The International Right to Health: What Does It Mean in Legal Practice and How Can It Affect Priority Setting for Universal Health Coverage?

Published on Jan 2, 2016in Health Systems and Reform
· DOI :10.1080/23288604.2016.1124167
Rebecca E. Dittrich1
Estimated H-index: 1
(Johns Hopkins University),
Leonardo Cubillos1
Estimated H-index: 1
(Dartmouth College)
+ 2 AuthorsKalipso Chalkidou8
Estimated H-index: 8
AbstractAbstract—The international right to health is enshrined in national and international law. In a growing number of cases, individuals denied access to high-cost medicines and technologies under universal coverage systems have turned to the courts to challenge the denial of access as against their right to health. In some instances, patients seek access to medicines, services, or technologies that they would have access to under universal coverage if not for government, health system, or service delivery shortfalls. In others, patients seek access to medicines, services, or technologies that have not been included or that have been explicitly denied for coverage due to prioritization. In the former, judicialization of the right to health is critical to ensure patients access to the technologies or services to which they are entitled. In the latter, courts may grant patients access to medicines not covered as a result of explicit priority setting to allocate finite resources. By doing so, courts may ...
  • References (25)
  • Citations (8)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
78 Citations
22 Citations
58 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Ryan Li (National Institute for Health and Care Excellence)H-Index: 12
Last. Kalipso Chalkidou (National Institute for Health and Care Excellence)H-Index: 23
view all 5 authors...
Abstract—As more low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) commit to universal health coverage (UHC), there is a growing need for rational priority setting using health technology assessment (HTA) and other policy tools. We describe an approach for rapidly mapping LMICs' capacity and needs for rational priority setting, aimed at identifying candidate countries where technical assistance would be most viable, and present our findings from applying this approach to three continents.Drawing on the m...
9 CitationsSource
#1Norman Daniels (Harvard University)H-Index: 45
#2Sofía Charvel (ITAM: Instituto Tecnológico Autónomo de México)H-Index: 2
Last. Julian Urrutia (Harvard University)H-Index: 2
view all 5 authors...
Abstract—A moral right to health or health care, given reasonable resource constraints, implies a reasonable array of services, as determined by a fair deliberative process. Such a right can be embodied in a constitution where it becomes a legal right with similar entitlements. What is the role of the courts in deciding what these entitlements are? The threat of “judicialization” is that the courts may overreach their ability if they attempt to carry out this task; the promise of judicialization...
10 CitationsSource
: Although Costa Rica has no explicit constitutional right to health, its constitutional chamber of the Supreme Court (Sala IV) has become increasingly central to the resolution of many health care decisions. Some argue that courts' decisions about individuals' access to very expensive medications could upset the country's medical priorities and harm the state's general health care provision capacity. This article assesses whether health rights litigation concerning the right to medications lead...
7 Citations
#1Kalipso ChalkidouH-Index: 8
#2Robert Marten (Rockefeller Foundation)H-Index: 11
Last. Alexandre Lemgruber (OPS: Pan American Health Organization)H-Index: 2
view all 22 authors...
22 CitationsSource
This thesis analyses “health care litigation” in Brazil and England. By health care litigation I mean those lawsuits in which claimants demand from the State the provision of a certain health treatment based on their entitlement to receive health care from the public health system or funded by it. The question that guides this thesis is whether courts intervening in rationing decisions make the public health system more or less fair. The concept of fairness I use in this thesis draws on the idea...
1 Citations
#1Jody Heymann (UCLA: University of California, Los Angeles)H-Index: 26
#2Adèle Cassola (McGill University)H-Index: 1
Last. Lipi Mishra (McGill University)H-Index: 3
view all 4 authors...
United Nations (UN) member states have universally recognised the right to health in international agreements, but protection of this right at the national level remains incomplete. This article examines the level and scope of constitutional protection of specific rights to public health and medical care, as well as the broad right to health. We analysed health rights in the constitutions of 191 UN countries in 2007 and 2011. We examined how rights protections varied across the year of constitut...
25 CitationsSource
12 Citations
#1Amanda GlassmanH-Index: 19
#2Kalipso ChalkidouH-Index: 23
Creating and developing fair and evidence-based national and global systems to more rationally set priorities for public spending on health. An interim secretariat should be there to incubate a global health technology assessment facility designed to help governments develop national systems and donors get greater value for money in their grants. [CGD Brief]. URL:[].
51 Citations
#1Leonardo Cubillos-Turriago (World Bank Institute)H-Index: 3
#2Maria-Luisa Escobar (World Bank Institute)H-Index: 2
Last. Roberto Iunes (World Bank Institute)H-Index: 2
view all 4 authors...
Purpose – Over the last five years many middle‐income Latin American countries have seen a steep increase in the number of cases litigating access to curative services. The purpose of this paper is to explore this complex phenomenon and outline some of its roots and impacts.Design/methodology/approach – The authors use an interdisciplinary approach based on a literature review and workshops convened to discuss the issue.Findings – A range of reasons can explain this increased legal activity. The...
13 CitationsSource
#1João Biehl (Princeton University)H-Index: 20
#2Joseph J AmonH-Index: 22
Last. Adriana Petryna (UPenn: University of Pennsylvania)H-Index: 14
view all 4 authors...
Background: The Brazilian Constitution states: “Health is the right of all persons and the duty of the State.” Yet individuals in Brazil frequently face barriers to health prevention and treatment. One response to these barriers has been a “judicialization” of the right to health, with an increasing number of patients suing the government for access to medicines. Objective/Methods: This study uses a mixed methods approach to identify trends in lawsuits for medicines in the southern state of Rio ...
36 Citations
Cited By8
#1Beatriz Cristina de Freitas (State University of Campinas)
Last. Dagmar de Paula Queluz (State University of Campinas)H-Index: 7
view all 3 authors...
No Brasil, o direito a saude tem previsao constitucional e universal. No entanto, a via judicial tem sido muito utilizada para acesso a bens e servicos de saude. Assim, o objetivo deste artigo foi revisar a literatura sobre a judicializacao da saude entre 2004 e 2017. A partir de pergunta estruturada, foram revisadas as bases de dados PubMed/MEDLINE, Lilacs, SciELO, Scopus e Bireme/BVS. A maioria das acoes refere-se a medicamentos. Houve consenso quanto a caracteristica individual das litigacoes...
#1Damian-Emilio Gibaja-Romero (UPAEP: Universidad Popular Autónoma del Estado de Puebla)
#2Rosa-Maria Canton-Croda (UPAEP: Universidad Popular Autónoma del Estado de Puebla)
International cooperation appears as a suitable strategy to deal with the inefficiencies that health systems face around the world, but agents with different objectives interact to reach it; so, we analyze international cooperation by following two game-theoretical approaches. The first one focuses on the intervention of international health organizations (IHOs), where coordination issues may arise due to different priorities. The second one studies the interaction between countries which casts ...
#1Niki O'Brien (Imperial College London)
#2Ryan Li (Imperial College London)H-Index: 12
Last. Kalipso Chalkidou (Imperial College London)H-Index: 8
view all 7 authors...
The World Health Organization (WHO) resolution calling on Member States to work towards achieving universal health coverage (UHC) has increased the need for prioritizing health spending. Such need will soon accelerate as low- and middle-income countries transition from external aid. Countries will have to make difficult decisions on how best to integrate and finance previously donor-funded technologies and health services into their UHC packages in ways that are equitable, and operationally and ...
#1João Biehl (Princeton University)H-Index: 20
#2Mariana P. Socal (Johns Hopkins University)H-Index: 9
Last. Joseph J Amon (Princeton University)H-Index: 22
view all 7 authors...
ABSTRACTOver the past two decades, debate over the whys, the hows, and the effects of the ever-expanding phenomenon of right-to-health litigation (‘judicialization’) throughout Latin America have b...
4 CitationsSource
#1Benedict Rumbold (UCL: University College London)H-Index: 9
#2Richard Baker (GCU: Glasgow Caledonian University)H-Index: 54
Last. Paul H Hunt (University of Essex)H-Index: 18
view all 16 authors...
As health policy-makers around the world seek to make progress towards universal health coverage they must navigate between two important ethical imperatives: to set national spending priorities fairly and efficiently; and to safeguard the right to health. These imperatives can conflict, leading some to conclude that rights-based approaches present a disruptive influence on health policy, hindering states’ efforts to set priorities fairly and efficiently. Here, we challenge this perception. We a...
17 CitationsSource
Cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA) can help countries attain and sustain universal health coverage (UHC), as long as it is context-specific and considered within deliberative processes at the country level. Institutionalising robust deliberative processes requires significant time and resources, however, and countries often begin by demanding evidence (including local CEA evidence as well as evidence about local values), whilst striving to strengthen the governance structures and technical capaci...
8 CitationsSource
#1Jean Slutsky (Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute)H-Index: 3
#2Emma Tumilty (University of Otago)H-Index: 7
Last. Leonardo Cubillos (Dartmouth College)H-Index: 1
view all 15 authors...
Purpose - The paper summarizes data from 12 countries, chosen to exhibit wide variation, on the role and place of public participation in the setting of priorities. The purpose of this paper is to exhibit cross-national patterns in respect of public participation, linking those differences to institutional features of the countries concerned. Design/methodology/approach - The approach is an example of case-orientated qualitative assessment of participation practices. It derives its data from the...
15 CitationsSource
Situada na convergencia entre direito e medicina, a "judicializacao do direito a saude" e um fenomeno contencioso que tem gerado debates acalorados no Brasil. Enquanto agentes publicos e alguns academicos sustentam que ela e dirigida por elites urbanas e interesses privados e e acionada, primordialmente, para acessar medicamentos de alto custo, evidencias empiricas refutam narrativas que descrevem a judicializacao como um indicador de desigualdade e um antagonista do sistema publico de saude. A ...
2 CitationsSource
#1João Biehl (Princeton University)H-Index: 20
#2Mariana P. Socal (Johns Hopkins University)H-Index: 9
Last. Joseph J Amon (Princeton University)H-Index: 22
view all 3 authors...
The impact of increasing numbers of lawsuits for access to medicines in Brazil is hotly debated. Government officials and scholars assert that the “judicialization of health” is driven by urban elites and private interests, and is used primarily to access high-cost drugs. Using a systematic sample of 1,262 lawsuits for access to medicines filed against the southern Brazilian state of Rio Grande do Sul, we assess these claims, offering empirical evidence that counters prevailing myths and affirms...
21 Citations