Systematic inequality and hierarchy in faculty hiring networks

Published on Feb 1, 2015in Science Advances11.5
· DOI :10.1126/sciadv.1400005
Aaron Clauset30
Estimated H-index: 30
(CU: University of Colorado Boulder),
Samuel Arbesman10
Estimated H-index: 10
(Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation),
Daniel B. Larremore14
Estimated H-index: 14
(Harvard University)
The faculty job market plays a fundamental role in shaping research priorities, educational outcomes, and career trajectories among scientists and institutions. However, a quantitative understanding of faculty hiring as a system is lacking. Using a simple technique to extract the institutional prestige ranking that best explains an observed faculty hiring network—who hires whose graduates as faculty—we present and analyze comprehensive placement data on nearly 19,000 regular faculty in three disparate disciplines. Across disciplines, we find that faculty hiring follows a common and steeply hierarchical structure that reflects profound social inequality. Furthermore, doctoral prestige alone better predicts ultimate placement than a U.S. News & World Report rank, women generally place worse than men, and increased institutional prestige leads to increased faculty production, better faculty placement, and a more influential position within the discipline. These results advance our ability to quantify the influence of prestige in academia and shed new light on the academic system.
  • References (45)
  • Citations (139)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
294 Citations
1 Author (Robert K. Merton)
3,739 Citations
5,164 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Pierre Deville (NU: Northeastern University)H-Index: 6
#2Dashun Wang (NU: Northeastern University)H-Index: 16
Last. Albert-La szlo Baraba si (NU: Northeastern University)H-Index: 120
view all 6 authors...
60 CitationsSource
#1Liangjun QiaoH-Index: 4
#2Hongwei GaoH-Index: 1
Last. Xianming MoH-Index: 19
view all 11 authors...
The Snail family member snail encodes a zinc finger-containing transcriptional factor that is involved in heart formation. Yet, little is known about how Snail regulates heart development. Here, we identified that one of the duplicated snail genes, snai1b, was expressed in the heart region of zebrafish embryos. Depletion of Snai1b function dramatically reduced expression of α5 integrin, disrupted Fibronectin layer in the heart region, especially at the midline, and prevented migration of cardiac...
8 CitationsSource
#1Paolo Boldi (University of Milan)H-Index: 33
#2Sebastiano Vigna (University of Milan)H-Index: 34
AbstractGiven a social network, which of its nodes are more central? This question has been asked many times in sociology, psychology, and computer science, and a whole plethora of centrality measures (a.k.a. centrality indices, or rankings) were proposed to account for the importance of the nodes of a network. In this study, we try to provide a mathematically sound survey of the most important classic centrality measures known from the literature and propose an axiomatic approach to establish w...
163 CitationsSource
#1Péter Csermely (Semmelweis University)H-Index: 57
#2András London (University of Szeged)H-Index: 4
Last. Brian Uzzi (NU: Northwestern University)H-Index: 34
view all 4 authors...
Recent studies uncovered important core/periphery network structures characterizing complex sets of cooperative and competitive interactions between network nodes, be they proteins, cells, species or humans. Better characterization of the structure, dynamics and function of core/periphery networks is a key step of our understanding cellular functions, species adaptation, social and market changes. Here we summarize the current knowledge of the structure and dynamics of "traditional" core/periphe...
163 CitationsSource
#1Silvia Knobloch-Westerwick (OSU: Ohio State University)H-Index: 28
#2Carroll J. Glynn (OSU: Ohio State University)H-Index: 19
Last. Michael E. Huge (OSU: Ohio State University)H-Index: 10
view all 3 authors...
An experiment with 243 young communication scholars tested hypotheses derived from role congruity theory regarding impacts of author gender and gender typing of research topics on perceived quality of scientific publications and collaboration interest. Participants rated conference abstracts ostensibly authored by females or males, with author associations rotated. The abstracts fell into research areas perceived as gender-typed or gender-neutral to ascertain impacts from gender typing of topics...
111 CitationsSource
#1Daniel J. TancrediH-Index: 45
#2Klea D. BertakisH-Index: 29
Last. Anthony F JerantH-Index: 31
view all 3 authors...
PurposeThe annual U.S. News & World Report (USN&WR) Primary Care Medical School (PCMS) ranking attracts considerable attention, but its measurement properties have not been published. The authors examined the short-term stability of the PCMS ranking and the PCMS score from which it derives, along wi
8 CitationsSource
Despite efforts to recruit and retain more women, a stark gender disparity persists within academic science. Abundant research has demonstrated gender bias in many demographic groups, but has yet to experimentally investigate whether science faculty exhibit a bias against female students that could contribute to the gender disparity in academic science. In a randomized double-blind study (n = 127), science faculty from research-intensive universities rated the application materials of a student—...
1,025 CitationsSource
#1Sean A. Myers (UNC: University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill)H-Index: 3
#2Peter J. MuchaH-Index: 39
Last. Mason A. Porter (University of Oxford)H-Index: 48
view all 3 authors...
The Mathematics Genealogy Project (http://www. is a database of over 150 000 scholars with advanced degrees in mathematics and related fields. Entries include dissertation titles, adviser(s), graduation years, degree-granting institutions, and advisees. The MGP is popular among mathematicians, and it can be used to trace academic lineages through luminaries like Courant, Hilbert, and Wiener to historical predecessors such as Gauss, Euler, and even Kant. For example, MGP data ...
12 CitationsSource
#1David CyranoskiH-Index: 28
#2Natasha Gilbert NgH-Index: 17
Last. Mohammed Yahia MyH-Index: 4
view all 5 authors...
212 CitationsSource
Explanations for women's underrepresentation in math-intensive fields of science often focus on sex discrimination in grant and manuscript reviewing, interviewing, and hiring. Claims that women scientists suffer discrimination in these arenas rest on a set of studies undergirding policies and programs aimed at remediation. More recent and robust empiricism, however, fails to support assertions of discrimination in these domains. To better understand women's underrepresentation in math-intensive ...
431 CitationsSource
Cited By139
#1Jichao LiH-Index: 2
#2Yian Yin (NU: Northwestern University)H-Index: 2
view all 4 authors...
Throughout history, a relatively small number of individuals have made a profound and lasting impact on science and society. Despite long-standing, multi-disciplinary interests in understanding careers of elite scientists, there have been limited attempts for a quantitative, career-level analysis. Here, we leverage a comprehensive dataset we assembled, allowing us to trace the entire career histories of nearly all Nobel laureates in physics, chemistry, and physiology or medicine over the past ce...
#1Peng Bao (Beijing Jiaotong University)H-Index: 6
#2Jiahui Wang (Beijing Jiaotong University)H-Index: 1
#1Bas Hofstra (Stanford University)H-Index: 4
#2Vivek V. Kulkarni (Stanford University)
Last. Daniel A. McFarland (Stanford University)H-Index: 23
view all 6 authors...
Prior work finds a diversity paradox: Diversity breeds innovation, yet underrepresented groups that diversify organizations have less successful careers within them. Does the diversity paradox hold for scientists as well? We study this by utilizing a near-complete population of approximately 1.2 million US doctoral recipients from 1977 to 2015 and following their careers into publishing and faculty positions. We use text analysis and machine learning to answer a series of questions: How do we de...
#1Laurence Clement (UCSF: University of California, San Francisco)H-Index: 1
#2Karen Nicole Leung (City College of San Francisco)
Last. Naledi Marie Saul (UCSF: University of California, San Francisco)
view all 4 authors...
In addition to developing innovative research programs, life science research faculty at research-intensive institutions are tasked with providing career mentoring and scientific training to new generations of scientists, including postgraduate, graduate, and undergraduate students. In this essay, we argue for a redefinition of mentoring in laboratory research, to thoroughly distinguish three essential roles played by research faculty relative to their trainees: advisor, educator, and supervisor...
#1Esther I. Wilder (CUNY: City University of New York)H-Index: 9
#2William H. Walters (Manhattan College)H-Index: 17
This study examines the 2013–2017 publishing productivity of sociology faculty at six types of colleges and universities (e.g., research universities, master’s institutions, and top liberal arts co...
#1Harald Bauder (RyeU: Ryerson University)H-Index: 23
The relationship between the international mobility of academic researchers and social capital is complex. On the one hand, the literature suggests that social capital facilitates the international mobility of academics which, in turn, promotes the accumulation of international social capital, enhances research productivity, and advances careers. On the other hand, international mobility can isolate researchers from the national social capital in their origin countries. In this paper, I present ...