Tensions and contradictions in nurses perspectives of evidence-based practice

Published on May 1, 2008in Journal of Nursing Management2.386
· DOI :10.1111/j.1365-2834.2008.00864.x
Gary Rolfe22
Estimated H-index: 22
(Swansea University),
Jeremy Segrott16
Estimated H-index: 16
(Cardiff University),
Estimated H-index: 31
(Swansea University)
Aim  To explore nurses’ understanding and interpretation of evidence-based practice (EBP). Background  EBP has been welcomed into the nursing lexicon without a critical examination of its interpretation by practitioners. The literature suggests that there is a great deal of confusion and contradiction over the meaning and application of EBP. Although work has been conducted on how EBP might be implemented, the general issue of how nurses understand and use EBP is largely unexplored. This paper seeks to examine in depth the understandings of EBP, to enable managers, educationalists and policy makers to implement it more effectively. Methods  All registered nurses, midwives and health visitors in one UK National Health Service (NHS) Trust were asked to complete a questionnaire in October 2006. Results  Despite a disappointing response rate (8.9%, 218/2438), the survey revealed interesting tensions and contradictions in nurses’ understanding of EBP. National and local guidelines, practitioners’ own experience and patients’ preferences were the main influences on nurses’ practice. Published research had relatively little impact, particularly among nurses graded E, F and G and those who had not attended a study day on EBP. Conclusions  The hierarchies of evidence propounded in local and national guidelines are not adopted by practising nurses, who use other sources of evidence, such as reflection on their own experiences, when making clinical decisions. However, subsuming published evidence to clinical judgement does not contradict the original tenets of EBP. Implications for Nursing Management  Unless it is incorporated into national or local guidelines, research has relatively little impact on practice. To develop nursing practice and nursing knowledge, nurse leaders need to foster the synthesis of experiential knowledge and published research, in accordance with the founding principles of the EBP movement.
  • References (33)
  • Citations (53)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
293 Citations
203 Citations
297 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Shirley ReynoldsH-Index: 34
#2E TrinderH-Index: 1
List of Contributors. 1 Introduction: The Context of Evidence--Based Practice.(Liz Trinder). 2 The Anatomy of Evidence--Based Practice: Principles and Methods.(Shirley Reynolds). 3 Evidence--Based Practice in General Practice and primary care. (Toby Lipman). 4 Evidence--Based Practice in Mental Health. (John Geddes). 5 Evidence--Based Public Health.(J.A. Muir Gray). 6 Evidence--Based Nursing Practice. (Richard Blomfield and Sally Harding). 7 Evidence--Based Practice in Social Work and Probation....
183 Citations
#1Sinead Brophy (Swansea University)H-Index: 31
#2Helen Davies (Swansea University)H-Index: 9
Last. Rhys Williams (Swansea University)H-Index: 23
view all 5 authors...
Background Latent autoimmune diabetes in adults (LADA) is a slowly developing type 1 diabetes. Objectives To compare interventions used for LADA. Search methods Studies were obtained from searches of electronic databases, supplemented by handsearches, conference proceedings and consultation with experts. Date of last search was December 2010. Selection criteria Randomised controlled trials (RCT) and controlled clinical trials (CCT) evaluating interventions for LADA or type 2 diabetes with antibo...
8,284 CitationsSource
#1Wolfgang Greiner (Bielefeld University)H-Index: 29
Da im Gesundheitswesen die Ressourcen begrenzt sind, mussen auf verschiedenen Ebenen Entscheidungen daruber getroffen werden, welche Guter und Dienstleistungen in welcher Qualitat und Beschaffenheit zu welchem Zeitpunkt fur welche Patienten und andere Konsumenten bereitgestellt werden sollen. Je nach Organisationstyp des jeweiligen Gesundheitssystems erfolgt die Entscheidungsfindung auf dezentraler Ebene (z. B. die Medikamentenlistung eines Krankenhauses), regionaler Ebene (z. B. der Abschluss r...
462 CitationsSource
#1Philip Edwards (Lond: University of London)H-Index: 12
#2Ian Roberts Mbbch (Lond: University of London)H-Index: 82
Last. Richard S. Cooper (Lond: University of London)H-Index: 108
view all 8 authors...
Background Postal questionnaires are widely used for data collection in epidemiological studies but non-response reduces the effective sample size and can introduce bias. Finding ways to increase response rates to postal questionnaires would improve the quality of health research. Objectives To identify effective strategies to increase response rates to postal questionnaires. Search strategy We aimed to find all randomised controlled trials of strategies to increase response rates to postal ques...
304 CitationsSource
#1Don A. DillmanH-Index: 44
Preface to the 2007 Update.Preface to the Second Edition.Acknowledgments.Part One: ELEMENTS OF THE TAILORED DESIGN METHOD.1 Introduction to Tailored Design.2 Writing Questions.3 Constructing the Questionnaire.4 Survey Implementation.5 Reduction of Coverage and Sampling Errors.Part Two: TAILORING TO THE SURVEY SITUATION.6 Mixed-Mode Surveys.7 Alternative Questionnaire Delivery: In Person, to Groups, and through Publications.8 When Timing Is Critical: Diary, Customer Satisfaction, and Election For...
8,774 Citations
2 CitationsSource
#1Gary Rolfe (Swansea University)H-Index: 22
#2Lyn Gardner (Swansea University)H-Index: 8
We begin this paper with a consideration of the significance of a historical perspective in presentations of evidence-based practice in the nursing and medical literature. We suggest that whereas writers often produce coherent historical narratives as justification for particular views of the nature of EBP, an examination of its origins reveals no such signs of historical development or progress in our conception or understanding of it. We then explore alternative modes of thought for attempting...
38 CitationsSource
Aims. This paper reports an analysis of recruitment and response rates in published nursing research in three peer reviewed nursing journals in 2002. We wished to establish if the deficits in reporting nursing research identified a decade earlier had been addressed. Background. This analysis was informed by our personal experiences of research which produced widely differing response rates. An examination of the literature revealed a lack of consensus on desirable response rates in nursing resea...
63 CitationsSource
#1Emanuela SalaH-Index: 13
#2Peter LynnH-Index: 26
Many studies of data collection processes for business surveys focus on issues related to how to increase response rates and how to reduce response burden. Additionally, some have focussed on measurement error. Issues related to non response bias, on the other hand, do not seem to be explicitly part of the research agenda. The main reason why researchers should be concerned about non response is the potential for it to introduce bias. Our paper compares two alternative survey designs in terms of...
2 Citations
14 Citations
Cited By53
1 CitationsSource
Abstract Purpose To describe knowledge, values, and implementation of evidence-based practice (EBP) and use of two National Patient Safety Goals–Central Line Associated Blood Stream Infections (CLABSI) and Surgical Site Infections (SSI)–between nurses working in Magnet® versus non-Magnet® designated hospitals. Background There is a gap in the literature concerning nurses' understanding of EBP and how EBP guidelines are used in practice and if guidelines are being used as intended. The Conceptual...
2 CitationsSource
#1Rachael Spencer (University of Nottingham)H-Index: 6
#2Onje Yuill (University of Nottingham)H-Index: 1
Clinical midwifery skills and understanding are continually changing in line with research evidence and service innovations. Evidence-based midwifery practice is essential to ensuring that the care provided to childbearing women is safe, effective and of the best quality to meet their individual needs. To deliver woman-centred care, evidence from research should be considered in conjunction with clinical experience and women's own preferences. One of the challenges for Higher Education Instituti...
#1David MercerH-Index: 1
#2Maria FlynnH-Index: 1
2 CitationsSource
#1Linda Connor (Boston Children's Hospital)H-Index: 15
#2Fiona Paul (Boston Children's Hospital)H-Index: 3
Last. Sonja ZinielH-Index: 15
view all 4 authors...
Background The Quick-EBP-VIK is a new instrument for measuring nurses’ value, implementation, and knowledge of EBP. Psychometric testing was conducted in two parts. Part 1 describes the tool development and validity testing which resulted in the development of a 25-item survey after receiving ≥0.80 Item-Level Content Validity Index for both clarity and relevance. Part 2 describes psychometric testing was necessary to assess additional types of validity and reliability. Aim The purpose of this pa...
3 CitationsSource
#1Hannele Saunders (University of Eastern Finland)H-Index: 4
#2Katri Vehviläinen-Julkunen (University of Eastern Finland)H-Index: 32
4 CitationsSource
#1Mph Hannele Saunders Rn (University of Eastern Finland)H-Index: 1
#2Katri Vehviläinen-Julkunen Rn, PhD, Lic Hc, MSc, Feans (University of Eastern Finland)H-Index: 1
Background Although systematic implementation of evidence-based practice (EBP) is essential to effectively improve patient outcomes, quality, and value of care, nurses do not consistently use evidence in practice. Uptake is hampered by lack of nurses’ readiness for EBP, including nurses’ EBP beliefs and lack of EBP mentors. Favorable EBP beliefs are foundational to Registered Nurses’ (RNs) use and integration of best evidence into clinical decision making, whereas EBP mentors are in a key role f...
3 CitationsSource
An evidence-based practice (EBP) education project was developed and implemented to create a preadmission clinic in the surgical services department of a small rural hospital. The project objectives were to (a) improve patient satisfaction, (b) reduce overtime hours in the same-day surgical area, and (c) increase the use of EBP. A literature review was first used to support the need for EBP education and to identify best practices. Next, an educational presentation on the development and impleme...
#1Jun-Qiang Zhao (Beijing University of Chinese Medicine)H-Index: 1
#2Fen Zhou (Beijing University of Chinese Medicine)H-Index: 1
Last. Yu-Fang Hao (Beijing University of Chinese Medicine)H-Index: 2
view all 6 authors...
Abstract Background Traditional Chinese medicine nursing (TCM nursing) is one of the highlights of nursing profession in China, which plays a significant role in Chinese healthcare system. However, bottlenecks exist in TCM nursing development. It’s necessary to explore the discipline connotation and advantages of TCM nursing in nursing education and clinical practice and introduce modern nursing concepts. Methods We analysis the connotations of TCM nursing, the bottlenecks it faces, and strategi...
1 CitationsSource