Can the AML system be evaluated without better data

Published on Mar 1, 2018in Crime Law and Social Change0.952
· DOI :10.1007/s10611-017-9757-4
Michael Levi29
Estimated H-index: 29
(Cardiff University),
Peter Reuter42
Estimated H-index: 42
(UMD: University of Maryland, College Park),
Terence C. Halliday9
Estimated H-index: 9
(American Bar Foundation)
The Anti-Money Laundering regime has been important in harmonizing laws and institutions, and has received global political support. Yet there has been minimal effort at evaluation of how well any AML intervention does in achieving its goals. There are no credible estimates either of the total amount laundered (globally or nationally) nor of most of the specific serious harms that AML aims to avert. Consequently, reduction of these is not a plausible outcome measure. There have been few efforts by country evaluators in the FATF Mutual Evaluation Reports (MERs) to acquire qualitative data or seriously analyze either quantitative or qualitative data. We find that data are relatively unimportant in policy development and implementation. Moreover, the long gaps of about 8 years between evaluations mean that widely used ‘country risk’ models for AML are forced still to rely largely on the 3rd Round evaluations whose use of data was minimal and inconsistent. While the 4th round MERs (2014–2022) have made an effort to be more systematic in the collection and analysis of data, FATF has still not established procedures that provide sufficiently informative evaluations. Our analysis of five recent National Risk Assessments (a major component of the new evaluations) in major countries shows little use of data, though the UK is notably better than the others. In the absence of more consistent and systematic data analysis, claims that countries have less or more effective systems will be open to allegations of ad hoc, impressionistic or politicized judgments. This reduces their perceived legitimacy, though this does not mean that the AML efforts and the evaluation processes themselves have no effects.
  • References (28)
  • Citations (5)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
9 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Mark T. Nance (NCSU: North Carolina State University)H-Index: 6
Most explanations of the Financial Action Task Force argue that material coercion plays a key role in the consolidation and diffusion of the global anti-money laundering regime. This paper looks carefully at the decision-making within FATF and argues that, at its most impactful, FATF operates in line with the principles of “experimentalist governance.” Experimentalism emphasizes broad, participatory standard setting, contextualized implementation, intensive but diagnostic monitoring, and routini...
2 CitationsSource
#1Richard WrightH-Index: 19
#2Scott JacquesH-Index: 13
Last. Michael SteinH-Index: 2
view all 3 authors...
2 CitationsSource
#1Jeff FerrellH-Index: 15
2 CitationsSource
#1John HeathershawH-Index: 11
20 Citations
8 Citations
Trends in police-recorded and (where they exist) household survey-measured cybercrimes for economic gain are reviewed in a range of developed countries – Australia, Canada, Germany, Hong Kong, the Netherlands, Sweden, the UK and the US - and their implications for criminal policy are considered. The datasets indicate a substantial rise in online fraud – though one that is lower than the rise in online shopping and other ‘routine activity’ indicators - but it is not obvious whether this is just d...
15 CitationsSource
#1Ioana Deleanu (Yale University)H-Index: 4
Indicators of compliance and efficiency in combatting money laundering, collected by EUROSTAT, are plagued with shortcomings. In this paper, I have carried out a forensic analysis on a 2003–2010 dataset of indicators of compliance and efficiency in combatting money laundering, that European Union member states self-reported to EUROSTAT, and on the basis of which, their efforts were evaluated. I used Benford’s law to detect any anomalous statistical patterns and found that statistical anomalies w...
4 CitationsSource
#1Joras FerwerdaH-Index: 8
Thirty years ago the US criminalized money laundering. Quickly after that, all countries in the world were asked to join an international fight against money laundering. At the moment, basically all countries in the world have money laundering and its financial regulations on their policy agenda. Although money laundering has always been a hot topic, after the 9/11 terrorist attacks in 2001 its financial regulations received even more attention. But how much do we really know about money launder...
15 Citations
This article analyses the social construction of the problem of organised crime and associated problems of measurement. It reports on a study conducted for the European Parliament which had three principal aims:1. To produce a critical assessment of the state-of-the-art in terms of what is and is not known about the prevalence and distribution of different forms of organised crime.2. To set out a robust conceptual framework which would enable us to think more clearly and coherently about the cos...
5 CitationsSource
#1Peter AlldridgeH-Index: 7
6 Citations
Cited By5
Fighting financial crime is a highly institutionalised global governance task. At a time of crisis for many of the institutions of global governance, tackling money laundering and combatting terrorist financing through global cooperation continues to be a priority for public officials. The global regime, if anything, is intensifying. This essay provides an overview of the regime’s development and addresses questions of design and implementation. It is structured around three sets of questions: (...
#1Ronald F. Pol (La Trobe University)
AbstractThis paper uses anti-money laundering as a case study to illustrate the benefits of cross-disciplinary engagement when major policymaking functions develop separately from public policy des...
#1Ilaria Zavoli (University of Leeds)
#2Colin King (Lond: University of London)
Last. Colin King (Lond: University of London)H-Index: 3
view all 2 authors...
ABSTRACTIn recent years, money laundering in the property market has come under scrutiny across the world, attracting significant attention from governments, regulators, policy-makers, NGOs, academ...
1 CitationsSource
The purpose of this paper is to utilise underused information in anti-money laundering rating data to assist policymaking and research.,This paper explores what evidence “hidden in plain sight” in official anti-money laundering rating data reveals about claims justifying the expansion of money laundering controls in response to European bank scandals.,A perceived lack of international coordination influencing the policy response to a series of alleged anti-money laundering breaches does not acco...
1 CitationsSource
This paper aims to increase the transparency of information in official anti-money laundering rating data to assist evidence-informed decision-making in compliance, policy-making and research.,This paper converts anti-money laundering rating data into information-rich visualisations, reintroduces a comparison methodology and ranks all anti-money laundering regimes evaluated to date.,Official anti-money laundering ratings as currently structured and presented offer surprisingly little policy-rele...
2 CitationsSource
#1Trevor Jones (Cardiff University)H-Index: 27
#2Jarrett Blaustein (Monash University)H-Index: 5
Last. Tim Newburn (LSE: London School of Economics and Political Science)H-Index: 37
view all 3 authors...
The empirical study of ‘policy transfer’ and related topics remains a relatively rare enterprise in criminology. Comparative studies of crime control policy tend to focus on broader structural expl...
#1Edgar Alonso Lopez-Rojas (NTNU: Norwegian University of Science and Technology)H-Index: 5
Financial transactions lay up the foundation of modern society. Unfortunately, illicit abuse of the financial system is pervasive. Fraud controls aim to detect these suspicious activities, but they require deep analysis to model their efficacy and value proposition. Due to the private nature and scale of these financial transactions, this analysis is often performed in hindsight. Financial institutions lack of information, due to the hidden fraud problem, to properly set and tune their fraud con...
#1Joras FerwerdaH-Index: 8
#2Ioana DeleanuH-Index: 4
Last. Brigitte UngerH-Index: 15
view all 3 authors...
Financial and legal entities (e.g. banks, casinos, notaries etc.) have to report money laundering suspicions. Countries’ engagement in fighting money laundering is evaluated–among others–with statistics on how often these suspicions are reported. Lack of compliance can result in economically harmful blacklisting. Nevertheless, these blacklists repeatedly become empty–in what is known as the emptying blacklist paradox. We develop a principal-agent model with intermediate agents and show that non-...