A global politics of pity? Disaster imagery and the emotional construction of solidarity after the 2004 Asian Tsunami

Published on Mar 1, 2014in International Political Sociology1.958
· DOI :10.1111/ips.12037
Emma Hutchison9
Estimated H-index: 9
(UQ: University of Queensland)
The study of emotion has become a steadily growing field in international relations and international political sociology. This essay adds to the field through a further empirical examination of the political roles emotions can play. Specifically, the essay questions how emotions were implicated in the construction of transnational solidarity—and the associated humanitarian actions—following an event of pivotal global importance: the Asian tsunami disaster of December 2004. To this end, I focus on the emotional dimensions of dominant media tsunami imagery and examine how emotions helped to produce the humanitarian meanings and ideologies on which the subsequent solidarity and humanitarian actions were based. Analyzing photographs in the New York Times, the essay demonstrates that the dominant tsunami imagery helped to evoke solidarity and garner aid. It did so, at least in part, through mobilizing stereotypical and deeply colonial representations of developing world disaster that are suggestive of a “politics of pity.” In this way, the essay contributes both an empirical study of emotions in world politics and an examination of the linkages between emotions and contemporary humanitarianism.
Figures & Tables
  • References (54)
  • Citations (36)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
167 Citations
63 Citations
60 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Lilie Chouliaraki (LSE: London School of Economics and Political Science)H-Index: 23
In this article, I engage with humanitarian celebrity as a communicative structure that historically articulates various discourses of solidarity. Specifically, I approach this communicative structure as a theater of pity that, by circulating images and stories about suffering, proposes dispositions of emotion and action to the West. Whereas, I argue, the traditional critique of celebrity humanitarianism challenges celebrity as spectacle that produces inauthentic aspirational discourse, my analy...
54 CitationsSource
#1Didier Bigo ('KCL': King's College London)H-Index: 24
This article demonstrates how the work of Pierre Bourdieu offers a productive way to practice research in international relations. It especially explores the alternatives opened by Bourdieu in terms of a logic of practice and practical sense that refuses an opposition between general theory and empirical research. Bourdieu's preference for a relational approach, which destabilizes the different versions of the opposition between structure and agency, avoids some of the traps commonly found in po...
121 CitationsSource
#1Michael BarnettH-Index: 31
#2Thomas G. WeissH-Index: 34
Introduction 1. Humanitarianism: The Essentials 2. 'Birth' and Maturation, 1864-1945 3. The Traditional Enterprise, 1945 - 1989 4. The Turbulent Post-Cold War Era: The New Humanitarianism? 5. Turbulent Humanitarianism Since 1989: Rhetoric Meets Reality 6. Humanitarianism's Past and Possible Futures: Ten Guiding Questions
31 Citations
#1Lucile Eznack (University of Geneva)H-Index: 1
Affect exists among close allies and influences their actions and reactions vis-a-vis each other. These countries’ perceptions of, and affective attachment to, the specialness of their relationships explains why, in certain circumstances, big clashes occur among them. In this sense, affect explains why crises among close allies are more signals of strength than weakness: the passionate nature of such crises—as opposed to more routine or recurrent disagreements—is triggered by the high value plac...
27 CitationsSource
#1Maja ZehfussH-Index: 20
Preface 1. Speaking of war and memory 2. Forgetting to remember? 3. Wounds of memory 4. The truth of memory 5. Times of memory 6. Memory, uncertainty, responsibility.
39 Citations
This study examines how power operates within international development discourse and investigates its effects on development organizations and on individuals—donors and recipients of aid alike. It analyzes the narratives pertaining to Afghanistan that are (re)produced by five different types of development actors: a donor state, a recipient state, an international financial institution, an international organization, and a non-governmental organization. I argue that the operation of multiple, i...
18 CitationsSource
Objects, including photographs, offer a significant aid to memory and how people process past events. Family photography and family photograph albums can be important tools for preserving memories and creating shared family narratives. However, some important family events may not be represented in family photographs. In my family, for instance, some of the most significant events that took place are not recorded in traditional family albums, but through images that appeared in newspapers. My gr...
3 CitationsSource
#1Brent E. Sasley (UTA: University of Texas at Arlington)H-Index: 5
Although the important role of emotions in decision-making has been highlighted in the psychology, neural science, and decision research literatures, this conclusion has not been widely adopted in foreign policy analysis and International Relations (IR). Of the work that has been done, much of it has been focused on public perceptions and the impact on foreign policy, but not on elites and the actual decisions of foreign policy. This article seeks to address this imbalance by examining the role ...
30 CitationsSource
#1Keith TesterH-Index: 10
22 Citations
#1Lilie Chouliaraki (LSE: London School of Economics and Political Science)H-Index: 23
This article offers a trajectory of humanitarian communication, which suggests a clear, though not linear, move from emotion-oriented to post-emotional styles of appealing. Drawing on empirical examples, the article demonstrates that the humanitarian sensibility that arises out of these emerging styles breaks with pity and privileges a short-term and low-intensity form of agency, which is no longer inspired by an intellectual agenda but momentarily engages us in practices of playful consumerism....
115 CitationsSource
Cited By36
Recent scholarship claims that narratives and images of war have political effects, not simply because of their content and ‘form’, but because of their affective and emotional ‘forces’. Yet, International Relations scholars rarely explore how audiences respond to narratives and images of war in their research. Addressing this gap, this paper combines discourse analysis of RT (formerly Russia Today) ‘breaking news’ YouTube videos of Russian military intervention in Syria with analysis of 750 com...
Studies into affective publics often involve textual communication. However, emotive communication is increasingly visual. This study zooms in on the representation of the suffering other in seven ...
#1Helen Berents (QUT: Queensland University of Technology)H-Index: 5
Images of suffering children have long been used to illustrate the violence and horror of conflict. In recent years it is images of dead children that have garnered attention from media audiences around the world. In response to the deaths of four children killed by the Israeli army while playing on a Gazan beach, Israeli Prime Minister Netenyahu accused Hamas of generating “telegenically dead” Palestinian children for their cause (CNN 2014). This term is engaged with by this article to consider...
1 CitationsSource
#1Thomas Olesen (AU: Aarhus University)H-Index: 10
This article argues that opinions on distant suffering must be understood via three variables: recipients of aid and sympathy; cause of suffering; and providers of aid and sympathy. These insights ...
#1David Hudson (University of Birmingham)H-Index: 16
#2N. Susan Laehn (University of Louisville)
Last. Jennifer vanHeerde-Hudson (UCL: University College London)H-Index: 5
view all 4 authors...
Objective In this article, we test whether emotions mediate the effect of international development appeals on cosmopolitanism and donation behavior. Methods We design and conduct a lab experiment to test the impact of representations of global poverty on participants’ cosmopolitan sentiments and their likelihood to donate to development charities. We use multiple mediation analysis to test the intervening role of six emotional responses—anger, guilt, solidarity, hope, repulsion, and pity—as cau...
#1Isabelle Desportes (EUR: Erasmus University Rotterdam)H-Index: 2
Little academic research has examined the challenges humanitarian actors face or the strategies they develop in the increasingly numerous authoritarian and low-intensity conflict settings. Based on 4 months of qualitative fieldwork in Myanmar in 2017–2018, this article explores how civil society organisations, international non-governmental organisations, international organisations, and donor agencies tried to provide relief to marginalised minorities in the ethnic States of Chin and Rakhine fo...
#1Isabelle Desportes (EUR: Erasmus University Rotterdam)H-Index: 2
#2Hone Mandefro (University of Gondar)H-Index: 2
Last. Dorothea Hilhorst (EUR: Erasmus University Rotterdam)H-Index: 18
view all 3 authors...
markdownabstractThis article aims to rekindle the debate on the politics of aid in the increasingly common – yet still under-studied – authoritarian and low-intensity conflict settings, detailing the case of Ethiopia in 2016, when a 50-year drought coincided with a wave of protests and a state of emergency. During four months of qualitative fieldwork in 2017, state, civil society, Ethiopian and international actors were approached – from humanitarian headquarters to communities in the Amhara, Or...
2 CitationsSource
Any reader who is interested in the rich and diverse relations between the visual, the political, and the global should look out for Roland Bleiker’s edited volume with the simple, yet programmatic title Visual Global Politics (VGP). In my review, I critically reflect the many virtues but also missed opportunities and suggest ways how this excellent edition could further develop as a living and creative project.
3 CitationsSource
#1Yansheng Mao (HEU: Harbin Engineering University)H-Index: 1
#2Xin Zhao (HIT: Harbin Institute of Technology)H-Index: 1
With the increasing popularity and accessibility of online healthcare service and the continuous development of interactive digital communication, online medical consultation is prevalent in contemporary China. As a new genre, online medical consultation deserves in-depth exploration from a non-English discursive perspective in order to better understand the pragmatic features of this genre. This will help to map out the harmonious rapport management between doctors and patients in online medica...