Match!

"I'm a Second-Language English Speaker": Negotiating Writer Identity and Authority in Sociology One

Published on Apr 2, 2002in Journal of Language Identity and Education0.736
· DOI :10.1207/S15327701JLIE0102_02
Sue Starfield12
Estimated H-index: 12
Source
Abstract
Student writing needs to be viewed in its insertion into a context defined by the existence of sociohistorically shaped, asymmetrical power relations. How novice student writers negotiate these complex political relationships and develop a sense of authority and identity in their academic essay writing has been underexplored in academic literacy research. In this article I examine the discursive production of success and failure through a discussion of 2 first-year sociology essays at a South African university. The successful student's ability to construct a powerful, authoritative textual and discoursal identity for himself, and his highly developed "textual" capital, are seen as factors in his success. Systemic functional grammar is used to demonstrate how he has recourse to the linguistic features of authority as he discursively negotiates success with his marker. The student who fails struggles to negotiate an authoritative self as author and, relying heavily on the words of recognized authorities in...
  • References (24)
  • Citations (65)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
1998
1 Author (Roz Ivanič)
960 Citations
453 Citations
174 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
References24
Newest
Acknowledgements 1. Introduction: An Overture PART I: DANCING A THEORETICAL STANCE 2. Discourses and Access: Dancers in the Wings 3. Plagiarism, "Originality" and Copyright: A Striptease 4. Plagiarism and Referencing Across Genres: Different moves to different tunes 5. The development of the student writer: from mimic to master PART II: A MULTIVOICED TEXT: THE CHORUS 6. Introduction to Part II 7. Plagiarism and referencing as communicated in a departmental handbook: a discourse analysis 8. The R...
137 Citations
#1Roz Ivanič (Lancaster University)H-Index: 16
960 Citations
#1Mary R. Lea (OU: Open University)H-Index: 20
#2Brian Street ('KCL': King's College London)H-Index: 31
ABSTRACT This article addresses the issue of student writing in higher education. It draws on the findings of an Economic and Social Research Council funded project which examined the contrasting expectations and interpretations of academic staff and students regarding undergraduate students' written assignments. It is suggested that the implicit models that have generally been used to understand student writing do not adequately take account of the importance of issues of identity and the insti...
1,095 CitationsSource
#1Romy ClarkH-Index: 6
#2Roz IvaničH-Index: 16
Writing matters: it plays a key role in the circulation of ideas in society and has a direct impact on the development of democracy. But only a few get to do the kind of writing that most influence this development. The Politics of Writing examines writing as a social practice. The authors draw on critical linguistics, cultural studies and literacy studies, as they explore and analyse: * the social context in which writing is embedded * the processes and practices of writing * the purposes of wr...
293 Citations
#1James Paul GeeH-Index: 57
INTRODUCTION CHAPTER 1: IDEOLOGY CHAPTER 2: MEANING CHAPTER 3: LITERACY CRISES CHAPTER 4: LITERACY AS SOCIAL CHAPTER 5: ORALITY AND LITERACY: THE GREAT DEVIDE CHAPTER 6: THE LITERACY MYTH AND THE HISTORY OF LITERACY CHAPTER 7: THE CAPACITIES OF LITERACY AND PAULO FREIRE CHAPTER 8: THE NEW LITERACY STUDIES CHAPTER 9: SOCIAL LANGUAGES, SITUATED MEANINGS, AND CULTURAL MODELS CHAPTER 10: CULTURAL MODELS/FIGURED WORLDS IN ACTION CHAPTER 11: DISCOURSE ANALYSIS CHAPTER 12: DISCOURSE ANALYSIS STORIES GO...
3,681 Citations
#1Alastair Pennycook (University of Melbourne)H-Index: 39
453 CitationsSource
n composition studies, most published discussions of student plagiarism proceed from the assumption that plagiarism occurs as a result of one of two possible motivations: an absence of ethics or an ignorance of citation conventions. Some students don't appreciate academic textual values and therefore deliberately submit work that is not their own; others don't understand academic citation conventions and therefore plagiarize inadvertently. Both of these are negative interpretations, postulating ...
269 CitationsSource
I was delighted to hear that the BMJ (British Medical Journal) had accepted an advertisement for the BMJ (Builders Merchants Journal). It confirmed a long held belief in the abomination of abbreviations and the arrogance of those who use them, expecting others to know what they are talking about. Over the years I have collected many examples with a similar potential for confusion. A simple case might be BP: …
1,272 CitationsSource
The concept of plagiarism, as used both in considerations of academic writing and in international negotiations over intellectual copyright, assumes a model of communication based on autonomous, rational, individuals who behave as originators of their own discourses. But studies of communication, beginning with Goffman's concepts of production format and footing - and also including the concepts of enactment, social role, face, politeness pragmatics, metaphors of self and communication, and inna...
137 CitationsSource
#1Suzanne EgginsH-Index: 9
This new edition of the best-selling An Introduction to Systemic Functional Linguistics explores the social semiotic approach to language most closely associated with the work of Michael Halliday and his colleagues. An approach which views language as a strategic, meaning-making resource, systemic linguistics focuses on the analysis of authentic, everyday texts, and asks both how people use language to make meanings, and how language itself is organized to enable those meanings to be made. The b...
1,209 Citations
Cited By65
Newest
#1Rong Chen (CSUSB: California State University, San Bernardino)
Abstract Chen and Yang (forthcoming) find that, in published work, authors of academic writing in English (AWE) in the area of language studies predominantly use the 1st-person singular, I, to refer to themselves as single authors in their publications. Authors of academic writing in Chinese (AWC), however, largely avoid the 1st-person singular pronoun for single author self-reference. Based on interview data and available literature, we propose that the avoidance of the 1st-person singular by A...
Source
ABSTRACTThis paper explores the trajectories of six young academics (early-stage researchers) currently active in the context of Swedish academia in two different fields: English Linguistics and Po...
Source
Source
#1Sue StarfieldH-Index: 12
Source
Abstract Translingualism has become increasingly popular as a construct that captures the fluid nature of language(s) and writers’ ability to strategically draw from nonstandard language varieties, a practice referred to as “code-meshing.” This critical review reassesses the merits of translingualism in the context of L2 writing. While translingualism has blurred traditional boundaries between L1 and L2 writing, it remains unclear whether and how multilingual students would benefit from translin...
2 CitationsSource
There has been much research conducted on second language writing. In addition, there exists a significant amount of studies conducted with African American student writers. However, the fields of Second Language Writing and Composition Studies rarely if ever dovetail in the research literature. The purpose of this article is to argue how English language learners and bidialectal (English as a second dialect) learners share similar learning experiences and how sociocultural theories of English l...
Source
#1Shih-Chieh Chien (National Taipei University of Business)H-Index: 1
The present study investigates Taiwanese college students’ perceptions of plagiarism. Specifically, this study seeks to explore how perceptive students pursuing higher education in Taiwan are in recognizing plagiaristic writing, in what terms they perceive source use in writing as appropriate and inappropriate, and view why plagiarism occurs. The study included 30 high- and 30 low-achieving students selected out of 396 students in English writing classes at a university in Taiwan. Drawing upon e...
5 CitationsSource
#1Marguerite van den Berg (UvA: University of Amsterdam)H-Index: 21
This chapter considers the next generation of urbanites as one entry point for entrepreneurial urban strategies. It investigates the way in which cities aiming to redefine themselves imagine future populations and how in these efforts they design social policies that explicitly and particularly target women as mothers. It develops the concept of urban regeneration: efforts to regenerate the city by either investing in the children (the next generation) of the current population or replacing the ...
Source
Although most writing centres maintain policies against providing grammar correction during writing tutorials, it is undeniable that students expect some level of grammar intervention there. Just how much students expect and receive is a matter of speculation. This article examines the grammar-correction issue by reporting on a survey of L1, L2, and Generation 1.5 (Gen 1.5) writing-centre attendees. Results reveal that while all groups expected grammar help, L2 students expected the most. In add...
1 CitationsSource