Inventing the University

Published on Jan 1, 2005
· DOI :10.1007/978-1-4039-8439-5_4
David Bartholomae11
Estimated H-index: 11
(University of Pittsburgh)
Every time a student sits down to write for us, he has to invent the university for the occasion — invent the university, that is, or a branch of it, like history or anthropology or economics or English. The student has to learn to speak our language, to speak as we do, to try on the peculiar ways of knowing, selecting, evaluating, reporting, concluding, and arguing that define the discourse of our community. Or perhaps I should say the various discourses of our community, since it is in the nature of a liberal arts education that a student, after the first year or two, must learn to try on a variety of voices and interpretive schemes — to write, for example, as a literary critic one day and as an experimental psychologist the next; to work within fields where the rules governing the presentation of examples or the development of an argument are both distinct and, even to a professional mysterious.
  • References (14)
  • Citations (396)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
1 Author (John M. Swales)
3,853 Citations
1 Author (Roz Ivanič)
979 Citations
29.9k Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1David Bartholomae (University of Pittsburgh)H-Index: 11
I want to use this occasion1 to work on the paradox at the center of this passage from Beginnings: to begin to write is to “know” what cannot be known. It has become commonplace for English teachers to talk of writing as a “mode of learning,” or of writing as “discovery.” And it has become common to represent the writer’s struggle as a struggle for realization: “How can I know what I mean until I see what I’ve said?” This representation of writing is conventionally in service of a pedagogy whose...
8 CitationsSource
#1David Bartholomae (University of Pittsburgh)H-Index: 11
At the University of Pittsburgh, we teach Basic Writing to around 1,200 students each year. The instruction is offered through two different courses — Basic Writing (3 hours, 3 credits) and Basic Reading and Writing (6 hours, 6 credits). We also have a Writing Workshop, and basic writers frequently attend, but their attendance is voluntary, and the workshop is not specifically for writers with basic problems.
20 CitationsSource
55 CitationsSource
Many of our attempts to help college remedialI writers, attempts that are often well-intentioned and seemingly commonsensical, may, in fact, be ineffective, even counterproductive, for these attempts reduce, fragment, and possibly misrepresent the composing process. I believe we may be limiting growth in writing in five not unrelated ways. 1) Our remedial courses are self-contained; that is, they have little conceptual or practical connection to the larger academic writing environment in which o...
69 CitationsSource
#1Patricia BizzellH-Index: 16
#2Janice M. LauerH-Index: 2
Last. Finbarr W. O'ConnorH-Index: 3
view all 10 authors...
39 CitationsSource
#1George M. BlancoH-Index: 1
#2Richard RodriguezH-Index: 10
119 Citations
There is a venerable tradition in rhetoric and composition which sees the composing process as a series of decisions and choices.1 However, it is no longer easy simply to assert this position, unless you are prepared to answer a number of questions, the most pressing of which probably is: "What then are the criteria which govern that choice?" Or we could put it another way: "What guides the decisions writers make as they write?" In a recent survey of composition research, Odell, Cooper, and Cour...
1,941 CitationsSource
In The Philosophy of Composition, E. D. Hirsch translates his theories of literary criticism into principles of composition teaching.' In his critical books, Validity in Interpretation (1967) and The Aims of Interpretation (1976), Hirsch champions an anti-relativistic critical position. He opposes the purportedly objective explication of literary texts by formal methods, from the New Criticism to Derridean deconstruction. When the text is detached from the conditions of its creation, he argues, ...
4 CitationsSource
In 1976, when I was struggling with a bewildering explosion of figures gathered in relation to a study of basic writers, I wrote to Mina Shaughnessy. "Help," I said, "I am awash in a sea of uncontrolled variables, error counts, and tests for statistical significance. Now that I've started counting things, I can't seem to stop." As always, Mina somehow found time to write back, and she gave me some eminently sensible advice: "Cut the list of countable items in half," she said, and then begin to n...
28 CitationsSource
#1Stanley FishH-Index: 30
PART ONE: Literature in the Reader 1. Literature in the Reader: Affective Stylistics 2. What Is Stylistics and Why Are They Saying Such Terrible Things About It? 3. How Ordinary Is Ordinary Language? 4. What It's Like To Read L'Allegro and II Penseroso 5. Facts and Fictions: A Reply to Ralph Rader 6. Interpreting the Variorum 7. Interpreting "Interpreting the Variorum" 8. Structuralist Homiletics 9. How To Do Things with Austin and Searle: Speech- Act Theory and Literary Criticism 10. What Is St...
1,869 Citations
Cited By396
#1Christine Sinclair (Edin.: University of Edinburgh)H-Index: 7
Understanding forms of imitation and their purposes is an important aspect of postdigital media literacy. Parody is important because it is used not only to generate fake news but also as an antidote to it. For parody to work, it needs to be distinguishable from fake news, and for the author and the audience both to be in on the joke. Using illustrative examples, the paper considers the importance of context, the role of the Bakhtinian notion of double-voiced discourse in understanding parody, a...
1 CitationsSource
ABSTRACTFull-time undergraduate applicants to English universities must apply via the University and Colleges Admission Service (UCAS). By analysing the UCAS statements of 15 undergraduate applican...
Abstract This ethnographically oriented study followed the writing experiences of four students on an international masters programme in Finland. Gathering a range of data, the study set out to examine what counts as good writing on a programme with a very diverse student body in which English is used as a lingua franca. Both teachers and students emphasised the importance of arguing one's ‘own point of view’ in academic writing, and teachers often formed impressions of students on the basis of ...
#1Joyce E. Johnson (CUA: The Catholic University of America)H-Index: 1
#2Kevin Rulo (CUA: The Catholic University of America)H-Index: 1
Abstract As a profession, nursing is obligated to disseminate knowledge by publishing research in the professional literature. Beyond producing scholarly work for publication, nurses need writing skills to complete doctoral dissertations and scholarly projects, and to succeed in obtaining funds for new nurse-directed business ventures. Ultimately, good writing skills are essential for the future of the nursing profession. In this article, we describe the critical role of writing in nursing, and ...
1 CitationsSource
This article examines commonplaces in the debate over using trigger warnings in college classes with special attention given to the repudiation of “sensitivity.” Arguments against sensitivity have privileged appeals to academic freedom over course and classroom accessibility, but these values may engender conflicting and even contradictory obligations. A rhetorical theory of sensitivity can equip teachers and scholars of rhetoric to make more ethical decisions in the debate over trigger warnings...
#1Ailbhe BoothH-Index: 3
#2Eilis HennessyH-Index: 16
Last. Orla DoyleH-Index: 13
view all 3 authors...
The capacity to self-regulate is a key developmental ability that has become a focal point for research across multiple disciplines. Yet interdisciplinary collaboration on self-regulation is rare and the term is often applied in different ways across studies. Drawing on literature from psychology, medical sciences, sociology, and economics, this article provides a synthesis of disciplinary approaches to research on self-regulation. A review of search returns from one prominent database per disci...
#1John R. Gallagher (UIUC: University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign)H-Index: 3
Abstract Prompted by an in-depth case study of a web-writer, this article argues that audience may be understood as an emergent process for web-writers who consider their comments. Rather than a group of people or demographic that is prefigured to exist, this article posits that audience might be a concept used throughout the composing process, including production and distribution processes. Such an approach is useful for digital pedagogies that involve online comments because it allows audienc...
3 CitationsSource
#1Lauren E. Salisbury (BGSU: Bowling Green State University)H-Index: 1
Abstract This study uses interview and observation data from first-year composition instructors to determine how instructors’ experiences with course management systems (CMSs) influence their teaching practices within those spaces. I determine that although instructors recognize the potential significance of CMSs, there is still a great disparity between instructors’ practices in face-to-face and CMS spaces with many instructors failing to see their use of CMSs as part of their pedagogical pract...
2 CitationsSource
#1Weronika Fernando (QMUL: Queen Mary University of London)
Abstract In higher education, formative academic literacy assessment tends to prioritise the product, i.e. a written text, rather than the writing processes, i.e. an active and focused reading which leads to the development of an evidence-based argument. This paper shifts the emphasis from the written product to the writing processes and investigates the effectiveness of formative academic literacy assessment in facilitating students’ engagement with composing processes and in helping them devel...