The Illusion of Leadership: Misattribution of Cause in Coordination Games

Published on Sep 1, 2001in Organization Science
· DOI :10.1287/orsc.12.5.582.10090
Roberto A. Weber27
Estimated H-index: 27
(CMU: Carnegie Mellon University),
Colin F. Camerer102
Estimated H-index: 102
+ 1 AuthorsMarc Knez9
Estimated H-index: 9
This paper reports the results of experiments which examine attributions of leadership quality. Subjects played an abstract coordination game which is like many organizational problems. Previous research showed that when larger groups play the game, they rarely coordinate on the Pareto-optimal (efficient) outcome, but small groups almost always coordinate on the efficient outcome. After two or three periods of playing the game, one subject who was randomly selected from among the participants to be the "leader" for the experiment was instructed to make a speech exhorting others to choose the efficient action. Based on previous studies, we predicted that small groups would succeed in achieving efficiency but that large groups would fail. Based on social psychological studies of the fundamental attribution error, we predicted that the subjects would underestimate the strength of the situational effect (group size) and attribute cause to personal traits of the leaders instead--leaders would be credited for the success of the small groups, and blamed for the failure of the large groups. This hypothesis proved true: Subjects attributed differences in outcomes between conditions to differences in the effectiveness of leaders. In a second experiment, subjects voted to replace the leaders more frequently in the large-group condition (at a small cost to themselves), showing that misattributions of leadership ability also affect actual behavior by subjects. Previous research has demonstrated a tendency to credit or blame leaders for unusual performance. The difference in our study is that subjects should be blaming a structural condition--the size of the group--but they blame the leaders instead. Thus, our experiment is the first to establish a mistaken illusion of leadership.
  • References (43)
  • Citations (162)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
1,002 Citations
5,646 Citations
197 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
James R. Meindl, Sanford B. Ehrlich, and Janet M. Dukerich This research is an attempt to explore and understand the prominence of the concept of leadership in our collective consciousness. In three archival studies, we examined the attention and interest in leadership as reflected in a variety of publications, in conjunction with national, industry, and firm variations in performance. In a series of experimental studies, we examined the effects of performance outcome levels on the strength of l...
1,042 CitationsSource
#1Roberto A. Weber (CMU: Carnegie Mellon University)H-Index: 27
#2Colin F. Camerer (California Institute of Technology)H-Index: 102
Last. Marc KnezH-Index: 9
view all 3 authors...
Previous studies have shown that simply knowing one player moves first can affect behavior in games, even when the first-mover's moves are known to be unobservable. This observation violates the game-theoretic principle that timing of unobserved moves is irrelevant, but is consistent with virtual observability, a theory of how timing can matter without the ability to observe actions. However, this previous research only shows that timing matters in games where knowledge that one player moved fir...
106 CitationsSource
#1Bruce Kogut (UPenn: University of Pennsylvania)H-Index: 48
#2Nalin Kulatilaka (BU: Boston University)H-Index: 24
Strategy research consists of a balance between positive and normative theory. Normative theories suggest particular heuristics, or cognitive representations, to find appropriate solutions. Heuristics permit faster solutions to real-time problems; they also suffer from the potential of negative transfer to inappropriate applications.The theory of real options provides the appropriate heuristic framing of competencies and exploratory search. A real options approach marries the theory of financial...
427 CitationsSource
Replication, a familiar phenomenon sometimes referred to as the "McDonalds approach," entails the creation and operation of a large number of similar outlets that deliver a product or perform a service. Companies pursuing this strategy are now active in over 60 industries. Although replicators are becoming one of the dominant organizational forms of our time, they have been neglected by scholars interested in organizations. As a result of this neglect, replication is typically conceptualized as ...
860 CitationsSource
#1Robert Gibbons (MIT: Massachusetts Institute of Technology)H-Index: 40
#2Leaf Van Boven (UBC: University of British Columbia)H-Index: 27
We examined a central assumption of recent theories: that social utility is contingent on impressions of other people. We manipulated participants’ impression of the other player in a prisoners’ dilemma. We then measured participants’ own preferences in the PD, their estimates of the other player’s preferences in the PD, their prediction of the other player’s move, and their own move.We hypothesized that the participants’ move would maximize their stated preferences, given their prediction of th...
12 CitationsSource
#1Michael L. TushmanH-Index: 69
#2P. MurmannH-Index: 1
8 Citations
#1Andrew Schotter (NYU: New York University)H-Index: 37
#2Avi Weiss (BIU: Bar-Ilan University)H-Index: 13
Last. Iñigo Zapater (Brown University)H-Index: 3
view all 3 authors...
Much of the debate surrounding ultimatum and dictatorship games centers around the question of fairness. Fairness, however, is not a concept that is devoid of context. What may be considered unfair when two people meet face to face or in a bilateral manner may be considered fair in a market context where economic survival is at stake. For example, it may be considered unfair in isolation to charge a high price for prescription drugs from people in need, but one’s opinion of such an act might cha...
84 CitationsSource
#1Gérard P. Cachon (Duke University)H-Index: 37
#2Colin F. Camerer (California Institute of Technology)H-Index: 102
We report experiments on how players select among multiple Pareto-ranked equilibria in a coordination game. Subjects initially choose inefficient equilibria. Charging a fee to play (which makes initial equilibria money-losing) creates coordination on better equilibria. When fees are optional, improved coordination is consistent with forward induction. But coordination improves even when subjects must pay the fee (forward induction does not apply). Subjects appear to use a "loss-avoidance" select...
213 CitationsSource
#1Simon P. AndersonH-Index: 39
#2Jacob K. GoereeH-Index: 39
Last. Charles A. HoltH-Index: 48
view all 3 authors...
12 Citations
#1Colin F. CamererH-Index: 102
#2Marc KnezH-Index: 9
Classic literature on organizations recognizes that the paramount function of an organization is the coordination of physical and human assets to produce a good or service (e.g., Barnard, 1938; Chisholm, 1989; Schein, 1985). Coordination in this early literature was defined broadly, as for example by Mooney (1947, p. 5): "Coordination therefore, is the orderly arrangement of group effort, to provide unity of action in the pursuit of a common purpose." Mooney argues further that coordination is t...
57 CitationsSource
Cited By162
#1Maoliang Ye (SU: Southern University and A&M College)H-Index: 3
#2Jie Zheng (THU: Tsinghua University)H-Index: 6
Last. Sam Asher (Johns Hopkins University)H-Index: 3
view all 4 authors...
We study how gradualism -- increasing required levels (“thresholds”) of contributions slowly over time rather than requiring a high level of contribution immediately -- affects individuals’ decisions to contribute to a public project. Using a laboratory binary choice minimum-effort coordination game, we randomly assign participants to three treatments: starting and continuing at a high threshold, starting at a low threshold but jumping to a high threshold after a few periods, and starting at a l...
4 CitationsSource
#1Michael Kosfeld (Goethe University Frankfurt)H-Index: 19
Abstract I discuss recent findings from behavioral economic experiments in the lab and in the field on the role of leaders in human cooperation. Three implications for leadership are derived, which are summarized under the notion CC strategy . Firstly, leaders need to trust to not demotivate the motivated. Secondly, leaders need to punish to motivate the non-motivated. Finally, leaders shall (and can) attract motivated types. The discussion is embedded in a more general attempt to promote and st...
5 CitationsSource
#1Nathan J. Hiller (FIU: Florida International University)H-Index: 9
#2Ronald F. Piccolo (UCF: University of Central Florida)H-Index: 19
Last. Stephen J. Zaccaro (GMU: George Mason University)H-Index: 42
view all 3 authors...
Abstract Separated by longstanding differences, mainstream leadership scholarship and economics have rarely conversed. In this paper, we contribute to the emerging conversation between the two fields by (1) summarizing how economic assumptions about leadership may broadly inform leadership scholarship, and (2) offering a framework for conceptualizing the economic context in which leaders operate. We argue that inclusion of economic context in models of leadership antecedents, processes and outco...
1 CitationsSource
#1Stephanie M. Rizio (VU: Victoria University, Australia)H-Index: 1
#2Ahmed Skali (RMIT: RMIT University)H-Index: 2
Abstract Supposedly well-intentioned dictators are often cited as drivers of economic growth. We examine this claim in a panel of 133 countries from 1858 to 2010. Using annual data on economic growth, political regimes, and political leaders, we document a robust asymmetric pattern: growth-positive autocrats (autocrats whose countries experience larger-than-average growth) are found only as frequently as would be predicted by chance. In contrast, growth-negative autocrats are found significantly...
#1Béatrice Boulu-Reshef (University of Orléans)H-Index: 4
#2Charles A. Holt (UVA: University of Virginia)H-Index: 48
Last. Melissa C. Thomas-Hunt (Airbnb)H-Index: 1
view all 4 authors...
Abstract Organizations often appoint leaders to foster cooperation. This paper studies the effect of leader communication on free-riding behavior using controlled and incentivized experiments. Leaders are asked to choose public messages from a set that induces a particular leadership style and to send them to subjects matched in groups to play a repeated, finite-horizon public good game. Using a between-subjects design, empowering and directive message sets are studied. Treatments are implemente...
1 CitationsSource
#1Joël Berger (University of Bern)H-Index: 5
#2Margit Osterloh (University of Basel)H-Index: 28
Last. Thomas Ehrmann (WWU: University of Münster)H-Index: 10
view all 4 authors...
Abstract Hubris is a tendency of leaders to hold an overly confident view of their own capabilities and to abuse power for their own selfish goals, sometimes with disastrous consequences for organizations. A major reason for hubris is the rigorous selection process leaders typically undergo. This study proposes a governance mechanism used successfully in history to tackle hubris: partly random selections, which combine competitive selections by competence with lotteries. A frequently voiced conc...
#1Sirio Lonati (UNIL: University of Lausanne)H-Index: 1
Abstract Why do we observe either participative or directive leadership in organizations? I test an evolutionary-informed theory suggesting that organizational leadership is currently less participative (i.e., close supervision, rare delegation) among societies that used intensive forms of agriculture in the past. Intensification caused increased social complexity and skewed power distribution, promoting the emergence of directive leaders and eventually shaping followers' preferences for and per...
#1M. Ghufran Ahmad (LUMS: Lahore University of Management Sciences)H-Index: 1
#2Christoph H. Loch (University of Cambridge)H-Index: 38
1 CitationsSource
#1Zhengguang Liu (BNU: Beijing Normal University)
#2Shruthi Venkatesh (CMC: Claremont McKenna College)
Last. Ronald E. Riggio (CMC: Claremont McKenna College)H-Index: 39
view all 4 authors...
Abstract Previous research has established leader development as an ongoing process across the entire lifespan. Experience, especially on-the-job experience, has been increasingly acknowledged as a needed condition for leader development. From a life span developmental perspective, however, individuals are exposed to a variety of critical experiences across their life course—from preschool, childhood, through adolescence, emerging adulthood, adulthood and well into late adulthood. These time per...
#1Brian R. Spisak (University of Otago)H-Index: 9
#2Paul van der Laken (Tilburg University)H-Index: 2
Last. Brian M. Doornenbal (VU: VU University Amsterdam)
view all 3 authors...
Abstract Using self-report personality data and 360-degree performance evaluations of 973 managers across various contexts, we investigated the leader trait paradigm using a range of machine learning methods. We found that a relatively simple linear ordinary least squares model incorporating direct effects of traits and context performed equally as well as our best performing complex machine learning alternatives (e.g., lasso and random forests) at predicting leader effectiveness under low-dimen...