Political scientists on the functions of personal pronouns in their writing: An interview-based study of ‘I’ and ‘we’

Published on Jan 26, 2007in Text & Talk0.4
· DOI :10.1515/TEXT.2007.002
Nigel Harwood17
Estimated H-index: 17
In contrast to the numerous corpus-based studies of pronouns in academic writing, this paper uses qualitative interviews in an attempt to account for academic writers' motivations for using the pronouns ‘I’ and ‘we’ and to describe the textual effects that each case of ‘I’ and ‘we’ helps to create. Five political scientists took part in the research, commenting upon their pronoun use in one of their own journal articles and also in the other informants' texts. Seven textual effects that ‘I’ and ‘we’ help to construct are identified and described. ‘I’ and ‘we’ are said to help (i) make the readership feel included and involved in the writers' argument; (ii) make the text more accessible; (iii) convey a tentative tone and hedge writers' claims; (iv) explicate the writers' logic or method regarding their arguments or procedures; (v) signal writers' intentions and arguments; (vi) indicate the contribution and newsworthiness of the research; and (vii) allow the writer to inject a personal tenor into the text. The insights and implications of the study are discussed and the paper closes by proposing that similar interview-based studies could be used for pedagogical purposes in English for academic purposes (EAP) contexts.
  • References (48)
  • Citations (17)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
39 Citations
159 Citations
198 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Nigel Harwood (University of Essex)H-Index: 17
39 CitationsSource
#1Theresa Lillis (OU: Open University)H-Index: 20
#2Mary Jane Curry (UR: University of Rochester)H-Index: 11
Scholars around the world are under increasing pressure to publish their research in the medium of English. However, little empirical research has explored how the global premium of English influences the academic text production of scholars working outside of English-speaking countries. This article draws on a longitudinal text-oriented ethnographic study of psychology scholars in Hungary, Slovakia, Spain and Portugal to follow the trajectories of texts from local research and writing contexts ...
213 CitationsSource
159 CitationsSource
#1Nigel Harwood (University of Essex)H-Index: 17
Abstract This paper is a qualitative corpus-based study of how academic writers can use the personal pronouns I and we to help to create a self-promotional tenor in their prose. Using a corpus comprising journal research articles (RAs) from the fields of Business & Management, Computing Science, Economics, and Physics, I present data extracts which reveal how I and we can publicize the writer and their work even though the pronouns are ostensibly helping to perform other functions, such as creat...
112 CitationsSource
Abstract This paper is a corpus-based study of how native speaker computing students and experts use the pronoun I when elaborating their methodology (‘methodological I ’). Using two corpora, (i) a student corpus of about 62,000 words of postgraduate computing project reports, written at the end of the MSc programme and roughly equivalent to the master’s dissertation; and (ii) an expert corpus of about 88,000 words of computing articles taken from prestigious journals, a quantitative analysis of...
41 CitationsSource
#1Mary Jane Curry (UR: University of Rochester)H-Index: 11
#2Theresa Lillis (OU: Open University)H-Index: 20
This article examines how multilingual scholars who work outside English-speaking countries negotiate the demand to publish in English alongside their broader academic and publishing interests. Based on our ethnographic study of the academic writing and publishing practices of 16 psychology scholars in Hungary, Slovakia, and Spain, we characterize the range of communities for whom the scholars are writing, drawing on notions of discourse community, community of practice, and speech community. We...
193 CitationsSource
Metadiscourse is self-reflective linguistic material referring to the evolving text and to the writer and imagined reader of that text. It is based on a view of writing as social engagement and in academic contexts reveals the ways that writers project themselves into their discourse to signal their attitude towards both the propositional content and the audience of the text. Despite considerable interest in metadiscourse by teachers and applied linguists, however, it has failed to achieve its e...
439 CitationsSource
#1Madeline Haggan (Kuniv: Kuwait University)H-Index: 4
Although it is a very small part of the research paper, the title plays an important role as the first point of contact between writer and potential reader and may decide whether or not the paper is read. Research paper titles in the widely differing fields of science, literature and linguistics are studied in detail with a view to showing what researchers from each discipline implicitly feel are important features in the succinct knowledge transmission required in title design. Three basic type...
74 CitationsSource
6,539 CitationsSource
#1Anna De Fina (Georgetown University)H-Index: 21
This volume presents both an analysis of how identities are built, represented and negotiated in narrative, as well as a theoretical reflection on the links between narrative discourse and identity construction. The data for the book are Mexican immigrants' personal experience narratives and chronicles of their border crossings into the United States. Embracing a view of identity as a construct firmly grounded in discourse and interaction, the author examines and illustrates the multiple threads...
198 Citations
Cited By17
#1Hanna Skorczynska (Polytechnic University of Valencia)H-Index: 3
Abstract This study looks into the meta-pragmatics of e-releases by providing corpus-based data on variations in the use of first-person references in e-releases from two oil companies: BP and Repsol. Previous research on corporate press releases had approached this particular feature (Jacobs, 1999a, 1999b), but no further attempts have been made to look into their usage in press releases published on corporate websites of different organizations. Two corpora of nearly 100,000 tokens have been e...
#1Jolanta Šinkūnienė (Vilnius University)H-Index: 2
1 CitationsSource
#1Lisa McGrath (SHU: Sheffield Hallam University)H-Index: 6
Abstract The aim of this study was to investigate the deployment of self-mentions in 18 history and 18 anthropology published research articles. ‘I’ was used more frequently in the anthropology articles than in history articles, a finding that can be traced to the knowledge-making practices of the disciplines. However, considerable intra-disciplinary variation was also observed, both in terms of frequency of self-mentions per article and the author roles adopted via the use of the first-person s...
8 CitationsSource
#1Guangwei Hu (NIE: National Institute of Education)H-Index: 24
#2Feng Cao (NUS: National University of Singapore)H-Index: 3
This is the final draft, after peer-review, of a manuscript published in English for Specific Purposes. The published version is available online at
21 CitationsSource
#1Lisa McGrathH-Index: 6
Scholars globally are under increasing pressure to publish in international, highly-ranked, and usually English-language journals. This has created a need for insights into the evolving discourses, ...
1 Citations
#1Mónica Chávez Muñoz (PolyU: Hong Kong Polytechnic University)H-Index: 1
Intercommunication among the members of academic discourse communities is usually achieved through certain defined genres that aim to achieve the community’s goals. As a result, language analysts have focused their attention on how scientists from different fields manipulate their readership by using personal pronouns and persuade the reader of their claims. This study analyses the use of inclusive and exclusive pronominal signals in English and Spanish research articles and investigates whether...
#1Sylvain Dieltjens (Katholieke Universiteit Leuven)H-Index: 2
#2Priscilla Heynderickx (Katholieke Universiteit Leuven)H-Index: 2
The we-form has been analyzed in different theoretical frameworks and domains. Researchers point to the complexity of first person plural pronouns: not only can they refer to different participants in a communicative situation, but they can also be used to avoid other referential forms. In organizational discourse, however, transparency is of the utmost importance to ensure efficient communication. Based on the minute analysis of 3700 we-forms in a corpus of internal communications documents, we...
2 CitationsSource
The study of interactive features of language has been a very productive source of insights into written discourse in recent years, revealing the ways that writers engage with readers to successfully persuade them of a particular viewpoint in a range of different genres and contexts. While a variety of approaches have illuminated our understanding of these features, the concept of interactional metadiscourse has been particularly valuable in revealing how writers project themselves into their di...
10 CitationsSource