Agrobiodiversity Under Different Property Regimes

Published on Apr 1, 2016in Journal of Agricultural & Environmental Ethics1.398
· DOI :10.1007/s10806-016-9602-2
Cristian Timmermann6
Estimated H-index: 6
(UNAM: National Autonomous University of Mexico),
Zoë Robaey4
Estimated H-index: 4
(TU Delft: Delft University of Technology)
Having an adequate and extensively recognized resource governance system is essential for the conservation and sustainable use of crop genetic resources in a highly populated planet. Despite the widely accepted importance of agrobiodiversity for future plant breeding and thus food security, there is still pervasive disagreement at the individual level on who should own genetic resources. The aim of the article is to provide conceptual clarification on the following concepts and their relation to agrobiodiversity stewardship: open access, commons, private property, state property and common heritage of humankind. After presenting each property regime, we will examine whether and how these incentivize the conservation, improvement and sharing of crop genetic resources, and conclude by defending a mixed property regime.
  • References (72)
  • Citations (7)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
1 Author (Juliana Santilli)
1 Citations
188 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Ronald H. CoaseH-Index: 36
This paper is concerned with those actions of business firms which have harmful effects on others. The standard example is that of a factory the smoke from which has harmful effects on those occupying neighbouring properties. The economic analysis of such a situation has usually proceeded in terms of a divergence between the private and social product of the factory, in which economists have largely followed the treatment of Pigou in The Economics of Welfare. The conclusions to which this kind o...
10.6k Citations
Ensuring the salvage of future sources is a challenge for plant geneticists and breeders, as well as historians and archivists. Here, this suggestion is illustrated with an account of the emergence, in the mid-20th century, of seed banks. These repositories are intended to enable the conservation of the world's crop genetic diversity against the ‘genetic erosion’ of crops, an unintended consequence of the global uptake of new high-yielding Green Revolution agricultural varieties. Plant breeders ...
15 CitationsSource
#1Andrés Lira-Noriega (KU: University of Kansas)H-Index: 14
#2Jorge Soberón (KU: University of Kansas)H-Index: 35
At a global level, the relationship between biodiversity importance and capacity to manage it is often assumed to be negative, without much differentiation among the more than 200 countries and territories of the world. We examine this relationship using a database including terrestrial biodiversity, wealth and governance indicators for most countries. From these, principal components analysis was used to construct aggregated indicators at global and regional scales. Wealth, governance, and scie...
4 CitationsSource
#1Brendan Coolsaet (UCL: Université catholique de Louvain)H-Index: 5
#2John Pitseys (Catholic University of Leuven)H-Index: 2
In 2010, at the tenth Conference of the Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD), Parties adopted the Nagoya Protocol on Access and Benefit-sharing (ABS). The adoption is the result of a long set of negotiations on the making of an international ABS regime, aiming to share benefits arising from the utilization of genetic resources in a ‘fair and equitable way’. However, the conditions for this fair and equitable benefit-sharing lie in a decision-making process that is similarly fa...
5 CitationsSource
This article examines the argument that biodiversity is crucial for well-functioning ecosystems and that such ecosystems provide important goods and services to our human societies, in short the ecosystem services argument (ESA). While the ESA can be a powerful argument for nature preservation, we argue that its dominant functionalist interpretation is confronted with three significant problems. First, the ESA seems unable to preserve the nature it claims to preserve. Second, the ESA cannot expl...
12 CitationsSource
#1Zoë Robaey (TU Delft: Delft University of Technology)H-Index: 4
Until now, the debates around genetically modified seeds in agriculture have converged towards two main issues. The first is about hazards that this new technology brings about, and the second is about the ownership of seeds and the distribution of their economic benefits. In this paper, I explore an underdeveloped topic by linking these two issues: how ownership shapes the distribution of moral responsibility for the potential hazards of genetically modified seeds. Indeed, while ownership is de...
5 CitationsSource
#1Cristian Timmermann (UNAM: National Autonomous University of Mexico)H-Index: 6
#2Georges F. Félix (WUR: Wageningen University and Research Centre)H-Index: 3
Agroecology has been criticized for being more labor-intensive than other more industrialized forms of agriculture. We challenge the assertion that labor input in agriculture has to be generally minimized and argue that besides quantity of work one should also consider the quality of work involved in farming. Early assessments on work quality condemned the deskilling of the rural workforce, whereas later criticisms have concentrated around issues related to fair trade and food sovereignty. We br...
35 CitationsSource
he article combines Elinor Ostrom’s design principles for common-pool resources and human rights provisions, including subsequent clarifications and jurisprudence. It analyses whether stronger local self-governance, embedded in the natural resource dimension of peoples’ rights to self-determination is a recommendable approach. Two changes in understanding are noted. First, the universal approval of indigenous peoples’ right to self-determination as specified in the UN Declaration on the Rights o...
5 CitationsSource
‘Food sovereignty’ must necessarily encompass ‘seed sovereignty’. Corporate appropriation of plant genetic resources, development of transgenic crops and the global imposition of intellectual property rights are now widely recognized as serious constraints on the free exchange of seeds and the development of new cultivars by farmers, public breeders and small seed companies. In response, an Open Source Seed Initiative (OSSI) has been launched in the United States to apply legal mechanisms drawn ...
63 CitationsSource
#1Lisa M. CampbellH-Index: 29
#2Shannon HagermanH-Index: 14
Last. Noella J. GrayH-Index: 17
view all 3 authors...
Biodiversity targets were prominent at the Tenth Conference of the Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD). Having failed to reach the CBD's 2010 target, delegates debated the nature of targets, details of specific targets, and how to avoid failure in 2020. As part of a group of seventeen researchers conducting a collaborative event ethnography at COP10, we draw on observations made during negotiations of the CBD Strategic Plan and at side events to analyze the production of the ...
20 CitationsSource
Cited By7
#1Teshome Hunduma Mulesa (NMBU: Norwegian University of Life Sciences)H-Index: 1
#2Ola Tveitereid Westengen (NMBU: Norwegian University of Life Sciences)H-Index: 6
Abstract Farmers' and breeders' access to a genetic diversity is essential for food system sustainability. The implementation of international agreements regulating access to plant genetic resources for food and agriculture (PGRFA) varies substantially between countries. Here, we examine why some countries implement a restrictive access governance regime, taking Ethiopia as a case. Drawing on commons theory and historical institutional analysis, we analyze historical, political, and economic fac...
1 CitationsSource
#1Laxmi Prasad Pant (U of G: University of Guelph)H-Index: 9
This research examines a series of case studies from the agricultural sector to illustrate how various models of innovation embrace value proposition. A conscious value contestation at the interface of science, policy and civil society requires transformations in the triple-helix model of university-government-industry collaboration, because reiterations in the triple-helix model of innovation, such as quadruple, quintuple and higher helices, do not necessarily address civil society concerns for...
#1Cristian Timmermann (University of Chile)H-Index: 6
The mixture of political, social, cultural, and economic environments in Latin America, together with the enormous diversity in climates, natural habitats, and biological resources the continent offers, make the ethical assessment of agricultural policies extremely difficult. Yet the experience gained while addressing the contemporary challenges the region faces, such as rapid urbanization, loss of culinary and crop diversity, extreme inequality, disappearing farming styles, water and land grabs...
#1Mehmet KaracaH-Index: 17
#2Ayse Gul InceH-Index: 13
The aim of conservation of biodiversity and genetic resources is to secure existing genetic biodiversity while allowing evolution and to build a wide base of genetic resources that meet demands of present and future uses not only for human kind but also for all livings forms on earth. Genetic resources for sustainable agriculture are irreplaceable natural sources for food, spice, medicine, fuel, fodder and building materials. Genetic diversity is an essential natural resource, like soil, water a...
#1Charles Perrings (ASU: Arizona State University)H-Index: 53
One effect of the Green Revolution has been the displacement of landraces and traditional livestock strains. Although humankind has historically cultivated more than 7000 species, 15 crops now provide 90% of the world’s food energy intake. The shift from traditional to modern production systems has led to genetic erosion of many crop species, and to the disappearance of a number of landraces—plants that are morphologically distinct, have some genetic integrity but are also genetically variable a...
#1Cristian Timmermann (Ton Duc Thang University)H-Index: 6
#2Georges F. Félix (WUR: Wageningen University and Research Centre)H-Index: 3
Last. Pablo TittonellH-Index: 35
view all 3 authors...
ABSTRACTThe concept of food sovereignty is becoming an element of everyday parlance in development politics and food justice advocacy. Yet to successfully achieve food sovereignty, the demands with...
2 CitationsSource
#1Massimo Monteduro (University of Salento)H-Index: 3
Positive law thus far has not recognized food diversity as a single and autonomous legal value that transcends its individual dimensions, nor has it prescribed systematic provisions for its general protection. This contribution sets forth the thesis that food diversity, in legal terms, must be considered a synthesis of multiple diversities, meaning, a “value system” where numerous legal values of primary legal status protected at the international, European and constitutional levels converge and...
#1Enric Tello Aragay (University of Barcelona)H-Index: 18
Agri-food systems are sustainable when they can meet human needs while maintaining the basic funds and ecosystem services of agoecosystems and cultural landscapes in both a reproducible way and a healthy ecological state, at local, regional and global scales. This axiological definition involves a large research agenda to explore the operative criteria and indicators needed to know how to achieve this goal. It has to be a transdisciplinary research, capable of linking some of the already existin...
4 CitationsSource