The Scarring Effects of Primary-Grade Retention? A Study of Cumulative Advantage in the Educational Career

Published on Dec 1, 2014in Social Forces
· DOI :10.1093/sf/sou074
Megan Andrew5
Estimated H-index: 5
(ND: University of Notre Dame)
Triggering events and the scarring, or status-dependence, process they induce are an important cornerstone of social stratification theory that is rarely studied in the context of the educational career. However, the decades-old high-stakes environment that ties many educational outcomes to a test score or other singular achievement underscores the potential importance of scarring in the contemporary educational career. In this paper, I study scarring in the educational career in the case of primary-grade retention. Using propensity score matching and sibling fixed-effects models, I evaluate evidence for primary-grade retention effects on high school completion and college entry and completion. I find consistent evidence of a causal effect of early primary school grade retention on high school completion. These effects operate largely through middle school academic achievements and expectations, suggesting that students who recover from the scar of grade retention on high school completion largely do so earlier rather than later in the educational career. Students can continue to recover from the effects of grade retention through early high school, not only through their academic achievements but through their expectations of high school completion as well. Models suggest that early primary grade retention scars the educational career mainly at high school completion, though there are important, unconditional effects on college entry and completion as a result. I conclude by placing these findings in the larger grade-retention literature and discussing future research on heterogeneities in and mechanisms of retention effects.
  • References (51)
  • Citations (23)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
44 Citations
82 Citations
308 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Bart Cockx (UCL: Université catholique de Louvain)H-Index: 17
#2Matteo Picchio (Research Foundation - Flanders)H-Index: 11
This study investigates whether and to what extent further unemployment experience for youths who are already long-term unemployed imposes a penalty on subsequent labor market outcomes. We propose a flexible method for analyzing the effect on wages aside of transitions from unemployment and employment within a multivariate duration model that controls for selection on observables and unobservables. We find that prolonging unemployment drastically decreases the chances of finding employment, but ...
50 CitationsSource
#1John Robert Warren (UMN: University of Minnesota)H-Index: 28
#2Jim Saliba (UMN: University of Minnesota)H-Index: 1
How many students repeat a grade each year? How do retention rates vary across states and over time? Despite extensive research on the predictors and consequences of grade retention, there is no systematic way to quantify state-level retention rates; even national estimates rely on imperfect proxy measures. We present a conceptually simple method—based on publicly available data that are routinely collected each year—that describes retention rates at the state and national levels. After describi...
25 CitationsSource
#1Sean Kelly (University of Pittsburgh)H-Index: 19
#2William Carbonaro (ND: University of Notre Dame)H-Index: 13
In an effort to understand teacher-student relationships much research has investigated how teacher expectations of student performance in the classroom affect achievement growth. However, little research has focused on how teacher expectations of students’ educational attainment are formed. In this paper, we examine how students’ high school track placements affect teacher expectations regarding students’ educational attainment in the NELS data. NELS is a large, nationally representative longit...
43 CitationsSource
#1Weihua NiuH-Index: 2
#2Jillian BrassH-Index: 1
6 CitationsSource
#1Jennie E. Brand (UCLA: University of California, Los Angeles)H-Index: 18
#2Yu Xie (UM: University of Michigan)H-Index: 43
In this article, we consider how the economic return to a college education varies across members of the U.S. population. Based on principles of comparative advantage, scholars commonly presume that positive selection is at work, that is, individuals who are most likely to select into college also benefit most from college. Net of observed economic and noneconomic factors influencing college attendance, we conjecture that individuals who are least likely to obtain a college education benefit the...
286 CitationsSource
44 CitationsSource
#1Chiharu S. Allen (A&M: Texas A&M University)H-Index: 1
#2Qi Chen (UNT: University of North Texas)H-Index: 11
Last. Jan N. Hughes (A&M: Texas A&M University)H-Index: 41
view all 4 authors...
The present meta-analysis examines the effect of grade retention on academic outcomes and investigates systemic sources of variability in effect sizes. Using multilevel modeling (MLM), the authors investigate characteristics of 207 effect sizes across 22 studies published between 1990 and 2007 at two levels: the study (between) and individual (within) levels. Design quality is a study-level variable. Individual-level variables are median grade retained and median number of years postretention. Q...
81 CitationsSource
Low-achieving students in many school districts are retained in a grade to allow them to gain the academic or social skills that teachers believe are necessary to succeed academically. In this paper, we use plausibly exogenous variation in retention generated by a test-based promotion policy to assess the causal impact of grade retention on high school completion. We find that retention among younger students does not affect the likelihood of high school completion, but that retaining low-achiev...
111 CitationsSource
#1Carl B. Frederick (UW: University of Wisconsin-Madison)H-Index: 5
#2Robert M. Hauser (UW: University of Wisconsin-Madison)H-Index: 56
We examine trends over time in the proportion of children below the modal grade for their age (BMG), a proxy for grade retention, and in the effects of its demographic and socioeconomic correlates. We estimate a logistic regression model with partial constraints predicting BMG using the annual October school enrollment supplements of the Current Population Survey. This model identifies systematic variation in the effects of social background across age and time from 1972 to 2005. While the effec...
21 CitationsSource
#1Paul T. von Hippel (OSU: Ohio State University)H-Index: 18
When fitting a generalized linear model—such as linear regression, logistic regression, or hierarchical linear modeling—analysts often wonder how to handle missing values of the dependent variable Y. If missing values have been filled in using multiple imputation, the usual advice is to use the imputed Y values in analysis. We show, however, that using imputed Ys can add needless noise to the estimates. Better estimates can usually be obtained using a modified strategy that we call multiple impu...
766 CitationsSource
Cited By23
#1James Chu (Stanford University)H-Index: 19
#2Guirong Li (Henan University)H-Index: 4
Last. Yanyan Li (Henan University)H-Index: 1
view all 6 authors...
#1Andrew Halpern-Manners (IU: Indiana University)H-Index: 11
#2Helge Marahrens (IU: Indiana University)H-Index: 1
Last. Leslie D. Leve (UO: University of Oregon)H-Index: 40
view all 7 authors...
Abstract Sociological research has traditionally emphasized the importance of post-birth factors (i.e., social, economic, and cultural capital) in the intergenerational transmission of educational advantages, to the neglect of potentially consequential pre-birth endowments (e.g., heritable traits) that are passed from parent to child. In this study, we leverage an experiment of nurture—children who were adopted at birth into nonrelative families— in an effort to simultaneously model the effects ...
#1Li-Chung Hu (National Chengchi University)H-Index: 1
#2Emily Hannum (UPenn: University of Pennsylvania)H-Index: 23
Abstract This paper analyzes the prevalence, correlates, and behavioral and academic impacts of grade retention using national and single-province data from China. Retention is much more prevalent in China than official estimates suggest; it is more frequent in less-developed parts of the country; and it is associated nationally with poorer subsequent performance and psychosocial well-being, even after adjusting for numerous confounders. However, a causal analysis in one province using matching ...
#1Deborah K. Reed (UI: University of Iowa)H-Index: 10
#2Kevin M. Cook (Georgetown University)H-Index: 1
Last. Ariel M. Aloe (UI: University of Iowa)H-Index: 18
view all 3 authors...
This study investigated the costs of different summer reading programs and compared costs to the benefits of summer school as a way to avoid retaining students not reading proficiently at the end of third grade. Per pupil costs ranged from US1,665 to US,194. The average cost was US1,887 (range: US66-US5,552) with 82% of overall expenses attributable to personnel. Results indicate that offering summer reading programs could save schools across the state a total of between US0.6 million a...
2 CitationsSource
OBJECTIVES: While a large body of evidence exists in support of outcomes associated with cumulative dis/advantage (CAD), individual-level experiences of the systemic processes that generate unequal outcomes have received far less attention. This study explored experiences, among members of an early baby-boom birth cohort, of CAD-generative processes within the education and housing systems and the mechanisms by which they interacted with initial social position to perpetuate inequalities. METHOD...
1 CitationsSource
#1Chrisse Edmunds (OSU: Ohio State University)H-Index: 1
#1Chrisse Edmunds (OSU: Ohio State University)
Abstract Economic deprivation experienced in early childhood can have lasting effects for children. Studies that focus only on families living in poverty do not capture the breadth of experiences associated with economic deprivation. This study breaks down economic deprivation into two constructs, poverty and material hardship, and examines their relationship with academic failure later in childhood. Using the Fragile Families and Child Wellbeing Study (N = 3591), this study examines how early c...
Racial/ethnic disparities in grade retention related to structural inequality are investigated using a quantitative theoretical model from the health literature. Data from the Early Childhood Longitudinal Study-Kindergarten Cohort are linked with segregation indices for dissimilarity and poverty interaction derived from the US Census 2000 data estimate the impact of individual and structural level variables on grade retention. Shared frailty models demonstrate that there are racial/ethnic differ...
#1Hans Dietrich (Institut für Arbeitsmarkt- und Berufsforschung)H-Index: 3
#1Hans Dietrich (Institut für Arbeitsmarkt- und Berufsforschung)H-Index: 2
view all 3 authors...
Rund ein Viertel der Sekundarstufe-I-Absolventen in Deutschland erwirbt bis zum 25. Lebensjahr keinen beruflichen Abschluss. Diese Gruppe der formal Geringqualifizierten weist ein deutlich erhohtes Risiko auf, erwerbslos zu sein, ein niedriges Einkommen zu beziehen oder eine prekare Erwerbstatigkeit auszuuben. Dieser Beitrag geht der Frage nach, welche Faktoren formal Geringqualifizierte motivieren, ab dem 25. Lebensjahr noch eine berufliche Erstausbildung aufzunehmen. Zur Begrundung nachholende...
#1Melanie Sberna Hinojosa (UCF: University of Central Florida)H-Index: 17
#2Ramon Hinojosa (UCF: University of Central Florida)H-Index: 1
Last. Jenny NguyenH-Index: 2
view all 4 authors...