Past speculations of the future: a review of the methods used for forecasting emerging health technologies

Published on Mar 1, 2016in BMJ Open2.376
· DOI :10.1136/bmjopen-2015-010479
Lucy Doos7
Estimated H-index: 7
(University of Birmingham),
Claire Packer12
Estimated H-index: 12
(University of Birmingham)
+ 2 AuthorsAndrew Stevens30
Estimated H-index: 30
(University of Birmingham)
Objectives Forecasting can support rational decision-making around the introduction and use of emerging health technologies and prevent investment in technologies that have limited long-term potential. However, forecasting methods need to be credible. We performed a systematic search to identify the methods used in forecasting studies to predict future health technologies within a 3–20-year timeframe. Identification and retrospective assessment of such methods potentially offer a route to more reliable prediction. Design Systematic search of the literature to identify studies reported on methods of forecasting in healthcare. Participants People are not needed in this study. Data sources The authors searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, PsychINFO and grey literature sources, and included articles published in English that reported their methods and a list of identified technologies. Main outcome measure Studies reporting methods used to predict future health technologies within a 3–20-year timeframe with an identified list of individual healthcare technologies. Commercially sponsored reviews, long-term futurology studies (with over 20-year timeframes) and speculative editorials were excluded. Results 15 studies met our inclusion criteria. Our results showed that the majority of studies (13/15) consulted experts either alone or in combination with other methods such as literature searching. Only 2 studies used more complex forecasting tools such as scenario building. Conclusions The methodological fundamentals of formal 3–20-year prediction are consistent but vary in details. Further research needs to be conducted to ascertain if the predictions made were accurate and whether accuracy varies by the methods used or by the types of technologies identified.
  • References (15)
  • Citations (6)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
70 Citations
5 Citations
11 Authors (William R. Hersh, ..., Joel H. Saltz)
21 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Jeffrey C. Lerner (ECRI Institute)H-Index: 3
#2Diane C. Robertson (ECRI Institute)H-Index: 2
Last. Sara M. Goldstein (ECRI Institute)H-Index: 1
view all 3 authors...
Health technology forecasting is designed to provide reliable predictions about costs, utilization, diffusion, and other market realities before the technologies enter routine clinical use. In this article we address three questions central to forecasting’s usefulness: Are early forecasts sufficiently accurate to help providers acquire the most promising technology and payers to set effective coverage policies? What variables contribute to inaccurate forecasts? How can forecasters manage the var...
8 CitationsSource
#1Annette CoxH-Index: 2
#2Luke FletcherH-Index: 5
This report presents findings from the first two elements of a research project commissioned from IES by EU-OSHA to undertake an exercise which will make recommendations about which new emerging OSH trends and challenges are relevant to explore in the next proposed large-scale foresight study, accompanied by recommendations concerning the most suitable methodology. These will then be finalised by EU-OSHA in consultation with its stakeholders.
3 CitationsSource
#1Annette CoxH-Index: 2
#2Luke FletcherH-Index: 5
Last. Martin RhisiartH-Index: 1
view all 3 authors...
This report, published by the European Agency for Safety & Health at Work (EU-OSHA), describes the methodology and findings of a scoping study carried out by IES, examining emerging trends and areas of future concern in OSH and their potential for a future large-scale foresight study. A literature review, telephone interviews, online surveys and a consultation of expert opinion were carried out to identify and assess the suitability of these topics for study. Topics were ranked in terms of impor...
4 Citations
#1George Wright (Warw.: University of Warwick)H-Index: 38
#2George Cairns (RMIT: RMIT University)H-Index: 18
Last. Ron Bradfield (University of Strathclyde)H-Index: 12
view all 3 authors...
In this Introduction, we review the logic that underpinned the earlier call for papers and provide a structured sequence for the contents of the twenty selected papers that comprise the special issue.
40 CitationsSource
#1Hassan MasumH-Index: 9
#2Jody RanckH-Index: 1
Last. Peter SingerH-Index: 80
view all 3 authors...
Purpose – This paper aims to show through empirical examples how five foresight methods have provided value in medicine and global health, and to argue for greater use of health foresight.Design/methodology/approach – Through evaluation, literature search, and personal experiences, five approaches were identified where health foresight has shown strong value: forecasting, scenario planning, Delphi, technology roadmapping, and mass collaboration. For each approach, compelling examples are given, ...
19 CitationsSource
Abstract Since the early 1990s, ‘Technology Foresight’ exercises with special emphasis on the use of Delphi surveys have played an important role in science and technology (S + T) policy across Europe in an effort to focus resource allocation. Yet, none of the estimates made in the European Delphi surveys have been formally assessed in retrospect, while this process has been incorporated into the Japanese surveys since 1996. Taking the UK Technology Foresight Programme, this research sets out to...
13 CitationsSource
#1Theo J.B.M. PostmaH-Index: 18
#2Janneke C. Alers (Dutch Cancer Society)H-Index: 21
Last. Arjan ZuurbierH-Index: 2
view all 4 authors...
Abstract In this article, we discuss a dilemma consisting of the market-oriented perspective of users of medical technology versus the long-term technology foresight perspective. The context of medical technology is interesting, because we have to cope with complex future-oriented multi-level and multi-actor strategic decision making. In order to deal with this dilemma we suggest combining the results of a (group) expert opinion forecasting approach with a more market-oriented scenario-approach....
19 CitationsSource
#1Karla Douw (University of Southern Denmark)H-Index: 6
#2Hindrik Vondeling (University of Southern Denmark)H-Index: 14
 Several countries have systems in place to support the managed entry of new health technologies. The big challenge for these so-called horizon-scanning systems is to select those technologies that require decision support by means of an early evaluation. Clinical experts are considered a valuable source of information on new health technologies, but research on the relevance of their input is scarce. In 2000, we asked six Danish expert oncologists to predict whether a sample of 19 new anticanc...
6 CitationsSource
#1Karla DouwH-Index: 6
#2Hindrik Vondeling (University of Southern Denmark)H-Index: 14
Last. Helga SigmundH-Index: 6
view all 5 authors...
Objectives: To explore and test methods for the operation of a national Early Warning System (EWS) in Denmark and to support decision making by the Danish Centre for Evaluation and Health Technology Assessment on this issue. Methods: On the basis of literature reviews, information from members of EuroScan, and supported by clinical experts and stakeholders, existing methods were adapted and new methods were developed as part of a feasibility study. Results: Approximately 200 technologies in 30 s...
16 CitationsSource
It is still disputed whether foresight exercises should be based on top-expert assessments or on a broader base of less specialised experts, and whether the self-rating of experts is an acceptable method. Using the German 1993 and the Austrian 1998 Technology Delphis, this study addresses both questions: Self-rating is in fact an appropriate method for selecting experts. But the assessment of self-rated top-experts tend to suffer from an optimism bias, due to the experts' involvement and their u...
77 CitationsSource
Cited By6
view all 3 authors...
Horizon Scanning ist ein Instrument zur strategischen Fruherkennung technologischer, okonomischer, gesellschaftlicher, politischer und okologischer Veranderungen und Innovationen, das weltweit in vielen Landern und unterschiedlichen Wirtschafts- und Wissenschaftsbereichen eingesetzt wird, um wichtige Informationen fruhzeitig bereitzustellen. Diese Informationen konnen eine Orientierung geben fur kunftige strategische aber auch politische und wirtschaftliche Handlungsoptionen und Entscheidungen. ...
#1Philip A. HinesH-Index: 1
Last. Marisa Papaluca-Amati (European Medicines Agency)H-Index: 6
view all 5 authors...
Objectives Society is confronted with the rapid emergence of innovation in science and technology. To manage this, horizon scanning is being adopted globally to identify, assess and prioritise innovations and trends at an early stage of their development. This enables decision-makers to be better informed and to prepare for change. The aim of this paper is to systematically identify and evaluate horizon scanning methodologies employed in the healthcare and biomedical fields. Methods A systematic...
#1Alexander Kott (ARL: United States Army Research Laboratory)H-Index: 14
#2Philip Perconti (ARL: United States Army Research Laboratory)H-Index: 5
During the 1990s, while exploring the impact of the collapse of the Soviet Union on developments in future warfare, a number of authors offered forecasts of military technology appearing by the year 2020. The forecasts covered diverse systems ranging from unmanned systems to guns to missiles to electronic warfare. This paper offers a quantitative assessment of the accuracy of this group of forecasts. The overall accuracy — by several measures — was assessed as quite high. In particular, when mea...
1 CitationsSource
#1Lucy Doos (University of Birmingham)H-Index: 7
#2Claire Packer (University of Birmingham)H-Index: 12
Last. Andrew Stevens (University of Birmingham)H-Index: 30
view all 5 authors...
Objective To describe and classify health technologies predicted in forecasting studies. Design and methods A portrait describing health technologies predicted in 15 forecasting studies published between 1986 and 2010 that were identified in a previous systematic review. Health technologies are classified according to their type, purpose and clinical use; relating these to the original purpose and timing of the forecasting studies. Data sources All health-related technologies predicted in 15 for...
#1Isaac Cano (University of Barcelona)H-Index: 11
#2Akos Tenyi (University of Barcelona)H-Index: 5
Last. Josep Roca (University of Barcelona)H-Index: 73
view all 5 authors...
Abstract Recent advances on prospective monitoring and retrospective analysis of health information at national or regional level are generating high expectations for the application of Big Data technologies that aim to analyze at real time high-volumes and/or complex of data from healthcare delivery (e.g., electronic health records, laboratory and radiology information, electronic prescriptions, etc.) and citizens' lifestyles (e.g., personal health records, personal monitoring devices, social n...
7 CitationsSource