The Programme Approach to the Growth of Government

Published on Jan 1, 1985in British Journal of Political Science4.292
· DOI :10.1017/s000712340000404x
Richard Rose58
Estimated H-index: 58
In order to understand the dynamics of contemporary government, we must consider what government does as well as why it grows. This is true whether theories seek to explain past growth or are hypotheses about future developments. Political science has a unique responsibility to address this problem, because it is the discipline for which government is central. Whereas economists and sociologists can produce models that treat political change as epiphenomenal, political scientists must identify what it is that changes when government changes. In the I98os the size of government gives particular importance to its dynamics. Government is already big in the resources it commands, and in its impact upon society. By almost any measure, government has grown substantially bigger in aggregate in the past quarter-century. The current scale of government is a subject of substantial political debate: proponents of welfare-state measures attack government for not doing enough, and opponents attack it for doing too much. Ironically, the debate is most intense in the United States, which, by conventional measures, has a government that is below-average in size among OECD countries. This article proposes a distinctive approach to understanding the growth of government: the programme approach. The things that most visibly change in government are its programmes; disaggregating government into programmes is therefore a meaningful and necessary way to understand its dynamics. The first section reviews familiar approaches to the growth of government, and identifies deficiencies. The second section defines the programme approach, and how the activities of government can be differentiated by the size of their claims on resources. The third section demonstrates that programmes change at very different rates, and even in opposite directions. In the fourth section, the programme approach is shown as capable of resolving confusion caused by conflicting theories of causes of growth. The conclusion reviews the conjoint implications of the programme approach for understanding the swings and roundabouts of the growth of government in aggregate.
  • References (8)
  • Citations (34)
📖 Papers frequently viewed together
1 Author (Richard Rose)
60 Citations
63 Citations
1 Author (Peter Self)
2 Citations
78% of Scinapse members use related papers. After signing in, all features are FREE.
#1William Ascher (Johns Hopkins University)H-Index: 19
The nature and use of “complex” models for forecasting and policy simulation are analyzed on theoretical and empirical-performance grounds. The analysis suggests that while the accuracy of complex models in forecasting trends in such fields as economic and energy is, and will remain, undistinguished, complex models' special virtues of preserving counter-intuitive results and representing subsystem interdepedence could be used to better advantage than current practice permits. Suggestions for suc...
40 CitationsSource
#1Patrick D. Larkey (CMU: Carnegie Mellon University)H-Index: 11
#2Chandler Stolp (CMU: Carnegie Mellon University)H-Index: 1
Last. Mark Winer (UBC: University of British Columbia)H-Index: 1
view all 3 authors...
This paper surveys literature from several disciplines on how and why governments grow. The empirical question as to whether, or to what degree, government has grown is critically entwined with the nature of the ‘dependent variable’ chosen (federal government expenditures as a proportion of GNP, total real public expenditures, number of government employees as a percentage of the workforce, etc.). Specific approaches to the study of government growth considered include those associated with: Wag...
82 CitationsSource
#1Richard Rose (University of Strathclyde)H-Index: 58
Starting without any a priori assumption that government is necessarily a force for good or ill, this article examines what negative consequences are likely to arise from big government – or government growing bigger still. Three generic effects are postulated: a loss of effectiveness, because of the use of weaker means-ends programme technologies for new programmes; an increase in contradictions between existing, growing and new programmes; and a possible reduction of consent, insofar as growth...
14 CitationsSource
Political scientists have explored policy-making from many perspectives, e.g., demographic characteristics, constituency preferences, decision-makers' attitudes, the influence of career bureaucrats, and the input of interested and affected citizens. While the empirical evidence marshalled around each is often rich, seldom have two or more of the perspectives been systematically integrated. Richard Hofferbert's recently developed multivariate (six-stage) model of the public-policy process provide...
77 CitationsSource
In this article we identify incrementalism in budgetary processes with regularity in the annual change in the appropriation, and non-incrementalism with irregularity in the annual appropriation change. This definition focusses interest on structural changes in the underlying budget processes. These changes may be isolated using a combination of statistical and more conventional techniques. Other meanings of incremental, we argue, are appropriate to different objectives in studying budgeting. We ...
83 CitationsSource
86 CitationsSource
I. Postindustrial Society and Its Darker (?) Politics The concept of postindustrial society was advanced in the early 1960s by Daniel Bell as a model of society comparable to, but significantly different from, models of industrial and agrarian society. In the following decade, the concept was elaborated by Bell, reformulated by others, and relabeled by some.l While individual postindustrial society theorists stress different aspects of the concept, they would generally agree on the following as ...
98 CitationsSource
#1Richard RoseH-Index: 1
10 CitationsSource
Cited By34
ABSTRACTThis study examines the dynamics of the displacement effect. Using government expenditure data from 1972 to 2006, this study finds evidence of the displacement effect in government expenditures immediately following German reunification, along with changes in both the composition of government expenditures and funding allocation authority between local and federal governments. These findings suggest that social disturbances play a significant role in determining the functional compositio...
Agricultural financing has a wide and deep history in Nigeria, owing to the fact that the Nigerian economy has huge potentials for growth especially from its agriculture sector which is the second largest contributor to GDP. Since the establishment of the Agricultural Credit Guarantee Scheme over 30 years ago, the total sum of 647,351 loans amounting to over N34 billion have been disbursed to farmers as at 2009. The result from this study shows that the guarantee scheme has been effective in pro...
4 Citations
Summary Over the past decades, all affluent welfare states have been coping with two major new trends: population ageing and new social risks resulting from de-industrialization. How have these demand-side trends, and their timing, affected welfare spending? We investigate up to 21 OECD democracies with respect to eight separate programmes and two composite indicators of aggregate welfare spending bias towards the elderly and new social risks. We find that welfare regime logics still matter cruc...
54 CitationsSource
#1Markus Tepe (University of Oldenburg)H-Index: 13
#2Pieter Vanhuysse (University of Southern Denmark)H-Index: 15
Over the past few decades, all affluent democracies have been coping with two major new trends: population aging, and new social risks resulting from de-industrialization. How have these trends, and their timing, affected welfare spending within and between countries? We investigate up to 21 OECD democracies between 1980 and 2003 with respect to eight separate spending categories (old age pensions, incapacity benefits, survivors benefits, health spending, family spending, unemployment benefits, ...
7 CitationsSource
#1Pieter VanhuysseH-Index: 15
Since 1990 the age of the average OECD median voter has increased three times faster than in the preceding 30 years. We use panel data from 1980-2002 to investigate the effects of population aging on both the program size and the benefit generosity of public pensions in 18 OECD countries. Population aging is accompanied by cutting smaller slices out of larger cakes: it increases aggregate spending on pensions but freezes or decreases the generosity of individual benefits. Controlling for politic...
#1Markus Tepe (University of Oldenburg)H-Index: 13
#2Pieter Vanhuysse (University of Southern Denmark)H-Index: 15
In the fifteen years since 1990, the average OECD median voter age has increased three times faster than in the preceding thirty years. We use panel data covering the years 1980-2002 to investigate the effects of population aging on both the program size and the benefit generosity of public pensions in 18 OECD countries. Population aging appears to lead to the cutting of smaller slices out of larger cakes: it increases overall pension program spending but decreases the generosity of individual b...
21 Citations
#1Kevin A. UnterH-Index: 1
2 Citations
#1Gita Subrahmanyam (LSE: London School of Economics and Political Science)H-Index: 5
Abstract The concept of empire has undergone a revival in recent years in the context of debates over American power and hegemony in world politics. Authors such as Niall Ferguson and Deepak Lal have used the British Empire as an exemplar to demonstrate that empires can be benign, engendering social and economic development and enabling democracy. In this article, I argue that British imperialism, far from being benign, in most cases undermined colonial democratisation and development through it...
15 CitationsSource
#1Jeremy MoonH-Index: 39
A photosensitive image receiving sheet material employable for color proofing and color display which comprises a photopolymerizable adhesive layer provided on a support via a releasable organic high-molecular polymer layer.
92 Citations