Match!

HUMBLE SERVANTS OF THE DISCIPLINE? SELF-MENTION IN RESEARCH ARTICLES

Published on Jan 1, 2001in English for Specific Purposes
· DOI :10.1016/S0889-4906(00)00012-0
Ken Hyland60
Estimated H-index: 60
(CityU: City University of Hong Kong)
Sources
Abstract
In this paper, I examine the view that research writing is a modest, self-effacing task which involves authors eradicating themselves from their texts to gain acceptance for their work. Conflicting advice in textbooks and style guides, and the apparently diverse conventions of different disciplines, mean that the extent to which writers can explicitly intrude into their discourse is highly problematic for students, teachers, and experienced writers alike. However, the choices which express writer presence are also closely associated with authorial identity and authority and these not only affect the ideational meaning that writers convey, but also influence the impression they make on their readers. Self-mention is therefore a powerful rhetorical strategy for emphasising a writer’s contribution. Here I focus on the use of self-citation and exclusive first person pronouns in a corpus of 240 research articles in eight disciplines. Through an analysis of these texts and interviews with expert informants I seek to reveal something of how self-mention is used and perceived as a way of understanding more about writing in the disciplines and about the kinds of options available to students.
  • References (40)
  • Citations (342)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
112 Citations
198 Citations
497 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
References40
Newest
#1Norman FaircloughH-Index: 42
List of contributors Acknowledgements 1. Introduction, Norman Fairclough Part I: Language Awareness: Critical and Non-critical Approaches 2. The appropriacy of 'appropriateness', Norman Fairclough Part II: Critical Language Awareness in Diverse Educational Contexts 3. Critical literacy awareness in the EFL classroom, Catherine Wallace 4. Making it work - communication skills training at a black housing association, Pete Sayers 5. Principles and practice of CLA in the classroom, Romy Clark 6. Who...
663 Citations
#1Ken Hyland (Iowa State University)H-Index: 60
Why do engineers "report" while philosophers "argue" and biologists "describe"? In the Michigan Classics Edition of "Disciplinary Discourses: Social Interactions in Academic" "Writing," Ken Hyland examines the relationships between the cultures of academic communities and their unique discourses. Drawing on discourse analysis, corpus linguistics, and the voices of professional insiders, Ken Hyland explores how academics use language to organize their professional lives, carry out intellectual ta...
1,136 Citations
Abstract This paper presents an empirical study of personal pronouns in scientific journal articles. Viewing written text as interaction, this study investigates how the use of personal pronouns may reveal writers perceptions of their own role in research and their relationship with expected readers as well as the scientific-academic community. First-person plural pronouns are used far more frequently than other types of personal pronouns. A further analysis of first-person plural pronouns sugge...
205 CitationsSource
#2Ken HylandH-Index: 60
The contributors to this volume are: Robert J. Barrett Vijay K. Bhatia Christopher N. Candlin Yu-Ying Chang Sandra Gollin Ken Hyland Roz Ivanic Mary R. Lea Ian G. Malcolm John Milton Greg Myers Guenter A. Plum Brian Street John M. Swales Sue Weldon Patricia Wright
165 Citations
#1James D. LesterH-Index: 3
46 Citations
#1Ken Hyland (CityU: City University of Hong Kong)H-Index: 60
This book provides a comprehensive study of hedging in academic research papers, relating a systematic analysis of forms to a pragmatic explanation for their use. Based on a detailed examination of journal articles and interviews with research scientists, the study shows that the extensive use of possibility and tentativeness in research writing is intimately connected to the social and institutional practices of academic communities and is at the heart of how knowledge comes to be socially accr...
526 Citations
#1Roz Ivanic (Lancaster University)H-Index: 17
Writing is not just about conveying ‘content’ but also about the representation of self. (One of the reasons people find writing difficult is that they do not feel comfortable with the ‘me’ they are portraying in their writing. Academic writing in particular often poses a conflict of identity for students in higher education, because the ‘self’ which is inscribed in academic discourse feels alien to them.) The main claim of this book is that writing is an act of identity in which people align th...
979 Citations
#1Ann M. JohnsH-Index: 23
1. Literacy and pedagogy: three views 2. Genre knowledge and socioliteracies: what readers and writers may share 3. Genres and social forces: homely and academic texts 4. Discourse communities/communities of practice: membership, conflict and diversity 5. Our special roles: literacy practitioners as campus mediators and researchers 6. Students as researchers: investigating texts, processes and contexts 7. The socioliterate classroom: basic tenets and goals 8. Putting tenets and goals into practi...
450 Citations
Abstract International postgraduates in the humanities and social sciences face particular challenges in writing English language theses, and in my experience often express these challenges negatively despite all the helpful explanations which they receive about our practices and conventions. A significant cause of difficulty may lie in the different epistemologies in which these students have been trained and in which their identities as learners are rooted. In this paper I explore this issue o...
98 CitationsSource
#1Ken Hyland (CityU: City University of Hong Kong)H-Index: 60
Hedging is a well-documented feature of spoken discourse as a result of its role in qualifying categorical commitment and facilitating discussion. Its use in academic writing has received less attention, however, and we know little about the functions it serves in different research fields and particular genres. Hedging is a significant communicative resource for academics since it both confirms the individual's professional persona and represents a critical element in the rhetorical means of ga...
354 CitationsSource
Cited By342
Newest
Source
#1Mohsen Khedri (UCY: University of Cyprus)
#2Konstantinos Kritsis (UCY: University of Cyprus)
This study examined the use of personal (exclusive first-person plural pronouns) and impersonal (abstract rhetors, periphrastic passives and it-clauses) authorial references in a corpus of 160 rese...
Source
#1Razieh Gholaminejad (Shahid Beheshti University)H-Index: 1
#2Mohammad Reza Anani Sarab (Shahid Beheshti University)H-Index: 2
Source
#1Rong Chen (CSUSB: California State University, San Bernardino)
Abstract Chen and Yang (forthcoming) find that, in published work, authors of academic writing in English (AWE) in the area of language studies predominantly use the 1st-person singular, I, to refer to themselves as single authors in their publications. Authors of academic writing in Chinese (AWC), however, largely avoid the 1st-person singular pronoun for single author self-reference. Based on interview data and available literature, we propose that the avoidance of the 1st-person singular by A...
Source
#1Cindy S.B. Ngai (PolyU: Hong Kong Polytechnic University)H-Index: 3
#2Rita Gill Singh (Hong Kong Baptist University)H-Index: 2
Research article abstracts often convince readers that the article is worth reading. Therefore, they rely not only on the quality of arguments or novelty of findings to persuade readers but also linguistic markers in the form of metadiscourse to assert a position on an issue, increase readability of a text, engage readers, and avoid objection to the writer's interpretations, thereby enhancing the credibility of the text. Given that research article abstracts are often published online and their ...
Source
#1Chia-Yen Lin (YZU: Yuan Ze University)H-Index: 2
Abstract This corpus-based study uses quantitative and qualitative methods to analyze pragmatic force modifiers (PFMs) in seven English-medium Master's thesis defenses from four Taiwan universities. The study reveals a broad distribution of modifiers in the defense corpus, which adds to the research on the commonality of linguistic features in various academic genres and implies that academic discourse norms play a greater role than linguistic/cultural conventions in their widespread prevalence....
Source
#1Yasir Bdaiwi Jasim Al-Shujairi (UPM: Universiti Putra Malaysia)H-Index: 1
ABSTRACTTraditionally, academic writing has been considered impersonal and objective. However, the use of first-person pronouns can have value when used as a rhetorical strategy that promotes a researcher’s claims. This study attempted to identify self-mention markers (e.g. ‘I’, ‘we’, ‘the author’, ‘the researcher’) in sections of various published research articles (RAs). A comparison was made between Institute for Scientific Information (ISI) and Iraqi local RAs regarding use of literary devic...
Source
Drawing on my 2018 and the current study’s findings, this paper aims to explore how second language (L2), tertiary-level students create their authorial identities by considering the dialogic nature of their textual argumentation. The approach adopted avoids the polarised conceptualization of notions of agency and structure with regards to writer identity which creates a dichotomy between content and rhetoric. I argue that the identity of an academic writer is comprised of the various, mutually ...
Source
#1Elvan Eda Işık-Taş (Middle East Technical University Northern Cyprus Campus)H-Index: 1
The statement of purpose (SoP), as a promotional genre, aims to convince the readers that the candidate is suitable for studying in the applied graduate program. Thus, establishing a discourse identity that fits the expectations of the target disciplinary community is central in SoP writing. I conducted this study with 41 students and 12 academics in the field of Psychology. I used the appraisal framework (Martin & White, 2005) to identify the type and discourse functions of the evaluative devic...
Source
#1Hanna Skorczynska (Polytechnic University of Valencia)H-Index: 4
Abstract This study looks into the meta-pragmatics of e-releases by providing corpus-based data on variations in the use of first-person references in e-releases from two oil companies: BP and Repsol. Previous research on corporate press releases had approached this particular feature (Jacobs, 1999a, 1999b), but no further attempts have been made to look into their usage in press releases published on corporate websites of different organizations. Two corpora of nearly 100,000 tokens have been e...
Source