Universality of citation distributions: Toward an objective measure of scientific impact

Published on Nov 11, 2008in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America9.58
· DOI :10.1073/pnas.0806977105
Filippo Radicchi28
Estimated H-index: 28
Santo Fortunato44
Estimated H-index: 44
Claudio Castellano44
Estimated H-index: 44
We study the distributions of citations received by a single publication within several disciplines, spanning broad areas of science. We show that the probability that an article is cited c times has large variations between different disciplines, but all distributions are rescaled on a universal curve when the relative indicator cf = c/c0 is considered, where c0 is the average number of citations per article for the discipline. In addition we show that the same universal behavior occurs when citation distributions of articles published in the same field, but in different years, are compared. These findings provide a strong validation of cf as an unbiased indicator for citation performance across disciplines and years. Based on this indicator, we introduce a generalization of the h index suitable for comparing scientists working in different fields.
  • References (30)
  • Citations (473)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
70 Citations
552 Citations
22.1k Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
Research assessment in the UK has evolved over a quarter of a century from a loosely structured, peer-review based process to one with a well understood data portfolio and assessment methodology. After 2008, the assessment process will shift again, to the use of indicators based largely on publication and citation data. These indicators will in part follow the format introduced in 2008, with a profiling of assessment outcomes at national and international levels. However, the shift from peer ass...
71 CitationsSource
#2Jevin D. WestH-Index: 18
Last. Carl T. BergstromH-Index: 46
view all 4 authors...
The impact factor of an academic journal for any year is the number of times the average article published in that journal in the previous two years are cited in that year. From 1994-2005, the average impact factor of journals listed by the ISI has been increasing by an average of 2.6 percent per year. This paper documents this growth and explores its causes.
13 Citations
#1Lutz Bornmann (ETH Zurich)H-Index: 48
#2Hans-Dieter Daniel (ETH Zurich)H-Index: 32
Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to present a narrative review of studies on the citing behavior of scientists, covering mainly research published in the last 15 years. Based on the results of these studies, the paper seeks to answer the question of the extent to which scientists are motivated to cite a publication not only to acknowledge intellectual and cognitive influences of scientific peers, but also for other, possibly non‐scientific, reasons.Design/methodology/approach – The review ...
677 CitationsSource
552 CitationsSource
The “h index” proposed by Hirsch [Hirsch JE (2005) Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 102:16569–16573] is a good indicator of the impact of a scientist's research and has the advantage of being objective. When evaluating departments, institutions, or laboratories, the importance of the h index can be further enhanced when it is properly calibrated for the size of the group. Particularly acute is the issue of federally funded facilities whose number of actively publishing scientists frequently dwarfs that of...
53 CitationsSource
#1Santo Fortunato (IU: Indiana University Bloomington)H-Index: 44
#2Claudio CastellanoH-Index: 44
A most debated topic of the last years is whether simple statistical physics models can explain collective features of social dynamics. A necessary step in this line of endeavor is to find regularities in data referring to large-scale social phenomena, such as scaling and universality. We show that, in proportional elections, the distribution of the number of votes received by candidates is a universal scaling function, identical in different countries and years. This finding reveals the existen...
110 CitationsSource
#1Juan E. Iglesias (CSIC: Spanish National Research Council)H-Index: 20
#2Carlos PecharrománH-Index: 30
We propose a simple way to put in a common scale the h values of researchers working in different scientific ISI fields, so that the foreseeable misuse of this index for inter-areas comparison might be prevented, or at least, alleviated.
165 CitationsSource
#1Jonas Lundberg (KI: Karolinska Institutet)H-Index: 6
Researchers worldwide are increasingly being assessed by the citation rates of their papers. These rates have potential impact on academic promotions and funding decisions. Currently there are several different ways that citation rates are being calculated, with the state of the art indicator being the crown indicator. This indicator has flaws and improvements could be considered. An item oriented field normalized citation score average (c¯f) is an incremental improvement as it differs from the ...
207 CitationsSource
#1Leo Egghe (University of Hasselt)H-Index: 27
1,007 CitationsSource
I propose the index h, defined as the number of papers with citation number ≥h, as a useful index to characterize the scientific output of a researcher.
5,164 CitationsSource
Cited By473
#1Milan Janosov (CEU: Central European University)H-Index: 1
#2Federico Battiston (CEU: Central European University)H-Index: 10
Last. Roberta Sinatra (ITU: IT University of Copenhagen)H-Index: 16
view all 3 authors...
Luck is considered a crucial ingredient to achieve impact in all creative domains, despite their diversity. For instance, in science, the movie industry, music, and art, the occurrence of the highest impact work and a hot streak within a creative career are very difficult to predict. Are there domains that are more prone to luck than others? Here, we provide new insights on the role of randomness in impact in creative careers in two ways: (i) we systematically untangle luck and individual abilit...
1 CitationsSource
#2James R. Bradley (W&M: College of William & Mary)H-Index: 14
Last. George ChackoH-Index: 3
view all 5 authors...
Co-citation measurements can reveal the extent to which a concept representing a novel combination of existing ideas evolves towards a specialty. The strength of co-citation is represented by its f...
#1Bin Zhou (BU: Boston University)
#2Xiangyi Meng (BU: Boston University)
Last. H. Eugene Stanley (BU: Boston University)H-Index: 118
view all 3 authors...
Whether real-world complex networks are scale free or not has long been controversial. Recently, in Broido and Clauset [A. D. Broido, A. Clauset, Nat. Commun. 10, 1017 (2019)], it was claimed that the degree distributions of real-world networks are rarely power law under statistical tests. Here, we attempt to address this issue by defining a fundamental property possessed by each link, the degree–degree distance, the distribution of which also shows signs of being power law by our empirical stud...
#2Aditya TandonH-Index: 1
Last. Santo FortunatoH-Index: 44
view all 7 authors...
The citations process for scientific papers has been studied extensively. But while the citations accrued by authors are the sum of the citations of their papers, translating the dynamics of citati...
1 CitationsSource
Over its more than thirty-year history, the Advanced Technologies and Instrumentation (ATI) program has provided grants to support technology development and instrumentation for ground-based astronomy. Through a combination of automated literature assessment and in-depth literature review, we present a survey of ATI-funded research and an assessment of its impact on astronomy and society. Award acknowledgement and literature citation statistics for ATI are comparable to a comparison astronomy gr...
#1Sha Yuan (THU: Tsinghua University)H-Index: 1
#2Zhou Shao (Nanjing University of Science and Technology)
Last. Ye Wang (Ministry of Science and Technology)
view all 8 authors...
In this era of interdisciplinary science, many scientific achievements, such as artificial intelligence (AI), have brought dramatic revolutions to human society. The increasing availability of digital data on scholarly outputs offers unprecedented opportunities to explore science of science (SciSci). Despite many significant works have been done on SciSci, substantial disciplinary differences in different domains make some insights inadequate within particular fields. One thing standing out is t...
#1Hao Liao (SZU: Shenzhen University)
#2Jiao Wu (SZU: Shenzhen University)
Last. Kezhong Lu (SZU: Shenzhen University)
view all 6 authors...
Abstract For online service platforms such as Netflix, it is important to propose a list of high quality movies to their users. This type of problem can be regarded as a ranking problem in a bipartite network. This is a well-know problem, that can be solved by a ranking algorithm. However, many classical ranking algorithms share a common drawback: they tend to rank higher older movies rather than newer ones, though some new movies may be of higher quality. In the study, we develop a ranking meth...
#1Grzegorz Siudem (Warsaw University of Technology)H-Index: 3
#2Barbara Żogała-Siudem (PAN: Polish Academy of Sciences)
Last. Marek Gagolewski (PAN: Polish Academy of Sciences)H-Index: 8
view all 4 authors...
The growing popularity of bibliometric indexes (whose most famous example is the h index by J. E. Hirsch [J. E. Hirsch, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 102, 16569–16572 (2005)]) is opposed by those claiming that one’s scientific impact cannot be reduced to a single number. Some even believe that our complex reality fails to submit to any quantitative description. We argue that neither of the two controversial extremes is true. By assuming that some citations are distributed according to the rich g...
Abstract Nature, Science, and PNAS are the three most prestigious general-science journals, and Nature and Science are among the most influential journals overall, based on the journal Impact Factor (IF). In this paper we perform automatic classification of ~ 50,000 articles in these journals (published in the period 2005–2015) into 14 broad areas, to explore disciplinary profiles of these journals and to determine their field-specific IFs. We find that in all three journals the articles from Bi...
#1Daniel A. Friess (NUS: National University of Singapore)H-Index: 21
#2Erik S. Yando (NUS: National University of Singapore)H-Index: 1
Last. Natasha Bhatia (NTU: Nanyang Technological University)
view all 4 authors...
Abstract Coastal ecosystems provide a broad range of ecosystem services, which can be used to justify habitat conservation. The cultural ecosystem services of coastal ecosystems are generally underappreciated, and this is particularly the case when quantifying their scientific value. We created a tiered set of indicators to quantify scientific value spatially, and tested them using the case study of the island nation of Singapore. We conducted a systematic review of research papers, book chapter...