Interpreting variation to advance predictive restoration science

Published on Aug 1, 2017in Journal of Applied Ecology5.782
· DOI :10.1111/1365-2664.12938
Lars A. Brudvig24
Estimated H-index: 24
(MSU: Michigan State University),
Rebecca S. Barak5
Estimated H-index: 5
(NU: Northwestern University)
+ 7 AuthorsChad R. Zirbel5
Estimated H-index: 5
(MSU: Michigan State University)
Summary Ecological restoration is a global priority that holds great potential for benefiting natural ecosystems, but restoration outcomes are notoriously unpredictable. Resolving this unpredictability represents a major, but critical challenge to the science of restoration ecology. In an effort to move restoration ecology toward a more predictive science, we consider the key issue of variability. Typically, restoration outcomes vary relative to goals (i.e. reference or desired future conditions) and with respect to the outcomes of other restoration efforts. The field of restoration ecology has largely considered only this first type of variation, often focusing on an oversimplified success vs. failure dichotomy. The causes of variation, particularly among restoration efforts, remain poorly understood for most systems. Variation associated with restoration outcomes is a consequence of how, where and when restoration is conducted; variation is also influenced by how the outcome of restoration is measured. We propose that variation should decrease with the number of factors constraining restoration and increase with the specificity of the goal. When factors (e.g. harsh environmental conditions, limited species reintroductions) preclude most species, little variation will exist among restorations, particularly when goals are associated with metrics such as physical structure, where species may be broadly interchangeable. Conversely, when few constraints to species membership exist, substantial variation may result and this will be most pronounced when restoration is assessed by metrics such as taxonomic composition. Synthesis and applications. The variability we observe during restoration results from both restoration context (how, where and when restoration is conducted) and how we evaluate restoration outcomes. To advance the predictive capacity of restoration, we outline a research agenda that considers metrics of restoration outcomes, the drivers of variation among existing restoration efforts, experiments to quantify and understand variation in restoration outcomes, and the development of models to organise, interpret and forecast restoration outcomes.
Figures & Tables
  • References (102)
  • Citations (41)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
409 Citations
158 Citations
143 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Daniel C. Laughlin (UW: University of Wyoming)H-Index: 31
#2Robert T. Strahan (New Mexico Highlands University)H-Index: 4
Last. W. Wallace Covington (NAU: Northern Arizona University)H-Index: 46
view all 6 authors...
15 CitationsSource
#1Nash E. Turley (MSU: Michigan State University)H-Index: 11
#2John L. Orrock (UW: University of Wisconsin-Madison)H-Index: 39
Last. Lars A. Brudvig (MSU: Michigan State University)H-Index: 24
view all 4 authors...
15 CitationsSource
#1Rebecca S. Barak (NU: Northwestern University)H-Index: 5
#2Evelyn W. WilliamsH-Index: 5
Last. Daniel J. Larkin (UMN: University of Minnesota)H-Index: 14
view all 7 authors...
Summary Ecological restoration is critical for mitigating habitat loss and providing ecosystem services. However, restorations often have lower diversity than remnant, reference sites. Phylogenetic diversity is an important component of biodiversity and ecosystem function that has only recently been used to evaluate restoration outcomes. To move towards prediction in the restoration of biodiversity, it is necessary to understand how phylogenetic diversity of restorations compares with that of re...
16 CitationsSource
#1Katharine L. Stuble (UC Davis: University of California, Davis)H-Index: 14
#2Stephen E. Fick (UC Davis: University of California, Davis)H-Index: 8
Last. Truman P. Young (UC Davis: University of California, Davis)H-Index: 53
view all 3 authors...
Summary The outcomes of restoration efforts are contingent on the specifics of the restoration practices utilized, but also on uncontrolled contingencies such as site effects and year effects. Although restoration practitioners have long been aware that the successes of their projects vary from site to site and from year to year, there have been few direct experimental tests of these contingencies. We established grassland restoration plots identically across three sites in northern California, ...
27 CitationsSource
#1Karen D. Holl (UCSC: University of California, Santa Cruz)H-Index: 40
#2John Leighton Reid (Missouri Botanical Garden)H-Index: 3
Last. Rakan A. Zahawi (Organization for Tropical Studies)H-Index: 22
view all 5 authors...
Summary Developing restoration strategies that accelerate natural successional processes and are resource-efficient is critical to facilitating tropical forest recovery across millions of hectares of deforested lands in the tropics. We compared tree recruitment after a decade in three restoration treatments (natural regeneration, applied nucleation/island tree planting and plantation) and nearby reference forest in the premontane rain forest zone in southern Costa Rica. The study was replicated ...
22 CitationsSource
#1Loralee Larios (UM: University of Montana)H-Index: 8
#2Lauren M. Hallett (UO: University of Oregon)H-Index: 16
Last. Katharine N. Suding (INSTAAR: Institute of Arctic and Alpine Research)H-Index: 42
view all 3 authors...
Summary Managers are increasingly looking to apply concepts of resilience to better anticipate and understand conservation and restoration in a changing environment. In this study, we explore how information on demography (recruitment, growth and survival) and competitive effects in different environments and with different starting species abundances can be used to better understand resilience. We use observational and experimental data to better understand dynamics between native Stipa pulchra...
7 CitationsSource
#1Chad R. Zirbel (MSU: Michigan State University)H-Index: 5
#2Tyler Bassett (MSU: Michigan State University)H-Index: 4
Last. Lars A. Brudvig (MSU: Michigan State University)H-Index: 24
view all 4 authors...
Summary Recovering biological diversity and ecosystem functioning are primary objectives of ecological restoration, yet these outcomes are often unpredictable. Assessments based on functional traits may help with interpreting variability in both community composition and ecosystem functioning because of their mechanistic and generalizable nature. This promise remains poorly realized, however, because tests linking environmental conditions, functional traits, and ecosystem functioning in restorat...
22 CitationsSource
#1Caroline M. Tucker (CU: University of Colorado Boulder)H-Index: 13
#2Marc W. Cadotte (SYSU: Sun Yat-sen University)H-Index: 43
Last. Florent Mazel (CNRS: Centre national de la recherche scientifique)H-Index: 13
view all 16 authors...
The use of phylogenies in ecology is increasingly common and has broadened our understanding of biological diversity. Ecological sub-disciplines, particularly conservation, community ecology and macroecology, all recognize the value of evolutionary relationships but the resulting development of phylogenetic approaches has led to a proliferation of phylogenetic diversity metrics. The use of many metrics across the sub-disciplines hampers potential meta-analyses, syntheses, and generalizations of ...
175 CitationsSource
#1Nicholas A. Barber (NIU: Northern Illinois University)H-Index: 15
#2Holly P. Jones (NIU: Northern Illinois University)H-Index: 18
Last. David J. Gibson (SIU: Southern Illinois University Carbondale)H-Index: 14
view all 6 authors...
18 CitationsSource
#1Robin L. Chazdon (UConn: University of Connecticut)H-Index: 67
#2Pedro H. S. Brancalion (USP: University of São Paulo)H-Index: 25
Last. Chetan Kumar (IUCN: International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources)H-Index: 4
view all 6 authors...
The global restoration movement is gaining momentum. International and national leaders are demonstrating unparalleled political will for achieving ambitious targets. However, the knowledge base for implementing large-scale forest and landscape restoration (FLR) needs further development. Besides application of scientific and local knowledge, a broad understanding of the social, economic, and environmental context in which this knowledge is being applied is also needed. To address knowledge gaps...
86 CitationsSource
Cited By41
#1Laura M. LadwigH-Index: 12
#2Chad R. Zirbel (UMN: University of Minnesota)H-Index: 5
Last. Ellen I. DamschenH-Index: 29
view all 4 authors...
Abstract Ecological restoration offers an effective way to promote recovery of natural communities and is particularly important for ecosystems that have experienced extensive habitat loss, such as oak savannas in the Midwestern USA. Seeds are commonly added to restoration sites to introduce desired species, but the identity and composition of which species are included in seed mixes varies greatly and may be influenced more by seed availability and cost rather than historic prevalence or ecolog...
#1Anna M. Groves (MSU: Michigan State University)H-Index: 2
#2Jonathan T. Bauer (Miami University)
Last. Lars A. Brudvig (MSU: Michigan State University)H-Index: 24
view all 3 authors...
Ecological restoration — the rebuilding of damaged or destroyed ecosystems — is a critical component of conservation efforts, but is hindered by inconsistent, unpredictable outcomes. We investigated a source of this variation that is anecdotally suggested by practitioners, but for which empirical evidence is rare: the weather conditions during the first growing season after planting. The idea of whether natural communities face long-term consequences from conditions even many years in the past, ...
#2Joan Pino (Autonomous University of Barcelona)H-Index: 32
Last. Josep Maria Espelta (Autonomous University of Barcelona)H-Index: 24
view all 7 authors...
Insect herbivory in novel Quercus ilex L. forests is a highly context- and scale-dependent process. We show that forest composition, tree height and fine-scale spatial location, as well as tree genetic relatedness and ontogeny, can all influence herbivore activity at local to landscape scale. Understanding the intrinsic and extrinsic drivers of herbivory in novel expanding forests is essential to envisage their role for biodiversity conservation. To analyse the effects of landscape attributes, f...
#1Kirk W. Davies (ARS: Agricultural Research Service)H-Index: 29
#2Jon D. Bates (ARS: Agricultural Research Service)H-Index: 14
Last. D. Clenet (OSU: Oregon State University)
view all 3 authors...
1 CitationsSource
#2Luke B. B. Hecht (Durham University)
Last. Samniqueka J. Halsey (MU: University of Missouri)
view all 3 authors...
The restoration community continues to discuss what constitutes good environmental stewardship. One area of tension is the extent to which the wellbeing of wild animals should inform restoration efforts. We discuss three ways that the perspective of wild animal welfare can augment restoration ecology: strengthening people's relationship with nature, reinforcing biotic integrity, and reducing mechanistic uncertainty. The animal welfare movement elevates sentient animals as stakeholders and explor...
#1Liz KoziolH-Index: 7
#2Timothy E. CrewsH-Index: 13
Last. James D. BeverH-Index: 53
view all 3 authors...
#1Knut RydgrenH-Index: 23
#2Inger AuestadH-Index: 7
Last. Jan Sulavik (AMNH: American Museum of Natural History)H-Index: 1
view all 7 authors...
#1Chad R. Zirbel (MSU: Michigan State University)H-Index: 5
#2Lars A. Brudvig (MSU: Michigan State University)H-Index: 24
Establishment and persistence are central to community assembly and are determined by how traits interact with the environment to determine performance (trait-environment interactions). Community assembly studies have rarely considered such trait-environment interactions, however, which can lead to incorrect inferences about how traits affect assembly. We evaluated how functional traits, environmental conditions, and trait-environment interactions structure plant establishment, as a measure of p...
#1Jeremy J. James (University of California, Berkeley)H-Index: 27
#2Roger L. Sheley (ARS: Agricultural Research Service)H-Index: 25
Last. Matthew J. Rinella (ARS: Agricultural Research Service)H-Index: 17
view all 7 authors...
1 CitationsSource
#1Christine B. Rohal (UF: University of Florida)
#1Christine Rohal (UF: University of Florida)H-Index: 1
Last. Karin M. Kettenring (USU: Utah State University)H-Index: 21
view all 4 authors...
The outcomes of invasive plant removal efforts are influenced by management decisions, but are also contingent on the uncontrolled spatial and temporal context of management areas. Phragmites australis is an aggressive invader that is intensively managed in wetlands across North America. Treatment options have been understudied, and the ecological contingencies of management outcomes are poorly understood. We implemented a 5-year, multi-site experiment to evaluate six Phragmites management treat...
1 CitationsSource