The Archaeology of Research Practices: A Social Work Case

Published on Jan 1, 2015in Qualitative Inquiry1.795
· DOI :10.1177/1077800414542691
Ian Shaw25
Estimated H-index: 25
(Ebor: University of York)
From Foucault’s understanding of discursive forms, I suggest a hitherto little-recognized archival framework for understanding disparate but related objects, statements, and themes in social work research practices at Chicago in the third and fourth decades of the last century. Viewing these as surrounding and overhanging present practices, I detect from archival sources distinctions between methodology as professional model (research practices as taught), research practices as selective accountability and claims-making (reporting to funders), methodology as reported practice (monographs), and research practices in their relation to a vision for social service and reform. I suggest how the archive unsettles rhetorical ways of deploying visions for social work and applied research, and for the relationship between social work and sociology.
  • References (24)
  • Citations (8)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
1 Author (Tim May)
1,598 Citations
21 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1John S. Brekke (SC: University of Southern California)H-Index: 36
Social workers provide more social services to populations across the life span than any other human service profession, including psychiatry, nursing, and psychology. The scientific methodologies and the scientific knowledge relevant to social services have expanded dramatically in the last 30 years. Using the two indicators of the total number of journals and the impact factors of those journals, it would appear that social work’s contribution to that expanding scientific knowledge base has be...
93 CitationsSource
#1Ian Shaw (Ebor: University of York)H-Index: 25
A search of two major social work databases suggests that contemporary published social work research in the English language may have had very little to say about the engagement of social work and urban life. The focus of this paper is on the illumination that an early historical episode throws on the nature and implications of the affinity of social work research and urban life. Frederick Thrasher's iconic 1920s study of Chicago gangs enables us to illustrate three general claims. First, it pa...
10 CitationsSource
Herbert Blumer was a key figure in what came to be identified as the Chicago School of Sociology. He invented the term ‘symbolic interactionism’ as a label for a theoretical approach that derived primarily from the work of John Dewey, George Herbert Mead and Charles Cooley. But his most influential work was methodological in character, and he is generally viewed today as a prominent critic of positivism, and of the growing dominance of quantitative method within US sociology. While this picture ...
6 CitationsSource
#1Martin J. Packer (Duquesne University)H-Index: 16
Introduction Part I. The Objective Study of Subjectivity: 1. Paradigms of inquiry 2. The qualitative research interview 3. The analysis of qualitative research interviews 4. Hermeneutics and the project for a human science 5. Qualitative analysis reconsidered Part II. Ethnographic Fieldwork - the Focus on Constitution: 6. Calls for a new interpretive social science 7. The social construction of reality 8. Constitution as ontological 9. The crisis in ethnography 10. Studying ontological work Part...
158 Citations
#1Ian Shaw (Ebor: University of York)H-Index: 25
I revisit one of the iconic Chicago School studies, Clifford Shaw’s The Jack-Roller. A naive reading of Shaw’s book leaves the reader with a sense of having been inducted into a melange of what we now know as “sociology” and “social work,” but which to Shaw seems a coherent stance. I suggest that this is close to the heart of how things were, and not a temporary distortion in the distinct histories of sociology and social work. I develop and illustrate this argument through a hidden history of a...
13 CitationsSource
36 CitationsSource
#1Ian Shaw (Ebor: University of York)H-Index: 25
#2Hilary ArkseyH-Index: 15
Last. Audrey MullenderH-Index: 14
view all 3 authors...
There has been little interest until recently in the question of whether social work has the characteristics of an academic discipline. This article offers a synopsis of issues arising from a review of social work and social care research funded through the Social Care Institute for Excellence (SCIE). Following a brief scene setting, the first main section of the article gives a synopsis of the social work and social care community’s experience and judgements regarding their engagement with the ...
14 CitationsSource
Little is known about the changing techniques and technologies for the recording of unstructured interviews.This article traces the evolution of devices for recording what is said in unstructured interviews, and looks at the impact of technological change on the interview process.
40 CitationsSource
#1Andrew AbbottH-Index: 33
In this history of the Chicago School of Sociology, Andrew Abbott investigates central topics in the emergence of modern scholarship, paying special attention to "schools of science" and how such schools reproduce themselves over time. What are the preconditions from which schools arise? Do they exist as rigid rules or as flexible structures? How do they emerge from the day-to-day activities of academic life such as editing journals and writing papers? Abbott analyzes the shifts in social scient...
176 Citations
21 CitationsSource
Cited By8
#1Ian Shaw (Ebor: University of York)H-Index: 25
#1Ayana Halpern (HUJI: Hebrew University of Jerusalem)H-Index: 1
ABSTRACTThis article explores the interrelated affinity between social work, nationality and universal humanitarianism through the case study of professional interventions by Jewish social workers in Mandatory Palestine. Given the limited literature on these professionals and the significant contribution of women in particular, it focuses on Siddy Wronsky and other German Jewish immigrants whose pre-immigration international heritage has been relegated to the margins. The article examines the th...
#1Marcela Cornejo (UC: Pontifical Catholic University of Chile)H-Index: 10
#2Gabriela Rubilar (University of Chile)
Last. Pamela Zapata-Sepúlveda (University of Tarapacá)H-Index: 3
view all 3 authors...
Based on their research experiences, three female Chilean researchers from the capital city and the north of the country reflect on political trauma and violence, poverty and exclusion, and the processes underlying the mobility of Colombian women in Chile’s northern border. In all of these research areas, “the sensitive” not only becomes a research topic but also confronts both researchers and participants as the main characters of a particular and socially situated relationship. Through their r...
#1Lynelle Watts (ECU: Edith Cowan University)H-Index: 4
ABSTRACTReflective practice, reflexivity, and critical reflection are now widely accepted as important in contemporary social work practice. Despite this, there remain differences in how the terms ...
6 CitationsSource
#1Lynelle Watts (ECU: Edith Cowan University)H-Index: 4
#2David Hodgson (ECU: Edith Cowan University)H-Index: 4
Social work has had a long concern for people experiencing different forms of social injustice. This chapter sets out the history of social work debates about knowledge concerned with the shape of the discipline and profession of social work and then traces a history of practice responses that give social work its distinctive form. Despite changes in contemporary conditions, since its beginnings, social work continues to adapt its focus to challenge forms of injustice, disadvantage and social co...
#1Raymond M. Lee (RHUL: Royal Holloway, University of London)H-Index: 14
The paper examines the work of groups established by chapters of the American Association of Social Workers in the 1920s to develop a systematic and empirically based understanding of the interacti...
The current debate on social work research methods shares some of the features of a general ‘crisis in epistemology’ evident in many academic disciplines which in turn is related to unresolved issues concerning scientific knowledge production in modernity. Social work's own attempts to develop a research basis, as its entry into modernity, shows historically a polarisation between a leaning towards positivist models as well as an affirmation of the importance of reflecting on personhood and the ...
3 CitationsSource
#1Ian Frank Shaw (Ebor: University of York)H-Index: 6
Answers to the question just what is the ‘case’ partly defined the fields of sociology and social work in early 20th century Chicago. Drawing on the archives of the University of Chicago, I describe and appraise the way the ‘case’ figured in social work at Chicago and elsewhere. I ask the corresponding question of sociology. Finally, I briefly consider why not much came of social work and sociology ploughing similar territory in ways that served for a time to hallmark their identities. This anal...
3 CitationsSource
#1Ian Frank Shaw (AAU: Aalborg University)H-Index: 6
I argue that there is a submerged cluster of people who, at one or other stage of their careers, took positions in relation to social problems, social work practice, modes of understanding, and research practice that reflected and anticipated – knowingly or not – something we might call a Chicago-enriched sociological social work. They are Harriett Bartlett, Stuart Queen, Ada Sheffield, Erle Fisk Young and Pauline Young. Several of the themes that emerge from a review of their work are today, as...
2 CitationsSource