Integrating evidence, politics and society: a methodology for the science–policy interface

Published on Dec 1, 2018in Palgrave Communications
· DOI :10.1057/s41599-018-0099-3
Peter Horton81
Estimated H-index: 81
(University of Sheffield),
Garrett W. Brown1
Estimated H-index: 1
(University of Leeds)
There is currently intense debate over expertise, evidence and ‘post-truth’ politics, and how this is influencing policy formulation and implementation. In this article, we put forward a methodology for evidence-based policy making intended as a way of helping navigate this web of complexity. Starting from the premise of why it is so crucial that policies to meet major global challenges use scientific evidence, we discuss the socio-political difficulties and complexities that hinder this process. We discuss the necessity of embracing a broader view of what constitutes evidence—science and the evaluation of scientific evidence cannot be divorced from the political, cultural and social debate that inevitably and justifiably surrounds these major issues. As a pre-requisite for effective policy making, we propose a methodology that fully integrates scientific investigation with political debate and social discourse. We describe a rigorous process of mapping, analysis, visualisation and sharing of evidence, constructed from integrating science and social science data. This would then be followed by transparent evidence evaluation, combining independent assessment to test the validity and completeness of the evidence with deliberation to discover how the evidence is perceived, misunderstood or ignored. We outline the opportunities and the problems derived from the use of digital communications, including social media, in this methodology, and emphasise the power of creative and innovative evidence visualisation and sharing in shaping policy.
Figures & Tables
  • References (18)
  • Citations (4)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
182 Citations
1 Author (Odelia Funke)
2 Citations
7 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Julie Lucero (UNR: University of Nevada, Reno)H-Index: 13
#2Nina Wallerstein (UNM: University of New Mexico)H-Index: 34
Last. Malia VillegasH-Index: 6
view all 12 authors...
This article describes a mixed methods study of community-based participatory research (CBPR) partnership practices and the links between these practices and changes in health status and disparities outcomes. Directed by a CBPR conceptual model and grounded in indigenous-transformative theory, our nation-wide, cross-site study showcases the value of a mixed methods approach for better understanding the complexity of CBPR partnerships across diverse community and research contexts. The article th...
44 CitationsSource
#1Dustin Garrick (University of Oxford)H-Index: 20
#2Jim W. Hall (University of Oxford)H-Index: 50
Last. Alex L. N. Money (University of Oxford)H-Index: 3
view all 13 authors...
Achieving universal, safely managed water and sanitation services by 2030, as envisioned by the United Nations (UN) Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 6, is projected to require capital expenditures of USD 114 billion per year ( 1 ). Investment on that scale, along with accompanying policy reforms, can be motivated by a growing appreciation of the value of water. Yet our ability to value water, and incorporate these values into water governance, is inadequate. Newly recognized cascading negative...
28 CitationsSource
#1Ruth S. DeFries (Columbia University)H-Index: 87
#2Harini Nagendra (Azim Premji University)H-Index: 44
Ecosystems are self-regulating systems that provide societies with food, water, timber, and other resources. As demands for resources increase, management decisions are replacing self-regulating properties. Counter to previous technical approaches that applied simple formulas to estimate sustainable yields of single species, current research recognizes the inherent complexity of ecosystems and the inability to foresee all consequences of interventions across different spatial, temporal, and admi...
65 CitationsSource
#1Johan Rockström (Stockholm Resilience Centre)H-Index: 65
#2Owen Gaffney (Stockholm Resilience Centre)H-Index: 8
Last. Hans Joachim Schellnhuber (PIK: Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research)H-Index: 59
view all 6 authors...
Although the Paris Agreement's goals (1) are aligned with science (2) and can, in principle, be technically and economically achieved (3), alarming inconsistencies remain between science-based targets and national commitments. Despite progress during the 2016 Marrakech climate negotiations, long-term goals can be trumped by political short-termism. Following the Agreement, which became international law earlier than expected, several countries published mid-century decarbonization strategies, wi...
249 CitationsSource
#1Michael A. Neblo (OSU: Ohio State University)H-Index: 13
#2William Minozzi (OSU: Ohio State University)H-Index: 8
Last. David Lazer (NU: Northeastern University)H-Index: 39
view all 6 authors...
The bitterly factious 2016 U.S. presidential election campaign was the culmination of several trends that, taken together, constitute a syndrome of chronic ailments in the body politic. Ironically, these destructive trends have accelerated just as science has rapidly improved our understanding of them and their underlying causes. But mere understanding is not sufficient to repair our politics. The challenge is to build a translational science of democracy that maintains scientific rigor while ac...
7 CitationsSource
#1L. Goucher (University of Sheffield)H-Index: 1
#2Richard Bruce (University of Sheffield)H-Index: 2
Last. Peter Horton (University of Sheffield)H-Index: 81
view all 5 authors...
Food production causes a third of global greenhouse gas emissions. This life-cycle assessment of the supply chain of a loaf of bread finds that over half of its environmental impacts arise from wheat cultivation, with 40% from the use of nitrate fertiliser.
20 CitationsSource
#1Peter Horton (University of Sheffield)H-Index: 81
#2Steve Banwart (University of Sheffield)H-Index: 4
Last. Peter Jackson (University of Sheffield)H-Index: 44
view all 10 authors...
This paper outlines the development of an integrated interdisciplinary approach to agri-food research, designed to address the ‘grand challenge’ of global food security. Rather than meeting this challenge by working in separate domains or via single-disciplinary perspectives, we chart the development of a system-wide approach to the food supply chain. In this approach, social and environmental questions are simultaneously addressed. Firstly, we provide a holistic model of the agri-food system, w...
15 CitationsSource
This is a worrying time for those who believe government policies should be based on the best evidence. Pundits claim we9ve entered a postfactual era. Viral fake news stories spread alternative facts. On some issues, such as climate change and childhood vaccinations, many scientists worry their hard-won research findings have lost sway with politicians and the public, and feel their veracity is under attack. But just how should evidence shape policy? And why does it sometimes lose out? Those are...
13 CitationsSource
Malaria![Figure][1] Anopheles gambiae mosquitoes spread malaria but do not become sick themselves. IMAGE: ZHANG ET AL. ; © ALEX WILD Mosquitoes can transmit serious human diseases, including malaria. Why does the mosquito itself not succumb to infection? Castillo et al. studied the
1 CitationsSource
Synthetic Biology Unnatural amino acids can be incorporated into target proteins by using a transfer RNA (tRNA)—aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase pair that adds an unnatural amino acid at an amber stop codon. The strategy has been used in prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells and for generating transgenic invertebrates. Chen et al. have succeeded in integrating a construct coding for the unnatural amino acid p -azido-phenylalanine (AzF) into the mouse genome. The artificial gene was transmitted to subsequent...
1 CitationsSource
Cited By4
#1Zewelanji N. Serpell (VCU: Virginia Commonwealth University)H-Index: 11
AbstractThere is an ongoing debate about how best to infuse “evidence” into school evaluation and reform efforts, and what role education researchers can play in this effort. A lot of support has b...
#2Nicholas King (NWU: North-West University)H-Index: 3
Last. A. Meter
view all 5 authors...
ABSTRACTThe Intergovernmental Science–Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (IPBES) is an independent scientific body focused on assessing the state of the world’s ecosystem servic...
4 CitationsSource
#1Peter Horton (University of Sheffield)H-Index: 81
#2Richard Bruce (University of Sheffield)H-Index: 2
Last. Gavin MilliganH-Index: 1
view all 4 authors...
Achieving global food security requires a new approach that integrates not only all aspects of the growing, harvesting and processing of food (necessary to ensure sufficient affordable and sustainable production to alleviate hunger) but also the complexities associated with food consumption including deterring unhealthy overconsumption. Inefficiencies occur at various points along the agri-food supply chain but at present they are inadequately conceptualized via separate accounts of food loss, f...
1 CitationsSource
#1Peter Horton (University of Sheffield)H-Index: 81
#2Benjamin P. Horton (NTU: Nanyang Technological University)H-Index: 51
The increasing frequency of extreme weather events, urban air pollution, and contamination of oceans by plastic waste have dramatically increased awareness that human civilization faces an existential environmental crisis. Here, we argue that the way humankind views its place on planet Earth is the cause of this crisis and of the reluctance to take meaningful and urgent action. This view gives humans the right to exploit everything on Earth for their own benefit and a belief that sustainability ...
#1Bev MackenzieH-Index: 1
#2Louis CelliersH-Index: 1
Last. Eric Terrill (SIO: Scripps Institution of Oceanography)H-Index: 22
view all 32 authors...
The importance of stakeholder engagement in ocean observation and in particular the realization of economic and societal benefits is discussed, introducing a number of overarching principles such as the convergence on common goals, effective communication, co-production of information and knowledge and the need for innovation. A series of case studies examine the role of coordinating frameworks such as the US’s Interagency Ocean Observing System (IOOS®), and the European Ocean Observing System (...
2 CitationsSource
#1Rosário Couto Costa (ISCTE-IUL: ISCTE – University Institute of Lisbon)H-Index: 1
Over the past four decades, the humanities have been subject to a progressive devaluation within the academic world, with early instances of this phenomenon tracing back to the USA and the UK. There are several clues as to how the university has generally been placing a lower importance on these fields, such as through the elimination of courses or even whole departments. It is worth mentioning that this discrimination against humanities degrees is indirect in nature, as it is in fact mostly the...