A case for competencies: Assessing the value of trait-based performance appraisal for non-faculty university employees

Published on May 2, 2016in Education Policy Analysis Archives
· DOI :10.14507/epaa.24.2212
Emily A Messa (UH: University of Houston), Catherine L. Horn10
Estimated H-index: 10
(UH: University of Houston)
+ 2 AuthorsLisa M. Penney12
Estimated H-index: 12
(University of South Florida Sarasota–Manatee)
A case study analyzed how supervisors at one university selected competencies, or trait-based skills, for non-faculty employees. This case study provides a valuable contribution by focusing on employees at one institution type–a large, public research university. While it has been documented that non-faculty employees provide important contributions to higher education, there is more to be discovered about this population of university employee, noted as more than 2 million U.S. employees in 2011. The research question guiding this study was: Within a university setting, how are employee competencies valued by job title within colleges and divisions? Multiple correspondence analysis evaluated supervisor competency selection for 1,836 non-supervisory and 565 supervisory employees using data from this university’s 2012 performance appraisal. For non-supervisory employees, the first dimension accounted for 65.11% of adjusted inertia, or explained variance. The second dimension accounted for 23.89% of adjusted inertia. For supervisory employees, the first dimension accounted for 86.57% of adjusted inertia. The second dimension accounted for 8.26% of adjusted inertia. The key study finding was that, despite the availability of other higher-education specific competency alternatives and best practices for competency use in the appraisal, this institution’s implementation of competencies was found to be mechanical. This study proposed best practices for this and similarly situated institutions as to how competencies can be used to develop employees and improve their performance.
Figures & Tables
  • References (29)
  • Citations (0)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
3 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
4 Citations
#1Fred C. LunenburgH-Index: 1
6 Citations
#1Michael A. Campion (Purdue University)H-Index: 52
#2Alexis A. Fink (Microsoft)H-Index: 1
Last. Ronald B. OdmanH-Index: 1
view all 7 authors...
The purpose of this article is to present a set of best practices for competency modeling based on the experiences and lessons learned from the major perspectives on this topic (including applied, academic, and professional). Competency models are defined, and their key advantages are explained. Then, the many uses of competency models are described. The bulk of the article is a set of 20 best practices divided into 3 areas: analyzing competency information, organizing and presenting competency ...
241 CitationsSource
Organizations use many performance appraisal formats, but an ideal form still eludes us. This article moves closer to an ideal performance appraisal system. Research assessing all problems occurring with present performance appraisal systems produced 76 performance appraisal problems (reduced to 4 general categories). Performance appraisal systems are improved by rectifying common shortcomings (e.g. reducing biases, training those involved, using formats with research substantiation). However, t...
30 Citations
The purpose of this study was to identify the attitudes and behaviors of faculty and staff that impact the success and persistence of highrisk students. Using an exploratory qualitative approach, 62 successful high-risk students from nine different colleges and universities were interviewed and asked to identify and describe someone on campus who had been most influential in their ability to persist. The 54 campus personnel who were identified by these students were interviewed twice to learn wh...
61 CitationsSource
#1Richard E. Boyatzis (Case Western Reserve University)H-Index: 41
Purpose – Development of competencies needed to be effective managers and leaders requires research and theory that can drive future scholarship and application. This introductory essay to this special issue of JMD seeks to focus on competencies in organizations in Europe and a broader conceptualization of emotional intelligence.Design/methodology/approach – Competencies are defined and an overview is provided for the papers that will follow with original research on competencies, their link to ...
192 CitationsSource
In his recent article on the relevance of grad uate preparation of new college student person nel professionals, Herdlein (2004) stated, “It is unclear whether graduate programs in student affairs have been satisfactory in preparing student affairs administrators in the rapidly changing environment of higher education.” (p. 51). Indeed the issue of whether or not college student personnel (CSP) programs have been successful in preparing students to work in student affairs has been an issue for n...
53 CitationsSource
#1William B. Swann (University of Texas at Austin)H-Index: 6
#2Russell E. Johnson (USF: University of South Florida)H-Index: 36
Last. Jennifer K. Bosson (USF: University of South Florida)H-Index: 27
view all 3 authors...
Upon initiating relationships, people engage in a process of identity negotiation through which they establish their respective identities. Once established, people’s identities define their mutual expectations, obligations, and indeed, the very nature of their relationships. This chapter presents a rudimentary theory of identity negotiation, with emphasis on how such negotiations unfold in the workplace. We first discuss the nature and history of identity negotiation, noting similarities and di...
67 CitationsSource
This article explores some of the major issues in developing and implementing a competency-based human resource development strategy. The article summarizes a brief literature review on how competency models can be developed and implemented to improve employee performance. A case study is presented of American Medical Systems (AMS), a mid-sized health-care and medical device company, where the model is being used to improve employee performance and gain a competitive advantage.
62 CitationsSource
Purpose – The purpose of this research is to determine the competencies that predict highly effective performance in RD using a multi‐trait, multi‐method approach to measurement; and collecting data on competency development that preceded work history.Findings – Nine variables were found to differentiate the two groups of managers. These were similar enough to collapse into two competencies: managing groups and interpersonal sensitivity. For the highly effective managers who demonstrated these t...
57 CitationsSource
Cited By0