to the product. Consequently, they replaced correct answers with incorrect ones when given the reaction products. These results raise the possibility that traditional mechanism tasks may mask students’ mechanistic reasoning ability.
  • References (37)
  • Citations (3)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
65 Citations
1 Author (Carl Bereiter)
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1I. Caspari (University of Giessen)H-Index: 2
#2M. L. Weinrich (University of Massachusetts Boston)H-Index: 5
Last. Nicole Graulich (University of Giessen)H-Index: 6
view all 4 authors...
If an organic chemistry student explains that she represents a mechanistic step because “it's a productive part of the mechanism,” what meaning could the professor teaching the class attribute to this statement, what is actually communicated, and what does it mean for the student? The professor might think that the explanation is based on knowledge of equilibria of alternative steps. The professor might also assume that the student implies information about how one of the alternatives influences...
6 CitationsSource
We report our research of seven pairs of students enrolled in the second semester of sophomore-level organic chemistry as they attempted to describe (in their own words) and draw, respectively, three electron-pushing diagrams of three-step reaction mechanisms. The tasks’ objective was to accurately reproduce the diagrams based solely on the mechanistic language descriptions, because the goals of this research were to identify characteristics of effective descriptions and to describe factors that...
5 CitationsSource
#1Kelli R. Galloway (U of O: University of Ottawa)H-Index: 3
#2Carlee Stoyanovich (U of O: University of Ottawa)H-Index: 2
Last. Alison B. Flynn (U of O: University of Ottawa)H-Index: 10
view all 3 authors...
Research on mechanistic thinking in organic chemistry has shown that students attribute little meaning to the electron-pushing (i.e., curved arrow) formalism. At the University of Ottawa, a new curriculum has been developed in which students are taught the electron-pushing formalism prior to instruction on specific reactions—this formalism is part of organic chemistry's language. Students then learn reactions according to the pattern of their governing mechanism and in order of increasing comple...
10 CitationsSource
Organic synthesis problems require the solver to integrate knowledge and skills from many parts of their courses. Without a well-defined, systematic method for approaching them, even the strongest students can experience difficulties. Our research goal was to identify the most successful problem-solving strategies and develop associated teaching models and learning activities. Specifically we asked: (1) What problem-solving strategies do undergraduate students use when solving synthesis-type pro...
7 CitationsSource
#1Mary E. Anzovino (Miami University)H-Index: 4
#2Stacey Lowery Bretz (Miami University)H-Index: 19
Organic chemistry students struggle with reaction mechanisms and the electron-pushing formalism (EPF) used by practicing organic chemists. Faculty have identified an understanding of nucleophiles and electrophiles as one conceptual prerequisite to mastery of the EPF, but little is known about organic chemistry students' knowledge of nucleophiles and electrophiles. This research explored the ideas held by second-semester organic chemistry students about nucleophiles and electrophiles, finding tha...
17 CitationsSource
A significant redesign of the introductory organic chemistry curriculum at the authors’ institution is described. There are two aspects that differ greatly from a typical functional group approach. First, organic reaction mechanisms and the electron-pushing formalism are taught before students have learned a single reaction. The conservation of electrons, atoms, and formal charges, how the use of curved arrows helps describe the mechanism, and how to predict reaction mechanisms are emphasized. S...
27 CitationsSource
Using a constructivist framework, eight senior chemistry majors were interviewed twice to determine: (i) structural inferences they are able to make from chemical and physical properties; and (ii) their ability to apply their inferences and understandings of these chemical and physical properties to solve tasks on the reactivity of organic compounds. The latter included predicting the behaviors of natural products under acidic, basic, nucleophilic, and electrophilic reaction conditions and desig...
19 CitationsSource
The skill of proposing mechanisms of reactions using the electron-pushing formalism (EPF) is not only of value to practicing organic chemists but it is also emphasized to students enrolled in organic chemistry courses at all levels. Several research studies in the past decade have documented the difficulties that undergraduate, and even graduate students, encounter when trying to propose mechanisms using the EPF. An examination of this work suggests the emergence of a preliminary, but coherent, ...
22 CitationsSource
#1Daniel Cruz-Ramirez de Arellano (USF: University of South Florida)H-Index: 2
#2Marcy H. Towns (Purdue University)H-Index: 19
Organic chemistry is an essential subject for many undergraduate students completing degrees in science, engineering, and pre-professional programs. However, students often struggle with the concepts and skills required to successfully solve organic chemistry exercises. Since alkyl halides are traditionally the first functional group that is studied in undergraduate organic chemistry courses, establishing a robust understanding of the concepts and reactions related to them can be beneficial in a...
20 CitationsSource
#1Nathaniel P. Grove (UNCW: University of North Carolina at Wilmington)H-Index: 8
#2Stacey Lowery Bretz (Miami University)H-Index: 19
The Assimilation Theory of Ausubel and Novak has typically been used in the research literature to describe two extremes to learning chemistry: meaningful learning versus rote memorization. It is unlikely, however, that such discrete categories of learning exist. Rote and meaningful learning, rather, are endpoints along a continuum of learning. This paper reports the results of a qualitative investigation of students' experiences in a spiral, organic chemistry curriculum, specifically describing...
40 CitationsSource
Cited By3
#1Nicole Graulich (University of Giessen)H-Index: 6
#2Sebastian Hedtrich (University of Giessen)
Last. René Harzenetter (University of Giessen)
view all 3 authors...
Learning to interpret organic structures not as an arrangement of lines and letters but, rather, as a representation of chemical entities is a challenge in organic chemistry. To successfully deal with the variety of molecules or mechanistic representations, a learner needs to understand how a representation depicts domain-specific information. Various studies that focused on representational competence have already investigated how learners relate a representation to its corresponding concept. H...
#1Alison B. Flynn (U of O: University of Ottawa)H-Index: 10
#1Amanda Bongers (U of O: University of Ottawa)
#2Georg Northoff (U of O: University of Ottawa)H-Index: 58
Last. Alison B. Flynn (U of O: University of Ottawa)H-Index: 10
view all 3 authors...
Creating and using models are essential skills in chemistry. Novices and experts alike rely on conceptual models to build their own personal mental models for predicting and explaining molecular processes. There is evidence that chemistry students lack rich mental models of the molecular level; their mental models of reaction mechanisms have often been described as static and not process-oriented. Our goal in this study was to characterize the various mental models students may have when learnin...