Textual Appropriation and Citing Behaviors of University Undergraduates

Published on Feb 1, 2010in Applied Linguistics3.041
· DOI :10.1093/applin/amn045
Ling Shi17
Estimated H-index: 17
(UBC: University of British Columbia)
This article explores the citing behaviors of 16 undergraduates in a North American university. After completing a research paper for their disciplinary courses, each participating student was interviewed to identify in his/her writing words and ideas borrowed from source texts and to explain why and how the relevant texts were appropriated with or without citations. Analysis of students’ writing and comments illustrates how they relied on source texts for various aspects of their essays, some of which they believed required citations while some of which did not. Results showed that they tried to strike a balance between the need to cite published authors to gain credit for the scholarly quality of their writing and the desire to establish their own voice by limiting the extent to which they cited other texts. Some students also reported how they chose between quoting and paraphrasing (though the latter sometimes contained direct copying) on the basis of their ability to rephrase other's words and their understanding of the different roles played by the two. The study indicates the degree to which citational acts are discursive markings of learning and knowledge construction.
  • References (22)
  • Citations (83)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
172 Citations
279 Citations
453 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1Diane Pecorari (MDH: Mälardalen University College)H-Index: 12
As novice members of their academic discourse communities, postgraduates face the challenge of learning to write in ways which will be judged as appropriate by those communities. Two resources in this effort are students’ own observations of the features of published texts in their disciplines, and feedback on their texts from teachers and advisors. These resources depend, though, on the extent to which textual features can be observed. Swales [Swales, J. M. (1996). Occluded genres in the academ...
88 CitationsSource
The debate about what constitutes plagiarism and how it should be dealt with in the academy continues to gain momentum. The response from many higher education institutions is to channel ever-increasing amounts of resources into plagiarism detection technologies, rather than trying to ascertain why plagiarism might be occurring in the first place. In this article, drawing on a wide range of data from student assignments and interviews with staff and students, we argue that it would be preferable...
125 CitationsSource
172 CitationsSource
279 CitationsSource
Student writing needs to be viewed in its insertion into a context defined by the existence of sociohistorically shaped, asymmetrical power relations. How novice student writers negotiate these complex political relationships and develop a sense of authority and identity in their academic essay writing has been underexplored in academic literacy research. In this article I examine the discursive production of success and failure through a discussion of 2 first-year sociology essays at a South Af...
65 CitationsSource
#1Kathleen McCarthy Young (University of Pittsburgh)H-Index: 2
#2Gaea Leinhardt (University of Pittsburgh)H-Index: 36
Developing academic literacy involves learning valued content and rhetoric in a discipline. Within history, writing from primary documents to construct an evidenced interpretation of an issue requires students to transform both background and document knowledge, read and interpret historical documents, and manage discourse synthesis. The authors examine the potential of the Advanced Placement Document-Based Question as constructed and presented by an exemplary teacher to engage students in histo...
108 CitationsSource
174 CitationsSource
13 Citations
This study examines the reading and writing strategies of one student, Yuko, over a 3-year period and traces the process she went through to acquire college-level academic literacy in English, her second language. Multiple data sources included interviews with the student and two of her political science professors, classroom observations, and texts from 10 courses in three disciplines—including course materials and the student's writing, with instructors' comments. The investigation was enriche...
274 CitationsSource
#1Miguel Roig (St. John's University)H-Index: 14
In two studies undergraduate students were given an original paragraph and several rewritten versions of the paragraph, some of which were plagiarized (e.g., without a citation, superficially modified from the original) and some correctly paraphrased. Students were asked to determine whether each rewritten version had been plagiarized or correctly paraphrased. Approximately 74% of the students in both studies correctly identified the paraphrased versions. However, some of the plagiarized version...
115 CitationsSource
Cited By83
1 CitationsSource
#1Ali Akbar Khomeijani Farahani (UT: University of Tehran)H-Index: 5
#1Ali Akbar Khamijani Farahani (UT: University of Tehran)
Last. Robabeh Moshtaghi Zonouz (UT: University of Tehran)
view all 3 authors...
The current study follows complex dynamic systems theory (CDST) as a framework to report an almost uncharted research domain in second language acquisition; the dynamic interplay of writing complexity, accuracy, and fluency (CAF); and the language learning motivation (LLM) in a successful highly motivated EFL learner for whom LLM functioned as a control parameter in the process of language development. Both quantitative and holistic data were gathered from a number of sources—questionnaire, Engl...
#1María Sagrario Salaberri Ramiro (UAL: University of Almería)H-Index: 2
#2María del Mar Sánchez Pérez (UAL: University of Almería)H-Index: 2
#1Stephen M. Doolan (A&M-CC: Texas A&M University–Corpus Christi)H-Index: 2
AbstractTextual plagiarism is a serious violation of established academic protocols, but it requires considerable writing experience and care to avoid as well. Although student understanding of tex...
#1Martine Peters (UQO: Université du Québec en Outaouais)H-Index: 5
#2Alain Cadieux (UQO: Université du Québec en Outaouais)H-Index: 2
Max 150 words. If possible, please submit your abstract in both English and French. When writing an assignment, most students start by searching for information online, which they integrate in their writing and conclude by producing a bibliography for the sources used. They use their informational, writing and referencing skills to do this as well as refer to their plagiarism knowledge to make sure their text is exempt from plagiarism. In this paper, we examined which skills and knowledge studen...
Abstract It is widely believed source-use skills are among the most important academic literacy skills that students need to develop throughout their college years. Although there has been extensive discussion of the difficulties experienced by ESL/EFL students developing these skills, few studies have focused on instructional interventions designed specifically to build source-use skills. To the best of our knowledge, no intervention recorded in the literature has focused on both essential aspe...
#1Ismaeil Fazel (SFU: Simon Fraser University)H-Index: 1
Extant empirical literature on writing for scholarly publication has tended to predominantly focus on impediments facing English as an Additional Language (EAL) doctoral students (e.g., Ho in Journal of English for Academic Purposes 27: 1–13, 2017; Li in TESOL Quarterly 41: 55–79, 2007) in getting published. Little empirical research, except for Habibie (Research literacies and writing pedagogies for masters and doctoral writers. Brill Publishing, Leiden, Netherlands, pp. 51–67, 2016), has atten...
1 CitationsSource
#1Min Su (HIT: Harbin Institute of Technology)
#2Xin Ma (HIT: Harbin Institute of Technology)
Last. Xiaosong Rui (HIT: Harbin Institute of Technology)
view all 3 authors...
This article reports on a disciplinary study of Chinese university students' perceptions of and attitudes toward plagiarism in the context of Chinese educational background. A sample of 119 engineering undergraduates rated their (dis)agreement with 26 items using a five-point Likert scale. Qualitative and quantitative analyses revealed that Chinese engineering students tended to hold a much stronger stance against plagiarism than their foreign counterparts did. They were inclined to resort to ex...